The Student Room Group

Ao3 history a level aqa nea

My teacher is lowk terrible at explaining how to do the section on the historians comparison. Please could someone clear some questions I have up please?? Do you get graded higher/lower based on the popularity or how highly accredited the historians you pick are, does it matter where I place it in my overall essay and is it a direct comparison between 2 historians views???

Reply 1

for ours we put the historians right at the start of our essay, after the intro. for me i did 1 para per historian, then 1 para comparing and stating which is more convincing. i then referenced them throughout my essay if it aligned with the point i was making. my historians section took up 1000 words ish if that helps as a guide. you won't get graded lower for picking one historian over another, just as long as they are reputable historians (eg someone who has a book on the topic or smt - if ur unsure if u can use a historian just ask ur teacher). if it helps, this is the checklist our school gave us for writing it:
Explored at least two historians’ views in line with Q focus
Clear analysis of interpretations of both historians
Discussed the context of their work (when were they writing?)
How would this context impact their views?
Refer to both historians and their differing arguments throughout
(Remember your Historians’ views may differ subtly rather than overtly; this is fine as long as you explain this)
good luck!!

Reply 2

Original post
by abistntn
for ours we put the historians right at the start of our essay, after the intro. for me i did 1 para per historian, then 1 para comparing and stating which is more convincing. i then referenced them throughout my essay if it aligned with the point i was making. my historians section took up 1000 words ish if that helps as a guide. you won't get graded lower for picking one historian over another, just as long as they are reputable historians (eg someone who has a book on the topic or smt - if ur unsure if u can use a historian just ask ur teacher). if it helps, this is the checklist our school gave us for writing it:
Explored at least two historians’ views in line with Q focus
Clear analysis of interpretations of both historians
Discussed the context of their work (when were they writing?)
How would this context impact their views?
Refer to both historians and their differing arguments throughout
(Remember your Historians’ views may differ subtly rather than overtly; this is fine as long as you explain this)
good luck!!

My goodness thank you so much! This has helped me tremendously. I was so confused on whether we needed to directly compare them and this cleared that up. Thanks again!

Reply 3

Original post
by roman_Empire67
My goodness thank you so much! This has helped me tremendously. I was so confused on whether we needed to directly compare them and this cleared that up. Thanks again!

you're welcome!! glad i could help 🙂

Quick Reply

How The Student Room is moderated

To keep The Student Room safe for everyone, we moderate posts that are added to the site.