The Student Room Group

boyfriend and his ex

hey. well here goes....I have been with my boyfriend for 6 months. Before we met he had been in a 5 year relationship (he split up with her about 7 months before we met.) They split up on mutual terms and she now has a new bf. However they are still v.good friends and talk on phone occasionally. They met up over xmas for a drink and she told him 'she doesnt want to die not knowing whether they could have worked out.' He says although he still cares about her there is no love there and he couldnt get back with her.
They are planning to meet again over easter and I jst cant help feeling that I am just passing time until the day they get back together.
Help some1!! Should I jst trust what he says or do i have a right to b worried.
H x

Scroll to see replies

giddychick
hey. well here goes....I have been with my boyfriend for 6 months. Before we met he had been in a 5 year relationship (he split up with her about 7 months before we met.) They split up on mutual terms and she now has a new bf. However they are still v.good friends and talk on phone occasionally. They met up over xmas for a drink and she told him 'she doesnt want to die not knowing whether they could have worked out.' He says although he still cares about her there is no love there and he couldnt get back with her.
They are planning to meet again over easter and I jst cant help feeling that I am just passing time until the day they get back together.
Help some1!! Should I jst trust what he says or do i have a right to b worried.
H x



hi there im so glad to read your post!!!
i'd fancied my ex since yr 7. we got together two years later and were together for 5 yrs. we broke up just before uni cos i thought he was cheating on me. in november i found out he wasnt ever cheating on me and hasnt seen anyone since then. i met a guy when i started uni and we were seeing each other. but we went for a drink in december, and i told him that i found out my ex didnt cheat on me. then i started crying really much. my bf was really nice and took me home. but then he didnt speak to me for two weeks and says he doesnt like me anymore. althogh he did buy me a rose to make up for ignoring me.

its so interesting to hear the other side to the arguement. i thought my bf was being insecure and unreasonable, and he wont even admit this is the reason he stopped speaking to me.

what do u think?

im certain if ur bf says its over then its over n u should trust him
Reply 2
I say trust him.. it was him who said that there was no love there, after all. Plus, you've been together six months which is a decent amount of time, I doubt you'd have lasted that long if he wanted to get back together with her! However, I would talk to him about it- tell him that you do trust him, but you're worried.. hopefully he'll tell you that there's no chance and you'll feel more secure :smile:
Reply 3
I suppose I can see where your boyf is coming from...its not a nice feeling feeling that the person you are going out with would rather b with some1 else (i dont know if thats how he feels!) A lot of me does trust him but there is part of me that thinks once she moves back home (they split cos the pressure of her being at uni was too much) the thing that stopped them being together will have gone and they'll both realise they want to b togther!
Reply 4
lessthanthree
It seems as though she's more in to him as he is in to her.

You have no option but to trust him, since he is your boyfriend, and it wouldn't be in your interests to stifle him and tell him he can't see her.

This sounds totally harsh, but it's not intended that way:

Basically; if he says he wants to be with you, and has remained with you, you have a reason to trust him. If she wants him, but he is the guy for you, he'll resist her advances.

If he does still like her and wants to get back with her, there is absolutely nothing you can do about it.

IF he likes her and you don't let him go, you'll be stuck in a relationship with a guy who prefers another girl. IF he likes her and you do let him see her,you will have lost a guy who liked another girl better. Neither of these situations are favourable, but they're the realistic options if he does still like her.

IF he is true to his word, and he doesn't like her and you don't let him go, he'll think you don't trust him. IF you do let him go, he'll feel good that you trust him, and he'll love you all the more for it.

Of course you have a right to be worried, but you can be safe in the knowledge that they broke up for a reason, and thus couldn't "work it out" - he's bound to see this if he's any kind of man.

