The Student Room Group

Future of Forum Games and next steps

Hi all,

I want to be as upfront as possible and communicate clearly about what we’ve been experiencing over the last few weeks and months, the impact it’s having on our core function at The Student Room, and how we will move forward if things don’t improve significantly.

Over this period, a huge amount of our moderation and safeguarding resource has been taken up by consistent and relentless behavioural issues in Forum Games. This has included over-reporting, brigading in private messages, nastiness in both public and private comments, and ongoing conversations about bans and moderation decisions, all of which go against TSR guidelines.

The Student Room moderation team has a significant duty of care to its users, who range from age 13 onwards. We allow discussions on incredibly sensitive topics such as sexual health, relationships, mental health, politics, religion, because we believe the space we provide can be constructive, supportive, and genuinely positive for young people. However, these conversations come with real risk and require our team to handle reports, check in on user welfare, and support our volunteers in fostering the right environment. This is by far the most important aspect of what our moderation team does.

To be blunt, the incidents of the last few months have massively distracted from this work, demanded more time than we have available, and cannot continue. We simply cannot justify the level of resource currently required to keep these games running when the volume of complaints, rule-breaking, and general reports is this high. If we are forced to choose, we will always prioritise safeguarding our most vulnerable users.

With that in mind, I want us to find a constructive way to draw a line under the last few months and move forward so Forum Games can continue. I’m asking for your support in making that happen. Tomorrow we will be releasing new Forum Games guidance to centralise processes and help volunteers and staff manage issues in a way that requires less resource. We will also be drawing a line under previous behaviour and giving everyone a completely clean slate. This is a chance for all of us to start again and work together in the right way.

However, we will be taking a firm stance on moderation in three key areas:

Openly discussing moderation decisions will result in a card, and those cards will escalate. Repeated discussion of this topic will eventually lead to a ban.

Frivolous or false reports/complaints will first be addressed in conversation, but repeated behaviour of this kind will result in a card, which will escalate and may ultimately lead to a ban.

I will check in monthly with our moderation team and the volunteers who run the section. If it’s clear things have not improved, we will consider either closing Hurt/Heal games or closing the entire Forum Games section.

This is our opportunity to move forward together and continue enjoying the community you have built. Thank you for your patience and understanding as we do that.

EH

Spoiler

Scroll to see replies

Reply 1

Original post
by Evil Homer
Hi all,
I want to be as upfront as possible and communicate clearly about what we’ve been experiencing over the last few weeks and months, the impact it’s having on our core function at The Student Room, and how we will move forward if things don’t improve significantly.
Over this period, a huge amount of our moderation and safeguarding resource has been taken up by consistent and relentless behavioural issues in Forum Games. This has included over-reporting, brigading in private messages, nastiness in both public and private comments, and ongoing conversations about bans and moderation decisions, all of which go against TSR guidelines.
The Student Room moderation team has a significant duty of care to its users, who range from age 13 onwards. We allow discussions on incredibly sensitive topics such as sexual health, relationships, mental health, politics, religion, because we believe the space we provide can be constructive, supportive, and genuinely positive for young people. However, these conversations come with real risk and require our team to handle reports, check in on user welfare, and support our volunteers in fostering the right environment. This is by far the most important aspect of what our moderation team does.
To be blunt, the incidents of the last few months have massively distracted from this work, demanded more time than we have available, and cannot continue. We simply cannot justify the level of resource currently required to keep these games running when the volume of complaints, rule-breaking, and general reports is this high. If we are forced to choose, we will always prioritise safeguarding our most vulnerable users.
With that in mind, I want us to find a constructive way to draw a line under the last few months and move forward so Forum Games can continue. I’m asking for your support in making that happen. Tomorrow we will be releasing new Forum Games guidance to centralise processes and help volunteers and staff manage issues in a way that requires less resource. We will also be drawing a line under previous behaviour and giving everyone a completely clean slate. This is a chance for all of us to start again and work together in the right way.
However, we will be taking a firm stance on moderation in three key areas:
Openly discussing moderation decisions will result in a card, and those cards will escalate. Repeated discussion of this topic will eventually lead to a ban.
Frivolous or false reports/complaints will first be addressed in conversation, but repeated behaviour of this kind will result in a card, which will escalate and may ultimately lead to a ban.
I will check in monthly with our moderation team and the volunteers who run the section. If it’s clear things have not improved, we will consider either closing Hurt/Heal games or closing the entire Forum Games section.
This is our opportunity to move forward together and continue enjoying the community you have built. Thank you for your patience and understanding as we do that.
EH

Spoiler


Have I participated in any of this?

Reply 2

Original post
by SonicNChemistry
Have I participated in any of this?


