You are Here: Home >< Physics

# AS Pair Production Query watch

1. Question:
Explain why a photon of energy 2MeV could produce an electron-positron pair but not an proton-antiproton pair.

I understand that rest mass of electron is less than proton but problem is that i have no figures to back up the 2MeV bit.

I tried doing rest mass of electron times two divided by 1.6x10^-13 and rest mass of proton times two divided by 1.6x10^-13.

I get for...
...electron - 1.138875x10^-17 and ...proton - 2.09125x10^-14.

They are the correct respective side of 2 but too many decimal places out.

Cheers
2. (Original post by Stupiemountain)
Question:
Explain why a photon of energy 2MeV could produce an electron-positron pair but not an proton-antiproton pair.

I understand that rest mass of electron is less than proton but problem is that i have no figures to back up the 2MeV bit.

I tried doing rest mass of electron times two divided by 1.6x10^-13 and rest mass of proton times two divided by 1.6x10^-13.

I get for...
...electron - 1.138875x10^-17 and ...proton - 2.09125x10^-14.

They are the correct respective side of 2 but too many decimal places out.

Cheers
A little tip for you: it's probably worth sticking to units of MeV rather than having confusing standard form all over the place. And remember your significant figures please

I think as you have already identified, if the rest mass energy of the particle pair is greater than the energy of the photon, then pair production cannot occur (due to conservation of energy).

Know that . So for production of a pair, by , this requires at least of photon energy, which is . Thus this pair production cannot occur.

Clearly , thus pair production can occur.

(There is another subtlety here to do with conservation of momentum - meaning that the energy of the photon must actually be greater than - but this can be ignored for now.)
3. What is mp

TSR Support Team

We have a brilliant team of more than 60 Support Team members looking after discussions on The Student Room, helping to make it a fun, safe and useful place to hang out.

This forum is supported by:
Updated: March 26, 2018
Today on TSR

### Cambridge interviews

Find out which colleges are sending invitations

### University open days

• University of East Anglia
Fri, 23 Nov '18
• Norwich University of the Arts
Fri, 23 Nov '18
• Edge Hill University