The Student Room Group

Does anyone have really terrible lecturers who don't care about their students?

It's all in the title really. 90% of my lecturers offer no help with the modules they teach. They are never there during their office hours, and they don't take questions at the end of lectures.

I have been to see the head of the department and all he said was go and
complain to the lecturers concerned. So I have to complain to the lecturer
I'm complaining about. Even the most confident student would struggle with
that. I actually know someone on my course who has done this and the lecturer said 'this is uni not primary school, you have to deal with problems
yourself'

All my course mates feel the same as me, so I guess we will have to help each other through the degree.

I am interested to hear if anyone else has had similar experiences. It feels
so unfair as we pay a lot to study at uni, and some lecturers are ripping us
off.

Scroll to see replies

Reply 1

I would have no problem complaining to the lecturer, but it might not help in this case.
Unfortunately, a lot of them are PhD students and lecturing is not their biggest priority. They do their hours, and after that it's a no-go.

Pot luck I'm afraid. Not a whole lot you can do about it if they're all like that, really.

Reply 2

Some are far more involved with their research than teaching undergrads. Some are just utterly incompetent lectures. I think I have a good bunch, there's maybe one lecturer who's a bit poor. Well, probably more inexperienced as he's just finished his PhD. A lecturer I had in my first year, who looks like William Hague (he's a politics lecturer, so quite apt), certainly knows his stuff but his lectures were quite tedious. This is a combination of the dry course and lecturing.

So you don't have year tutors or course reps?

Reply 3

You've got to bear in mind that most lecturers are selected for the research ability and are given no formal training and very little support in delivering their teaching. Hence some are good but many aren't. Go back to the head of department (or whomever is responsible for teaching in you department) and say this is a general problem with the course and that many students feel the same way about the lack of support offered and the quality of teaching standards. You need to speak in terms they understand (i.e. mentioning the words 'quality' and 'support' and ensure that you have support from your classmates.

Reply 4

River85
Some are far more involved with their research than teaching undergrads. Some are just utterly incompetent lectures. I think I have a good bunch, there's maybe one lecturer who's a bit poor. Well, probably more inexperienced as he's just finished his PhD. A lecturer I had in my first year, who looks like William Hague (he's a politics lecturer, so quite apt), certainly knows his stuff but his lectures were quite tedious. This is a combination of the dry course and lecturing.

So you don't have year tutors or course reps?



I have had 3 personal tutors since september, I don't know why they keep changing. Their only function seems to be giving out exam results (I don't think they are expected to do anything else), there is no student-tutor relationship at all.

There are no course reps I checked that a while ago (I don't think they would achieve anything anyway).

Thanks for your comments, I liked the one about William Hague...

Reply 5

robertsmiths

Thanks for your comments, I liked the one about William Hague...


No you didn't. Don't lie :p:

http://www.dur.ac.uk/sgia/profiles/?mode=staff&id=567

He looks more like WH in real life.

Anyway, please take Chemistboy's advice. It's true that lecturers are chosen more for research then teaching. It just turns out that some are great teachers, not only do they know their stuff and deliver it appropriately but they're inspirational characters and helpful. Many are adequate and some are totally incompetent teachers (certainly researchers first and teachers second).

If you don't have a course rep or a member of staff who acts as a year tutor then please see your head of department again and make sure he knows it's not just you who's having problems. He/she is far more likely to take your views seriously. How many other students are disatisfied, in your experience?

Reply 6

I sometimes wonder why we have pay for a degree? The timetable is more part time that full time, it's well known that a degree is more "independent" learning, there are no mock exams or practice essay titles (at least in my course). The lectures are based on going over powerpoint slides which you can do your self. You literally have to hunt lecturers down.
Now college seems like something worth paying for. You are there almost everyday, for several hours a day, you do mock exams and practice essays, teachers actually teach and give up most of their day to do this. They guide you step by step (whilst not baby feeding you). They actually keep track of you, to make sure you are not dossing about. Yes, i realise the purpose of uni is to "prepare" you (although even in the "real" world, you are actually monitored and assessed reg. and you are not just left to do whatever). But is it worth paying for? Uni can stay working as it does..but paying £3145 a year for it? (Not that i think we should pay for college, just comparing the two).

Reply 7

Carmen_2008
I sometimes wonder why we have pay for a degree? The timetable is more part time that full time, it's well known that a degree is more "independent" learning, there are no mock exams or practice essay titles (at least in my course). The lectures are based on going over powerpoint slides which you can do your self. You literally have to hunt lecturers down.
Now college seems like something worth paying for. You are there almost everyday, for several hours a day, you do mock exams and practice essays, teachers actually teach and give up most of their day to do this. They guide you step by step (whilst not baby feeding you). They actually keep track of you, to make sure you are not dossing about. Yes, i realise the purpose of uni is to "prepare" you (although even in the "real" world, you are actually monitored and assessed reg. and you are not just left to do whatever). But is it worth paying for? Uni can stay working as it does..but paying £3145 a year for it? (Not that i think we should pay for college, just comparing the two).