I should have said. I've tagged in all posters in Forum Games over November :smile:

Reply 3

Original post
by Evil Homer
I should have said. I've tagged in all posters in Forum Games over November :smile:

I take it I must be in trouble then :dontknow:

Reply 4

Original post
by Evil Homer
I should have said. I've tagged in all posters in Forum Games over November :smile:

Oh ok. I do try to behave

Reply 5

:getmecoat:
k

Reply 6

Wait I did something wrong?

Reply 7

Ive never played a forum game before 😔

Reply 8

I haven’t even ever heard of forum games so I’m surprised I’m tagged!

Reply 9

Hi.

This is a very important message that I think everyone should be aware of. However, I don't understand why I've been tagged if it is only those who have participated in forum games in November as I have not participated in one in a long while.

Still, very important message.

Reply 10

In my opinion there are some games that are there for the freedom of speech and too strict moderation may result in people leaving the site completely.
The site should also be a place for random chats, fun and just a place to get to know other people.
Some games are built just for that.
If someone writes in a different language there it is not for the sake of other not understanding what is said or insulting someone or anything of that kind it is more about sharing and showing a side of you other people can't know otherwise.
Too strict moderation of this will ruin the fun of the post and the fun of the site.
I really like this place and as someone older I find it as a site with a good potential of supporting teens and young adults and not only for study discussions. Getting to know people gives people the feeling of wanting to share more, maybe talk about more personal things with certain people and the way to get to know each other better is through those forum games. I think there is a good potential there and more freedom should be allowed there to achieve that potential.

I'm saying my opinion "out loud" here. I am sure most of the members agree with that.

Reply 11

Looks like the thing we generate the tags from might not have worked well. Hopefully everyone who needs to see it has but apologies for any misdirected tags :smile:

Reply 12

I haven't been in forum Ames fro while but still an I pronto message than you
Anyone thinking "does this mean me?" can easily check this by looking at their community record here.

On a personal note, outside of my time volunteering on the site, Forum Games has had its ups and downs over my 11 years posting here. I haven't ever, ever seen a message like this threatening to close the forum. I have seen two other cases where sub-communities within The Student Room have been shut down. It wasn't pleasant in either scenario. In both of those cases, the reason for the decision was that too much time was taken up of moderators having to deal with cruel, unkind, petty (ridiculously so) and at times even dangerous behaviour. You may not like TSR's approach with this, or their moderation policies. Fact is you don't have to like it - you agreed to them when you created your account. If your response to this is that users might leave the site, my answer would be that having some of those users on the site at the moment is clearly not a beneficial thing.

On behalf of those who have been counting to a million (with me) for over a decade, I'd ask everyone to think carefully please before potentially throwing away something that isn't just yours. I joined CTAM during part 7. It's now at Part 80. I've always said to myself that I wouldn't leave the site while it was unfinished. If that is stopped due to the actions of others it will be very very sad.

Part of playing a Forum Game is following the rules. If we can't get that right what's the chuffing point?

Reply 14

Original post
by 04MR17
Anyone thinking "does this mean me?" can easily check this by looking at their community record here.
On a personal note, outside of my time volunteering on the site, Forum Games has had its ups and downs over my 11 years posting here. I haven't ever, ever seen a message like this threatening to close the forum. I have seen two other cases where sub-communities within The Student Room have been shut down. It wasn't pleasant in either scenario. In both of those cases, the reason for the decision was that too much time was taken up of moderators having to deal with cruel, unkind, petty (ridiculously so) and at times even dangerous behaviour. You may not like TSR's approach with this, or their moderation policies. Fact is you don't have to like it - you agreed to them when you created your account. If your response to this is that users might leave the site, my answer would be that having some of those users on the site at the moment is clearly not a beneficial thing.
On behalf of those who have been counting to a million (with me) for over a decade, I'd ask everyone to think carefully please before potentially throwing away something that isn't just yours. I joined CTAM during part 7. It's now at Part 80. I've always said to myself that I wouldn't leave the site while it was unfinished. If that is stopped due to the actions of others it will be very very sad.
Part of playing a Forum Game is following the rules. If we can't get that right what's the chuffing point?

Hi :wavey:a clean slate is all good?
Evil Homer's attitude and ideas for solutions to these issues seem to be hard, but consequent. I am glad that the moderation staff finally begin to deal with them.
(edited 1 month ago)

Reply 17

Original post
by Evil Homer
I should have said. I've tagged in all posters in Forum Games over November :smile:

This makes so much more sense

Reply 18

Original post
by AngryJellyfish

It wasn't me
Original post
by bobjeffandam
Ive never played a forum game before 😔


Most are still opened. Play them as long as you can. You never know what comes as next.

Quick Reply

How The Student Room is moderated

To keep The Student Room safe for everyone, we moderate posts that are added to the site.