The Student Room Group

girlfriend broke up with me suddenly.

girlfriend left me after nearly 7 months out of the blue claiming she doesn't want to be intimate and only sees me as a good friend.

I loved her. I thought she loved me. She talked about getting married, engaged, using my surname instead of her own. She's been travelling for the past 2 months at a summer camp abroad. I knew it would be hard but I knew i was strong and i could do it. I kept myself busy every day knowing she'd be coming home.

Two days ago her nan died, and i thought something was odd when she told me not to send a card or go to the funeral. then she texts me to say she doesn't see a future with me. she doesn't want to have sex with me, thinks im just a good ffirend, has felt like it since beffore she left. she said she needs space, when i said i assume this is a breakup she just said I need space.

I'm heartbroken, I'm devastated I'm everything. I just feel like i've been living a lie thinking I've been in this happy relationship when if she's telling the truth, she hasn't felt the same for a while. I just feel like my whole future which I had planned has gone. This is the longest relationship i've had and the second one i've had (also her second one but her one was longer).

I'm going to give her space but i've assumed from what she said its a break up but where do I even go from here? my ex before I dumped so it was on my terms and i never felt that strongly but this was something else.

How do I prevent this - if i can - from happening in the future?

She never told me anything or gave me any hint of anything being wrong. I noticed she wasn't that intimate in terms of physically/sexually for a couple weeks but she said that's just how she is. I also know i'm not that experienced sexually so i don't know if that was an issue but i feel like its something else. i don't want to ask much more because it doesn't seem healthy and i want her to leave her to grieve her grandmother, whilst i grieve our relationship and the future we could have had.

I'm just not ready for the world of *****y dating apps, dozens of talking stages which never go anywhere. if she had told me about this when she left i could have spent the summer thinking about it and getting up on my feet rather than believing every day she would come home and we'd have this amazing future together.

Reply 1

Original post
by Anonymous
girlfriend left me after nearly 7 months out of the blue claiming she doesn't want to be intimate and only sees me as a good friend.
I loved her. I thought she loved me. She talked about getting married, engaged, using my surname instead of her own. She's been travelling for the past 2 months at a summer camp abroad. I knew it would be hard but I knew i was strong and i could do it. I kept myself busy every day knowing she'd be coming home.
Two days ago her nan died, and i thought something was odd when she told me not to send a card or go to the funeral. then she texts me to say she doesn't see a future with me. she doesn't want to have sex with me, thinks im just a good ffirend, has felt like it since beffore she left. she said she needs space, when i said i assume this is a breakup she just said I need space.
I'm heartbroken, I'm devastated I'm everything. I just feel like i've been living a lie thinking I've been in this happy relationship when if she's telling the truth, she hasn't felt the same for a while. I just feel like my whole future which I had planned has gone. This is the longest relationship i've had and the second one i've had (also her second one but her one was longer).
I'm going to give her space but i've assumed from what she said its a break up but where do I even go from here? my ex before I dumped so it was on my terms and i never felt that strongly but this was something else.
How do I prevent this - if i can - from happening in the future?
She never told me anything or gave me any hint of anything being wrong. I noticed she wasn't that intimate in terms of physically/sexually for a couple weeks but she said that's just how she is. I also know i'm not that experienced sexually so i don't know if that was an issue but i feel like its something else. i don't want to ask much more because it doesn't seem healthy and i want her to leave her to grieve her grandmother, whilst i grieve our relationship and the future we could have had.
I'm just not ready for the world of *****y dating apps, dozens of talking stages which never go anywhere. if she had told me about this when she left i could have spent the summer thinking about it and getting up on my feet rather than believing every day she would come home and we'd have this amazing future together.

Im sorry man this is what most girls do, they change their minds without warning

Reply 2

Sorry to hear this. Girls, maybe guys too, change their minds at short notice. It can be very hard to understand and hurtful. It also feels most unfair when declarations of love has been made. There is a right time and a right person to make a commitment and the need for this combination to come together is part of the complexity. I tend to agree with you that she’s not going to have a change of heart. However there is not just one ideal girl, there are in fact many and new and better love comes

Reply 3

Well she has a right to do what she did, if she is not feeling the relationship no more then it is probably best that she does what she did there by breaking up with you

Reply 4

Hi there, so sorry to hear that. As an ordinary Hong Konger (typically with much negativity) I'd tell you that she cheated on you. You could wait for a month to figure out - if it's just because of her low spirits she'd probably return normal by then. She's otherwise cheating, hehe. Sincerely, sorry for the tragedy. Best way to move on is to get a new gf!