Well lecturers earn tiny salaries, at least compared to other public sector workers of similar ability.

If anything, we should be paying MORE.

And really, university is an investment in your future. It may not directly be proportional to the cost, but it'll help you vastly in the job market.

Reply 8

johnbrown
I swear lecturers start on like £30,000 - that's not a tiny salary. Although obviously they will have had to invest a lot in their education. It's hardly a really stressful job is it, there's worse things they could be doing especially considering they probably like LOVE their subject. If I was that passionate about a subject I can't think of anything better than spend my whole days teaching, researching and reading about it


£30k? That's pretty good. I got the impression they were all dirt poor.

But yeah that's why the wages are low in teaching generally, people are so passionate as to accept lower pay for doing what they love.

Reply 9

Some of my lecturers are absolutely appalling. They just can't lecture well at all... :s-smilie:

Reply 10

I have the impression with some that they are there to do their research, and that teaching is just an inconvenience that comes with the job.
Particularly if they have to teach a course that's not in their area of interest.

Reply 11

ChemistBoy
You've got to bear in mind that most lecturers are selected for the research ability and are given no formal training and very little support in delivering their teaching. Hence some are good but many aren't. Go back to the head of department (or whomever is responsible for teaching in you department) and say this is a general problem with the course and that many students feel the same way about the lack of support offered and the quality of teaching standards. You need to speak in terms they understand (i.e. mentioning the words 'quality' and 'support' and ensure that you have support from your classmates.



wow, I had no idea lecturers are selected for their research ability (I'm sure most students are not aware of this). I also naively assumed they would have to go on some sort of lecturer training course. It all makes sense now, on my course (and I would think many more) students are nothing more than an inconvenience...

Reply 12

robertsmiths
wow, I had no idea lecturers are selected for their research ability (I'm sure most students are not aware of this). I also naively assumed they would have to go on some sort of lecturer training course. It all makes sense now, on my course (and I would think many more) students are nothing more than an inconvenience...

That's why league tables like THES are unreliable. They put a big weighting on research when really for undergraduate you want the main focus to be teaching instead of the lecturers spending all their time on their own research.

Reply 13

Callum828
£30k? That's pretty good. I got the impression they were all dirt poor.

But yeah that's why the wages are low in teaching generally, people are so passionate as to accept lower pay for doing what they love.



I thought they earned very little, I have looked it up and the average pay for a lecturer is £36,489. Here is the website I got this from: http://www.timeshighereducation.co.uk/story.asp?storyCode=401025&sectioncode=26

I'm very surprised by how much they earn.

Reply 14

robertsmiths
wow, I had no idea lecturers are selected for their research ability (I'm sure most students are not aware of this). I also naively assumed they would have to go on some sort of lecturer training course. It all makes sense now, on my course (and I would think many more) students are nothing more than an inconvenience...


It varies between universities. The top universities in our country are very research focussed and teaching ability is very much secondary on the list of top CV points to possess when look for an academic job - in fact just having teaching experience (with no reference to quality) is enough. New universities (such as Nottingham Trent) are more teaching focussed due to their backgrounds as polytechnics and colleges of further and higher education - academics teaching loads are higher and their teaching ability is generally more scrutinised.

There is the PGCHE but this a very basic part-time course that isn't that great (according the experience of my colleagues who have taken it. It is also option at most universities rather than a requirement.

I got fairly far down the road to being an academic and I had relatively little teaching experience and that certainly wasn't important for gaining post-doctoral positions and your first job - it was all about research.

Reply 15

Callum828
£30k? That's pretty good. I got the impression they were all dirt poor.

But yeah that's why the wages are low in teaching generally, people are so passionate as to accept lower pay for doing what they love.


I thought lecturers earned very little. I have looked it up and the average pay for a lecturer is £36,489. This is the site I looked at: http://www.timeshighereducation.co.uk/story.asp?storyCode=401025&sectioncode=26

I'm surprised they earn so much.

Reply 16

I've had a few who decided to shout at us, not help and tell us we were thick among some things. I went to other lecturers who reported the bad ones to their boss and raised the issue through one of the committees.

Reply 17

haha that's quite funny
(edited 4 years ago)

Reply 18

robertsmiths
I thought lecturers earned very little. I have looked it up and the average pay for a lecturer is £36,489. This is the site I looked at: http://www.timeshighereducation.co.uk/story.asp?storyCode=401025&sectioncode=26

I'm surprised they earn so much.


I don't think anyone would argue that £35k is bad as an average wage. However, most don't get anywhere near that wage until 30-35 or so, which is less than my accountant, lawyer and doctor friends can expect to pick up by that age. Academic staff certainly don't live in penury but for professionals with several degrees they don't rake it in by any means.

Reply 19

Do lecturers get fired?
Just that comment at the bottom of the times article about 'permanent lectureship'...