The Student Room Group

ESAT results

My daughter got her ESAT results on Friday and they are so different to what she expected that I wonder if there could have been a mistake. On practice tests she consistently had 6's and 7's but she scored 1's and 2's on the actual test (she got a 1 in physics). On the day, she didn't think that it had gone any better or worse than her practice tests. Of course, anyone can have a bad day, and if she'd scored 3's and 4's I wouldn't have thought too much of it, but this seems spectacularly different to her usual performance. I'm wondering if there could be any possibility of a fault, either in the delivery of her results or in the computer on which she sat the test. I suspect that there will be no way to appeal this and I will just be treated as a disappointed parent but it really seems so wrong that it's impossible to believe. Did anyone else get results that were not just a bit different to what they expected but spectacularly different, and has anyone ever successfully appealed a result?

Reply 1

@CatkinLolly Check out this thread...may be relevant to you: https://www.thestudentroom.co.uk/showthread.php?t=7641490

Reply 2

Thanks, yes, it looks similar. If there are a lot of people in the same boat then maybe we'll have some grounds to bring it up.

Reply 3

Original post
by CatkinLolly
My daughter got her ESAT results on Friday and they are so different to what she expected that I wonder if there could have been a mistake. On practice tests she consistently had 6's and 7's but she scored 1's and 2's on the actual test (she got a 1 in physics). On the day, she didn't think that it had gone any better or worse than her practice tests. Of course, anyone can have a bad day, and if she'd scored 3's and 4's I wouldn't have thought too much of it, but this seems spectacularly different to her usual performance. I'm wondering if there could be any possibility of a fault, either in the delivery of her results or in the computer on which she sat the test. I suspect that there will be no way to appeal this and I will just be treated as a disappointed parent but it really seems so wrong that it's impossible to believe. Did anyone else get results that were not just a bit different to what they expected but spectacularly different, and has anyone ever successfully appealed a result?


My son is very disappointed in his results too. Got 3.6 average on maths 1, 2 & physics. It's heartbreaking seeing him so disappointed. Just listened to a webinar about Oxbridge interviews. Fingers crossed he still gets one. He's exceptionally bright so this has hit him hard. Can I ask if you live in Wales? Fingers crossed for your daughter.

Reply 4

So sorry for your son. We are British but live n France. As you say, it's heartbreaking after all the work - as she's not doing A-levels my daughter worked really hard all summer teaching herself the gaps in the syllabus and using the on-line materials to get to a point where she performed as well as anyone in the ESAT practice tests. Now I wonder if we should have invested in tutors, etc. but that feels wrong to me. If the on-line resources aren't enough then the system is inherently unfair to those who don't have access to more.

Reply 5

Hi everyone

try doing a Subject Access Request to get all the information they hold on your children. You'll need proof of ID and address.

In particular ask for all of the information they hold on your children including exam scripts.

The e-mail address is:

[email protected]

If the results don't tally contact the universities admissions teams immediately, then make a complaint, contact Ofqual and your MPs.

Good luck everyone!

Reply 6

Original post
by Prettypumpkin
Hi everyone
try doing a Subject Access Request to get all the information they hold on your children. You'll need proof of ID and address.
In particular ask for all of the information they hold on your children including exam scripts.
The e-mail address is:
[email protected]
If the results don't tally contact the universities admissions teams immediately, then make a complaint, contact Ofqual and your MPs.
Good luck everyone!

Thank you - I 'm doing that. There is someone in the TMUA group who's son did ESAT and got lower scores than expected. She contacted the university and discovered that they had been sent different scores to the ones received by her son. There is definitely something going wrong. Please, if you are in this situation, make a subject access request as described above - the more people who do it, the more likely they are to act.

Reply 7

Original post
by CatkinLolly
Thank you - I 'm doing that. There is someone in the TMUA group who's son did ESAT and got lower scores than expected. She contacted the university and discovered that they had been sent different scores to the ones received by her son. There is definitely something going wrong. Please, if you are in this situation, make a subject access request as described above - the more people who do it, the more likely they are to act.

do you have a link to that discussion?

Reply 8

So if I understand this correctly UAT-UK isn't regulated by anyone? Instead it's a collaboration between Imperial and Cambridge.

https://esat-tmua.ac.uk/about-uat-uk/

Pearson VUE administer the tests on their behalf but no one can investigate them?

And there is a SAR exemption that means candidates can't see their papers although as emerging-mogul says here there are other questions we can ask:

https://www.thestudentroom.co.uk/showthread.php?t=7641490&p=101001476

Doesn't this seem wrong to anyone else? If they are not regulated by anyone and there is no transparency and no way to question them how can we expect them to be fair?

What does everyone else think?

Reply 9

Hi Catkin,

Did you get aby response to your email to UAT UK. My son is in the same boat. He has a score of 5.1 which is not he accepted at all.
thanks

Quick Reply

How The Student Room is moderated

To keep The Student Room safe for everyone, we moderate posts that are added to the site.