Reply 5

Relationship 2 has ended. Time to move on to relationships 3, 4, and 5. When you get to relationships 5, 6, or 7, that's when you think about settling down with someone, marrying them, having children with them, all that.

2 books that will give you great advice on how to reduce the chances of you getting dumped again:
Atomic Attraction by Christopher Canwell
Why Men Love *****es by Sheri Argov

They are the sort of books that may not resonate with you till you get to Relationship 4. After you've made the sort of mistakes discussed in these books and done some of the wise things advised in them.

You mentioned your inexperience at sex. The sex was, almost certainly, a contributory factor in this latest break-up. That's fine. We all have to learn some time. With the right attitude, you should be able to get competent at making love with a woman, as you gain more experience.

Reply 6

Original post
by Anonymous
girlfriend left me after nearly 7 months out of the blue claiming she doesn't want to be intimate and only sees me as a good friend.
I loved her. I thought she loved me. She talked about getting married, engaged, using my surname instead of her own. She's been travelling for the past 2 months at a summer camp abroad. I knew it would be hard but I knew i was strong and i could do it. I kept myself busy every day knowing she'd be coming home.
Two days ago her nan died, and i thought something was odd when she told me not to send a card or go to the funeral. then she texts me to say she doesn't see a future with me. she doesn't want to have sex with me, thinks im just a good ffirend, has felt like it since beffore she left. she said she needs space, when i said i assume this is a breakup she just said I need space.
I'm heartbroken, I'm devastated I'm everything. I just feel like i've been living a lie thinking I've been in this happy relationship when if she's telling the truth, she hasn't felt the same for a while. I just feel like my whole future which I had planned has gone. This is the longest relationship i've had and the second one i've had (also her second one but her one was longer).
I'm going to give her space but i've assumed from what she said its a break up but where do I even go from here? my ex before I dumped so it was on my terms and i never felt that strongly but this was something else.
How do I prevent this - if i can - from happening in the future?
She never told me anything or gave me any hint of anything being wrong. I noticed she wasn't that intimate in terms of physically/sexually for a couple weeks but she said that's just how she is. I also know i'm not that experienced sexually so i don't know if that was an issue but i feel like its something else. i don't want to ask much more because it doesn't seem healthy and i want her to leave her to grieve her grandmother, whilst i grieve our relationship and the future we could have had.
I'm just not ready for the world of *****y dating apps, dozens of talking stages which never go anywhere. if she had told me about this when she left i could have spent the summer thinking about it and getting up on my feet rather than believing every day she would come home and we'd have this amazing future together.
Oh man, this happened to me today as well, I got dumped out the blue, she won't even give me a reason why other than she don't think we will work

Reply 7

Hei, it just takes time to get to know people, and now you know, how she is and she knows, how you are. 🙂 Luckily already after 7 months, so totally normal to break up that early, because you can never know a person, before you have actually been a couple, etc. ...
It of course hurts, but ... I would say, pretty normal to break up that early, because you are still finding out how things go. 🙂 Not need to stress to much, probably some lesson learned, like allways in life, but relationships take luck, skill and the right situation.

Reply 8

Original post
by Dunnig Kruger
Relationship 2 has ended. Time to move on to relationships 3, 4, and 5. When you get to relationships 5, 6, or 7, that's when you think about settling down with someone, marrying them, having children with them, all that.
2 books that will give you great advice on how to reduce the chances of you getting dumped again:
Atomic Attraction by Christopher Canwell
Why Men Love *****es by Sheri Argov
They are the sort of books that may not resonate with you till you get to Relationship 4. After you've made the sort of mistakes discussed in these books and done some of the wise things advised in them.
You mentioned your inexperience at sex. The sex was, almost certainly, a contributory factor in this latest break-up. That's fine. We all have to learn some time. With the right attitude, you should be able to get competent at making love with a woman, as you gain more experience.

Hm, I honestly know nearly no one, who had that money relationships of equal quality, and managed to stick to one, just because of age ... When you have that many relationships of equal quality, you have a problem. When you have that many relationships, because you count dating, adventures, non serious relationships in, then ... yeah, you might end up having that many ...

