I'm looking for a touch screen music phone.
The Nokia has more bass and more customizable for music, yet the renoir has an amazing camera too... The cookie is a third choice, since I can get a contract for £12.50 p/m (18months)
All have contracts for £20 to £30, so the price is no different.
I can speak for Orange only.
Nokia 5800 is a very good music phone comes with an 8GB memory card at the moment.
Renior is more focused on the camera - the interface is very different as well. Have a look in store and you can tell the small differences.
Nokia on the whole I would say are more reliable, battery life is very good as well.
Cookie is OK. Basically a low-end user phone, that's why it's available on PAYG and cheaper contracts. The Renoir and 5800 are out of its league.
Personally I would go for the 5800. Nokia brand is appealing but he size and shape of the phone I prefer and the Renoir's camera doesn't swing it for me.