The Student Room Logo
This thread is closed

Know anyone who should NOT have got into Cambridge but did!

Scroll to see replies

Reply 20
Me.

I'm not returning at the start of next term, either. I know I'm not good enough.
Reply 21
iceman_jondoe
i sense jelousy :p:


Nah, I did better in most of the subjects we share, except chemistry, last year, and I'm applying for medicine so I didn't apply to oxbridge. I just don't like the girl and really didn't think she deserved a place :p:
Reply 22
C2H5OH
Me.

I'm not returning at the start of next term, either. I know I'm not good enough.

:frown:
Jessaay!
Nah, I did better in most of the subjects we share, except chemistry, last year, and I'm applying for medicine so I didn't apply to oxbridge. I just don't like the girl and really didn't think she deserved a place :p:


Good luck!
that's a lie. anyone that gets into Cambridge deserves their place there as they have beaten other people to it. I mean why would they be picked if they weren't good enough for entry to Cambridge? also, anyone that is saying "oh this person is not clever he shouldn't have gone in" well, I sense jealousy in the air - and for what reason, you're at Cambridg yourself. I mean what are the chances of an admin tutor giving an offer to someone that wasn't academically capable? and anyway, they might see potential in this student, and if they were in doubt, they might give an offer of say AAAA if it so happens they were taking 4 a-levels.
Reply 25
iceman_jondoe
Good luck!


Thanks :biggrin:
Got an interview coming up at UCL :woo:
Reply 26
probably my ex-boyfriend, although he's at oxford. he shouldn't have got in because he hates his subject, and has no real interest in oxford as a place or university. he's an immense person, dead interesting and really clever - but I thought oxford looked for people who were passionate about what they were studying? or dats what I 'erd or sumfin.

not like I begrudge him his place or anything, he would have been happier elsewhere doing something else, though. I'm surprised the admissions tutors didn't notice.
Reply 27
im so academic
that's a lie. anyone that gets into Cambridge deserves their place there as they have beaten other people to it. I mean why would they be picked if they weren't good enough for entry to Cambridge? also, anyone that is saying "oh this person is not clever he shouldn't have gone in" well, I sense jealousy in the air - and for what reason, you're at Cambridg yourself. I mean what are the chances of an admin tutor giving an offer to someone that wasn't academically capable? and anyway, they might see potential in this student, and if they were in doubt, they might give an offer of say AAAA if it so happens they were taking 4 a-levels.


So "im so academic" trails in, once more, growling at those who ever questioned the decision of his Gods- the Oxbridge admissions tutors.
OhNO!
probably my ex-boyfriend, although he's at oxford. he shouldn't have got in because he hates his subject, and has no real interest in oxford as a place or university. he's an immense person, dead interesting and really clever - but I thought oxford looked for people who were passionate about what they were studying? or dats what I 'erd or sumfin.

They might look for people who are passionate about their subject, but many people get in who are not, or are not once they start studying it there.
alex_hk90
At times I wonder if I should not have got in, but apart from that no one else I've met really.

:ditto:
And you totally deserved to get in btw :yes:
Reply 30
alex_hk90
They might look for people who are passionate about their subject, but many people get in who are not, or are not once they start studying it there.


well, so it seems. he's totally clever enough to do the course, but with so many able candidates getting turned away, it seems pretty bum to offer a place to study chemistry at oxford to someone who really hates chemistry.

although, one of my best friends who hates oxford and didn't want to go there got rejected after an interview, and I was outraged because she's so ridiculously clever. clearly I cut both ways on this issue!
I do know someone who managed to get into Cambridge to study Computer Science because the college he applied to had I think 4 places, and there were 4 applicants... he's never been known to study at all.

But fair play to him for managing to get in at all, I guess.
alex_hk90
They might look for people who are passionate about their subject, but many people get in who are not, or are not once they start studying it there.


Surely not you for the latter part of that sentence?

I do think I can think of one... also after I meet the new students from my old school who have offers I might be able to add to this list :p:
The Sherminator
Surely not you for the latter part of that sentence?

You'd be surprised.
alex_hk90
You'd be surprised.


lol you're so modest. :rolleyes: Anyone who gets 600/600 in one of their A levels and 90%+ in all of their others can't be begrudged a place.
Reply 35
bret
Reply 36
lol

---
"Passion" goes through phases. You can be insanely motivated/"passionate" about your subject(s) one year and a bit bored the next. :P
Reply 37
ArcadiaHouse
Prince Charles, according to my English teacher.


Seconded :p: They have St. Andrews for that sort of thing nowadays though.
not really. i know a an mc at cambridge though: http://www.myspace.com/zeekoinc
Reply 39
I know people who probably deserved to go to a top 10 uni, but not Oxbridge. They are academically competent as far as exams are concerned, but have nothing outstanding beyond that. I know one who got into Cambridge who did not read beyond the syllabus at all (he did not read the books cited in his personal statement), and even often complained about reading challenging texts on the subject. He rarely gave intelligent answers during discussions in class, and he's really quite mediocre (often got confused) when it comes to the more 'advanced' stuff on the subject.

Luck plays a huge role in the interviews. Ultimately, everyone who gets into Cambridge (or Oxford) are competent, undoubtedly. But of course, there are many other people out there who were rejected but arguably deserved the place just as much/more than some of the lucky ones, who were good on display (on paper and during the short interviews), but genuinely and intrinsically- really not good enough.