It is not true, that you need different relationships to grow as a person, you can grow together, or not ... you can be naive and break up everytime your perfect phantasy breaks together or accept, that no relationship is rosa pink fluffy all the time. But yes, sometimes, you need considerably work on yourself to be able to become a good partner and you need luck to find a person, who wants to grow together with you.

If you would have 7 relationships, which actually reach a point, where you can seriously think about having spent enough time together, we talk fast 7 x 3 years = 21 years ... which is a ridiculously long time ...

Reply 9

I just wondered as well because I remember her describing to me how she stopped wanting to sleep with her ex before she dumped him and how she didn't see a future with him, either.

I can't see that she would have cheated I don't see whwr she would have had the opportunity to do so other than when she was away, and she claims to have had felt like this for longer. And even so, the opportunity to actually do much at where she is at camp is really limited.

Reply 10

Original post
by Nathanielle_
Hm, I honestly know nearly no one, who had that money relationships of equal quality, and managed to stick to one, just because of age ... When you have that many relationships of equal quality, you have a problem. When you have that many relationships, because you count dating, adventures, non serious relationships in, then ... yeah, you might end up having that many ...
It is not true, that you need different relationships to grow as a person, you can grow together, or not ... you can be naive and break up everytime your perfect phantasy breaks together or accept, that no relationship is rosa pink fluffy all the time. But yes, sometimes, you need considerably work on yourself to be able to become a good partner and you need luck to find a person, who wants to grow together with you.
If you would have 7 relationships, which actually reach a point, where you can seriously think about having spent enough time together, we talk fast 7 x 3 years = 21 years ... which is a ridiculously long time ...

It makes a lot of sense for the first 4 relationships to last between 3 and 12 months.
For a single person that is actively looking, that is reasonably attractive (in the broad sense of the term including social skills and personality and not just looks), they should be able to get into their next relationship within 3 months of the previous one ending.

This means that if the first relationship happens when the person is 19, they will be looking at starting their 5th relationship when they are aged 21 to 24.

Someone that has rattled through 4 relationships by the time they're 24 will be better equipped for their next relationship than if they'd had 0, 1 or 2 relationships.
Because a lot of the learning and experience gain is concentrated during the process of finding the next romantic partner, the early stages of the relationship and the final stage of the relationship.



Original post
by Anonymous
I just wondered as well because I remember her describing to me how she stopped wanting to sleep with her ex before she dumped him and how she didn't see a future with him, either.
I can't see that she would have cheated I don't see whwr she would have had the opportunity to do so other than when she was away, and she claims to have had felt like this for longer. And even so, the opportunity to actually do much at where she is at camp is really limited.

Yes, you often find that women (and men) have a pattern to their relationships.
It sounds like she probably didn't cheat on you. And that she just followed her relationship pattern.
Eventually a guy will come along that will interrupt her pattern. And she'll spend longer with him (or her) than she did with you and her ex.

That's the sort of guy you should aim to be. The sort of guy where the relationship that any given woman has with you is different to all her previous relationships. Different in a way that gets her hooked on you and keeps her attracted to you.

One big upside to your life now is that you have your freedom back. Please don't undervalue your freedom.
During your relationship you probably had to turn down opportunities to get to know other women. Those opportunities are open to you now.

Make it so that your life is wonderful when you're in a relationship. And it's wonderful when you're single. And it's wonderful when you're single and looking.