I hope it goes well for you, and that he's true to his word. This sort of thing is the BIG test for couples.



yeah, i agree with all of that! Although i dont like him meeting up with her I would never say to him 'u can't go' because I do know how much he cares for her and wants to know what she's doing with her life. Plus if i said no i think it would lead to more problems, not only would he think i didnt trust him he'd probably resent me for it too.
giddychick
I suppose I can see where your boyf is coming from...its not a nice feeling feeling that the person you are going out with would rather b with some1 else (i dont know if thats how he feels!) A lot of me does trust him but there is part of me that thinks once she moves back home (they split cos the pressure of her being at uni was too much) the thing that stopped them being together will have gone and they'll both realise they want to b togther!


this seems to be how my bf felt! me and my ex split up cos i thought he cheated on me. but when i found out he didnt i was really hurt in front of my bf, so he must have thought i wanted to get back with him. "the thing that stopped them being together will have gone and they'll both realise they want to b togther" seems to be how he feels.

what should people like me/ur bf do to reassure people like u and my bf?
i've told him it'll never happen but he still broke up with me.

the way i see it: if he gets back with her, it means he was using u cos she was too far away. dont take 2nd best girl, find a decent guy. its better o be with some1 who loves U not someone who want to be with someoen else.

im fairly certain if his gf know he's with someoen else, she'll back off. try to meet her and be frinds with her.
lessthanthree
It seems as though she's more in to him as he is in to her.

You have no option but to trust him, since he is your boyfriend, and it wouldn't be in your interests to stifle him and tell him he can't see her.

IF he is true to his word, and he doesn't like her and you don't let him go, he'll think you don't trust him. IF you do let him go, he'll feel good that you trust him, and he'll love you all the more for it.


i agree. my bf didnt trust me clearly

I hope it goes well for you, and that he's true to his word. This sort of thing is the BIG test for couples.

:eek: really?
Reply 7
you should trust him. he told you what happened last time, and he told you he was gonna meet up with her. if he wanted anything to happen, i doubt he would have told you.
Reply 8
magiccarpet
this seems to be how my bf felt! me and my ex split up cos i thought he cheated on me. but when i found out he didnt i was really hurt in front of my bf, so he must have thought i wanted to get back with him. "the thing that stopped them being together will have gone and they'll both realise they want to b togther" seems to be how he feels.

what should people like me/ur bf do to reassure people like u and my bf?
i've told him it'll never happen but he still broke up with me.

the way i see it: if he gets back with her, it means he was using u cos she was too far away. dont take 2nd best girl, find a decent guy. its better o be with some1 who loves U not someone who want to be with someoen else.

im fairly certain if his gf know he's with someoen else, she'll back off. try to meet her and be frinds with her.


Well im not sure what he/u can do really. He has told me time and time again he wont get back together with her a) cos he loves me and b) he couldnt imagine doin anything romantic with her. At the time I believe him but then if im feeling a bit down and start to think about it I jst worry. I think the only thing u can do is show it and not get back with your ex. My bf talks about his ex alot but he says she basically was the last 5 yrs of his life so any conversation for example holidays, birthdays usually involves her. I dont want to finish him over something that might not happen, the way i see it is that the only way Im goin to know is to stick with him and risk getting hurt in the end
Reply 9
hmm theres always something between ex's and they can hardly ever be friends afterwards
giddychick
Well im not sure what he/u can do really. He has told me time and time again he wont get back together with her a) cos he loves me and b) he couldnt imagine doin anything romantic with her. At the time I believe him but then if im feeling a bit down and start to think about it I jst worry. I think the only thing u can do is show it and not get back with your ex. My bf talks about his ex alot but he says she basically was the last 5 yrs of his life so any conversation for example holidays, birthdays usually involves her. I dont want to finish him over something that might not happen, the way i see it is that the only way Im goin to know is to stick with him and risk getting hurt in the end


omg i hardly ever talk about my ex.and i cut him out totally. i dont speak to him see him, destroyed all pics and gifts from him. its as if he never was cos im so hurt.

