Should football players move to different teams?

I'm not a big football person so I could be missing something here but from my perspective it makes no sense. People that I know that enjoy football support one team fiercely and are typically loyal to their team even if they aren't doing so well. So surely professional footballers would also support a specific team and be even more loyal to their team so it doesn't make sense to me why they would transfer to a different team for money. Doesn't this just defeat the purpose of supporting a team if you're just going for the money or perhaps you could potentially 'sabotage' another team if you are playing for one other than the one you support.

What do you think about this and can any avid football fans provide an explanation for this?

#HotTopics

Reply 1

feeble-radish

Original post

by agent_duck343

I'm not a big football person so I could be missing something here but from my perspective it makes no sense. People that I know that enjoy football support one team fiercely and are typically loyal to their team even if they aren't doing so well. So surely professional footballers would also support a specific team and be even more loyal to their team so it doesn't make sense to me why they would transfer to a different team for money. Doesn't this just defeat the purpose of supporting a team if you're just going for the money or perhaps you could potentially 'sabotage' another team if you are playing for one other than the one you support.
What do you think about this and can any avid football fans provide an explanation for this?
#HotTopics

I think most players move to teams in different countries to avoid clashes with teams in their home country like in the premier league, you’ll see often famous English players move to Bundesliga etc instead of moving to another premier league team to prove loyalty etc. I think most footballers are loyal to their teams in their respective leagues, it just becomes tricky with things like UEFA champions league where it’s European clubs. E.g Trent Alexander Arnold moved from Liverpool to Real Madrid but there is a real chance they could both play each other so the fans from Liverpool will probably heckle Trent a lot.

Anyways I feel like im getting off track but I guess it’s because players want to experience playing in different leagues and different countries, they’ll always have loyalty to their home teams but you can’t blame them for wanting something new once in a while. Football careers are like 15 years+ so staying in one team for that long is a feat. Also some teams will just loan players out regardless so some don’t have much of a choice if they didn’t negotiate before

Reply 2

StriderHort

"it doesn't make sense to me why they would transfer to a different team for money"

I think you're really underselling the Money here, captial M.😅 While the players are almost certainly fans in their own right they have different priorities and this is their time & health limited career and signing for even a lower league club can be a life changing amount of money for many, and it's not like leaving the club is always their choice. A player could be completely 'loyal' to their club but simply face unrealistic competition for regular games or struggle with a new managers tactics so will seek other opportunities to develop.

Reply 3

Geo Lover 7

Chat Forum Helper, Study Forum Helper

Original post

by agent_duck343

I'm not a big football person so I could be missing something here but from my perspective it makes no sense. People that I know that enjoy football support one team fiercely and are typically loyal to their team even if they aren't doing so well. So surely professional footballers would also support a specific team and be even more loyal to their team so it doesn't make sense to me why they would transfer to a different team for money. Doesn't this just defeat the purpose of supporting a team if you're just going for the money or perhaps you could potentially 'sabotage' another team if you are playing for one other than the one you support.
What do you think about this and can any avid football fans provide an explanation for this?
#HotTopics

I think that clubs shouldn't exist above the grassroots level.
I only watch the Euros and the World Cup (Men/women) for context.

Reply 4

agent_duck343

Original post

by StriderHort

"it doesn't make sense to me why they would transfer to a different team for money"
I think you're really underselling the Money here, captial M.😅 While the players are almost certainly fans in their own right they have different priorities and this is their time & health limited career and signing for even a lower league club can be a life changing amount of money for many, and it's not like leaving the club is always their choice. A player could be completely 'loyal' to their club but simply face unrealistic competition for regular games or struggle with a new managers tactics so will seek other opportunities to develop.

Well I get the importance of money but from what I've seen people I know would never switch to supporting another team and are extremely loyal so I just dont get why actually playing in a team would make you switch to another team

Reply 5

agent_duck343

Original post

by Geo Lover 7

I think that clubs shouldn't exist above the grassroots level.
I only watch the Euros and the World Cup (Men/women) for context.

Personally I think playing football and enjoying it is fine but watching it seems stupid to me.
The amount of money these players get paid seems unjustifiable for what they are doing

Reply 6

StriderHort

Original post

by agent_duck343

It's just not the same imo. It's easy to be a 'fanatical' fan, get the strips, season tickets, tattoo etc from a distance, you're never counting on the club for anything, it can never let you down in anything but a trivial way and never demands anything from you. A very different story if you work there and you rely on them for your home, athletic health, retirement etc. Likely the same for many companies as they aim for loyalty from both their customers and employees but it's always going to be different sort of relationship.

Remember an awful lot of football fans aren't that into it, they don't take support too seriously or even support several teams. Often this can be for the same essential reasons, people develop, people move, it's less common for people to spend their whole lives doing one thing with one group.

Reply 7

Kallisto

Entertainment Forum Helper, Life & Style Forum Helper

The most players move to different teams because of more money, closely followed by the second reason, to win as many as trophies in their career as possible. They became professionals for these two main reasons which are the main reasons for a move at the same time.

Reply 8

Zerforax

The fans are there to be loyal and support the club.

Reply 9

Dunnig Kruger

It's basic Human Rights!

Everyone has the right to work for whomever they want. If that employer is willing to offer them a job.

It would be totally evil if someone working for McDonalds were not allowed to start working for KFC instead. Or Rolls Royce. Or an Australian mining company...

The money is partially a wealth building thing and partially an ego thing. If you consider yourself a better player than someone earning £100,000 per week more than you, you'd be feeling that you were being treated unfairly, especially if they are playing at the same club as you.

Reply 10

ethenjames

I get why it seems weird, but for players, football is their career, not just a hobby. Transfers happen for better pay, more playtime, or bigger leagues. Unlike fans, most players don’t have lifelong loyalty to one team they’re trained to give their best no matter where they play.

Quick Reply

Related discussions

Latest

Trending

Articles for you

Personal Statement:Physiotherapy 1

Personal Statement:Psychology 16 - The Student Room

How The Student Room is moderated

To keep The Student Room safe for everyone, we moderate posts that are added to the site.

Try out the app

Continue on web