Reply 11

Original post
by Anonymous
girlfriend left me after nearly 7 months out of the blue claiming she doesn't want to be intimate and only sees me as a good friend.
I loved her. I thought she loved me. She talked about getting married, engaged, using my surname instead of her own. She's been travelling for the past 2 months at a summer camp abroad. I knew it would be hard but I knew i was strong and i could do it. I kept myself busy every day knowing she'd be coming home.
Two days ago her nan died, and i thought something was odd when she told me not to send a card or go to the funeral. then she texts me to say she doesn't see a future with me. she doesn't want to have sex with me, thinks im just a good ffirend, has felt like it since beffore she left. she said she needs space, when i said i assume this is a breakup she just said I need space.
I'm heartbroken, I'm devastated I'm everything. I just feel like i've been living a lie thinking I've been in this happy relationship when if she's telling the truth, she hasn't felt the same for a while. I just feel like my whole future which I had planned has gone. This is the longest relationship i've had and the second one i've had (also her second one but her one was longer).
I'm going to give her space but i've assumed from what she said its a break up but where do I even go from here? my ex before I dumped so it was on my terms and i never felt that strongly but this was something else.
How do I prevent this - if i can - from happening in the future?
She never told me anything or gave me any hint of anything being wrong. I noticed she wasn't that intimate in terms of physically/sexually for a couple weeks but she said that's just how she is. I also know i'm not that experienced sexually so i don't know if that was an issue but i feel like its something else. i don't want to ask much more because it doesn't seem healthy and i want her to leave her to grieve her grandmother, whilst i grieve our relationship and the future we could have had.
I'm just not ready for the world of *****y dating apps, dozens of talking stages which never go anywhere. if she had told me about this when she left i could have spent the summer thinking about it and getting up on my feet rather than believing every day she would come home and we'd have this amazing future together.

As I said in a similar thread, she found a Chad. I hear the same story many times, girls dump a bf out of the blue when they meet a handsome guy. It's very common so it's probable in this case too. Especially when they don't say why or use a generic "need space". Notice that she said you can be only friends, this proves personality isn't the reason why she dumped you. An advice I can give is to lower the level of attractiveness of girls you date, as Chads are less interested to steal your gf if she's ugly

Reply 12

Original post
by Dnnatnt
As I said in a similar thread, she found a Chad. I hear the same story many times, girls dump a bf out of the blue when they meet a handsome guy. It's very common so it's probable in this case too. Especially when they don't say why or use a generic "need space". Notice that she said you can be only friends, this proves personality isn't the reason why she dumped you. An advice I can give is to lower the level of attractiveness of girls you date, as Chads are less interested to steal your gf if she's ugly

An advice I can give is to lower the level of attractiveness of girls you date, as Chads are less interested to steal your gf if she's ugly
When I was 15, my very handsome (Chad) older brother told me "Go for the plain looking girls, as they're easier". It took me a few years to work out that this was terrible advice. And that beautiful women are about as easy to get into a relationship with as plain looking ones. And that fidelity does not appear to be an issue as long as the man has the right kind of inner world - resulting in him behaving in generally the right kind of way to retain the interest, attraction, love of his girlfriend. As well as there being an element of selection in the man getting into a relationship with the right kind of woman for him.
If anything, most women (that I've known) have been too faithful and have stayed too long with unsuitable partners. Because it's very human to fall into the sunken cost fallacy.
We also don't know how handsome the original poster is. He might have the looks of an ancient Greek demi-god!

As I said in a similar thread, she found a Chad.
It's possible she has. It's possible she hasn't. I'm keeping an open mind on this until more evidence comes to light. That's the nature of relationship break-ups. There's often a big grey area of unknown things.

I hear the same story many times, girls dump a bf out of the blue when they meet a handsome guy.
In my experience, from my own relationships, and those of my family and friends and friends of friends; the commonest story is that the behaviour of one or both people in the relationship isn't good enough, or isn't of the right kind of nature in order to keep the relationship going.
There's lots of different flavours of "break-up behaviours". Ranging from nasty evil abuse, to putting her on a pedestal typical nice guy mistakes. The root cause of almost all break-up behaviours is a lack of mental and emotional strength.
Think about it. Bullies snap and take things out on their girlfriends because they lack self control and emotional strength.
Typical nice guys supplicate too much because they lack mental and emotional strength.
Clingy, needy guys cling too much because they lack emotional strength.
Deadbeat guys, drift through life because they lack mental strength.
Etc etc etc

The original poster said "I also know i'm not that experienced sexually" and "This is the longest relationship i've had and the second one i've had". He is still very much learning about relationships. Given time, and a few hard knocks, and the right attitude from him, there's every chance he'll mature into being a competent boyfriend. The sort of guy that can attract women without too much difficulty and maintain that attraction. As time passes he may well become less good looking. This will - by far - be outweighed by him maturing inside his skull in the right kinds of ways.

Reply 13

I've decided when she gets back I'm going to text her and ask to meet or just talk and actually confirm whether we're breaking up or whether we can to try and repair our relationship if thats what she wants.

Right now I'm just in bits. I can't really enjoy anything not even self pleasure. Everything feels meaningless

Reply 14

Original post
by Connor Wonder
Im sorry man this is what most girls do, they change their minds without warning

hey excuse you girls minds I've been assaulted several times by 3 guys this year since even since age 3 that was my life guys who disrespected me because I have curves who doubted I could be what I wanted to become and its still happens been cheated lied to and used
(edited 2 months ago)

Reply 15

Original post
by Anonymous
girlfriend left me after nearly 7 months out of the blue claiming she doesn't want to be intimate and only sees me as a good friend.
I loved her. I thought she loved me. She talked about getting married, engaged, using my surname instead of her own. She's been travelling for the past 2 months at a summer camp abroad. I knew it would be hard but I knew i was strong and i could do it. I kept myself busy every day knowing she'd be coming home.
Two days ago her nan died, and i thought something was odd when she told me not to send a card or go to the funeral. then she texts me to say she doesn't see a future with me. she doesn't want to have sex with me, thinks im just a good ffirend, has felt like it since beffore she left. she said she needs space, when i said i assume this is a breakup she just said I need space.
I'm heartbroken, I'm devastated I'm everything. I just feel like i've been living a lie thinking I've been in this happy relationship when if she's telling the truth, she hasn't felt the same for a while. I just feel like my whole future which I had planned has gone. This is the longest relationship i've had and the second one i've had (also her second one but her one was longer).
I'm going to give her space but i've assumed from what she said its a break up but where do I even go from here? my ex before I dumped so it was on my terms and i never felt that strongly but this was something else.
How do I prevent this - if i can - from happening in the future?
She never told me anything or gave me any hint of anything being wrong. I noticed she wasn't that intimate in terms of physically/sexually for a couple weeks but she said that's just how she is. I also know i'm not that experienced sexually so i don't know if that was an issue but i feel like its something else. i don't want to ask much more because it doesn't seem healthy and i want her to leave her to grieve her grandmother, whilst i grieve our relationship and the future we could have had.
I'm just not ready for the world of *****y dating apps, dozens of talking stages which never go anywhere. if she had told me about this when she left i could have spent the summer thinking about it and getting up on my feet rather than believing every day she would come home and we'd have this amazing future together.

you'll find the one don't over think it love real love is when you feel it in your heart your safe and they can look you the eyes when things are good or bad they honest about there where abouts and lets you have passwords or to log in to her phone without asking and not bickering shows she loyal and honest with you

Reply 16

Original post
by Anonymous
girlfriend left me after nearly 7 months out of the blue claiming she doesn't want to be intimate and only sees me as a good friend.
I loved her. I thought she loved me. She talked about getting married, engaged, using my surname instead of her own. She's been travelling for the past 2 months at a summer camp abroad. I knew it would be hard but I knew i was strong and i could do it. I kept myself busy every day knowing she'd be coming home.
Two days ago her nan died, and i thought something was odd when she told me not to send a card or go to the funeral. then she texts me to say she doesn't see a future with me. she doesn't want to have sex with me, thinks im just a good ffirend, has felt like it since beffore she left. she said she needs space, when i said i assume this is a breakup she just said I need space.
I'm heartbroken, I'm devastated I'm everything. I just feel like i've been living a lie thinking I've been in this happy relationship when if she's telling the truth, she hasn't felt the same for a while. I just feel like my whole future which I had planned has gone. This is the longest relationship i've had and the second one i've had (also her second one but her one was longer).
I'm going to give her space but i've assumed from what she said its a break up but where do I even go from here? my ex before I dumped so it was on my terms and i never felt that strongly but this was something else.
How do I prevent this - if i can - from happening in the future?
She never told me anything or gave me any hint of anything being wrong. I noticed she wasn't that intimate in terms of physically/sexually for a couple weeks but she said that's just how she is. I also know i'm not that experienced sexually so i don't know if that was an issue but i feel like its something else. i don't want to ask much more because it doesn't seem healthy and i want her to leave her to grieve her grandmother, whilst i grieve our relationship and the future we could have had.
I'm just not ready for the world of *****y dating apps, dozens of talking stages which never go anywhere. if she had told me about this when she left i could have spent the summer thinking about it and getting up on my feet rather than believing every day she would come home and we'd have this amazing future together.

You will have to respect what she wants at this stage, she feels you are not for her anymore

Quick Reply

How The Student Room is moderated

To keep The Student Room safe for everyone, we moderate posts that are added to the site.