amo1
hmm theres always something between ex's and they can hardly ever be friends afterwards


this is true. hence why i dont speak to or about mine as we'd just fight then get back together for more of the same. i dont intend to see him ever again.. dont encourage them to be friends. and its ok to be jealous. i would be. it shows u care. just dont be unreasonable.after that length of time there will always be the need to know if it would work out, if they are fated t be together etc. tell the guy how u feel.
Reply 11
magiccarpet - this thread is not about u and ur ex!
giddychick - you have to trust him with what hes told you, he does sound genuine and im sure he wouldnt stay with you if he still had feelings for someone else.
lessthanthree is right - its a big test and if you can get through it ur relationship will be all the better for it.
best of luck :smile:
mangomaz
magiccarpet - this thread is not about u and ur ex!
giddychick - you have to trust him with what hes told you, he does sound genuine and im sure he wouldnt stay with you if he still had feelings for someone else.
lessthanthree is right - its a big test and if you can get through it ur relationship will be all the better for it.
best of luck :smile:


no but the situation between me and my ex and my bf is exactly the same as giddychick's, except the other way round (ie im the one just out of a 5 yr relationship, he's the injured party)

yes it is a big test but i think even for them to be friends, especially if they only broke up recently, is very very hard. i know i'd either angry at my ex, or get back with him.

all you can do is trust him. but remember girl, if it feels wrong then it is wrong and if u r unhappy u should dump him
Reply 13
magiccarpet
no but the situation between me and my ex and my bf is exactly the same as giddychick's, except the other way round (ie im the one just out of a 5 yr relationship, he's the injured party)

yes it is a big test but i think even for them to be friends, especially if they only broke up recently, is very very hard. i know i'd either angry at my ex, or get back with him.

all you can do is trust him. but remember girl, if it feels wrong then it is wrong and if u r unhappy u should dump him


They broke up last May so its been a while. Im going to talk to him about it and really let him know how uncomfortable him seeing her makes me feel, ive decided its me he's going out with me and so ultimately its me he should care more about upsetting!
damn right.

but dont come across as unreasonable.just say you dont feel comfortable with it, and either he respects that (ie doesnt see her) or you leave. make him choose to see where his loyalty lies. but then if he choose you you know u can trust him

may is quite recent for 5 yr relationship. mine ended last may, too as we broke up school.i still get upset n jealous if my ex sees another girl.so just be careful
Reply 15
giddy chick, I exactly have the same problem as yours... his ex still loves him. i want to kill her! but anyway, as what others had said, u must trust ur boy, simply because he is your boyfriend.
I think you are justified in feeling a little nervous about this - it would unsettle pretty much anyone, but dont worry too much. I'd worry too if this was me, but it really does sound like he wants to be with you, not her, and she is more keen than him.
Me and my ex are still great friends, and talk every few night for a few hours on the phone. He still wants me back but is quiet and undemanding about it..he's accepted its not going to happen, and I know I'd never ever ever get back together with him, even though I still like him as a person and want to be his friend, so sometimes people really do have no dodgy intentions towards their ex! On top of this my best friend is male, so I'd understand if any boyfriend of mine felt I was surrounded by males who might take me away and felt a little nervous. I hope your boyfriend is being understanding about your fears, so trust him to have enough willpower - and good luck :smile:
Reply 17
amo1
hmm theres always something between ex's and they can hardly ever be friends afterwards


:eek: I disagree - I'm still friends with guys I've been out with, and there's no romantic interest there whatsoever.

I reckon since he's the one that told her there was no love, there actually isn't. And since she seems the one who wants to go back out again, if he wanted to then surely they would have by now? What you say about him 'only passing time with you until he can get back to her' (or something along those lines) - sorry if this sounds harsh, but if that was true I think he'd have done it by now.

I don't think you really need to worry :smile:
amo1
hmm theres always something between ex's and they can hardly ever be friends afterwards


Not true. I went out for lunch with my ex the other day and we had a great time. The atmosphere was fine. If anything, it confirmed to me the fact that it never would have worked out between us, and although what we had was great while it lasted, we are not "meant to be" together.

Three months ago, I was still begging this guy to take me back. I think you should trust your boyfriend, and even give his ex-girlfriend a break. She just needs a little more time to come to terms with the situation. If I were you, I'd speak to your boyfriend and say that whilst you trust him, you're a little concerned about the fact that she still wants to be with him. Tell him to still be friends with her, but make it clear to her that it's over.
Reply 19
don't worry~ you are not alone~
i tell you, my boy's ex still telling him she misses him a lot and all those things, but my boy still loves me only. and this means that she won't have chance to get back to him unless i let him go. :wink: