The Student Room Group

Ab initio languages at Edinburgh

would anyone be able to share their experience with ab initio German or languages at Edinburgh? I’ve seen nothing about it online

Reply 1

I am currently studying German ab initio at Edinburgh, and all in all I think it's a pretty good course. The lecturers and tutorial leaders are great, and the material is generally good - they lay out what topics we need to learn very clearly. It is really intense, but if you're up to it then it's worth the effort.
That being said, the coursebook recommended (DaF Kompakt A1-B1) is pretty poor. I've spoken with others on the course and they agree - it isn't clearly laid out, and the exercises aren't helpful. For Semester 2, I decided I would just make a masterlist of all the grammar topics that we need to learn and use other resources to learn them. (Intending to use Hammer's German Grammar and Usage with the accompanying practice book).
Let me restate, it is a lot of work. It usually takes at least a year and a half, probably closer to two, to get from nothing to A2/B1 - you are expected to do so in around eight months. Compared to my school experience with French, it is night and day. Even those on my course who studied German a little before coming were surprised at how much there was, despite it being a beginners course. But if you have the motivation, willpower and ability to keep up, you'll manage fine. I'd be happy to answer any more specific questions if you have any, but such is my experience thus far.

Reply 2

Original post
by hfmacleo
I am currently studying German ab initio at Edinburgh, and all in all I think it's a pretty good course. The lecturers and tutorial leaders are great, and the material is generally good - they lay out what topics we need to learn very clearly. It is really intense, but if you're up to it then it's worth the effort.
That being said, the coursebook recommended (DaF Kompakt A1-B1) is pretty poor. I've spoken with others on the course and they agree - it isn't clearly laid out, and the exercises aren't helpful. For Semester 2, I decided I would just make a masterlist of all the grammar topics that we need to learn and use other resources to learn them. (Intending to use Hammer's German Grammar and Usage with the accompanying practice book).
Let me restate, it is a lot of work. It usually takes at least a year and a half, probably closer to two, to get from nothing to A2/B1 - you are expected to do so in around eight months. Compared to my school experience with French, it is night and day. Even those on my course who studied German a little before coming were surprised at how much there was, despite it being a beginners course. But if you have the motivation, willpower and ability to keep up, you'll manage fine. I'd be happy to answer any more specific questions if you have any, but such is my experience thus far.

Omg thankyou so much for taking the time to write this I really appreciate it!! I’d be studying it with politics so I don’t know if that would make it less or more intense, but I absolutely love the sound of the film/history modules so my main worry is the language learning itself. I do think I’d have the motivation as it seems so rewarding & would definitely be useful for what I want to do in the future, but at the same time I haven’t done a language since GCSE so I am worried about starting completely fresh and then not being ‘good’ at it. How many hours would you say you are revising per day//if you aren’t in first year anymore how is the workload in comparison ? :smile:
(edited 1 month ago)

Quick Reply

How The Student Room is moderated

To keep The Student Room safe for everyone, we moderate posts that are added to the site.