The Student Room Logo

Choosing an Oxford College

Scroll to see replies

Reply 700
mavoury
the specialites of the collgege fellows in your subject

This doesn't *much* matter, because: (1) You get taught by people at many different colleges (this is less true the more fellows your college has in your subject, obviously; but with just 1 English fellow at Newnham, I get to go all over the place and it's awesome!); (2) You can always just ask someone you like to supervise you for the bigger stuff like dissertations -- you don't have to wait to be told...; and -- probably most importantly -- (3) You will probably change your mind about your interests whilst you're here (in most cases, if this didn't happen then I'd be worried!). What you think you're interested in now is probably irrelevant. Also, dudes, most people here can teach things apart from their own 'specialisms'! That's a really restrictive way of looking at the fellows' abilities, often...(and a very rigd way of vieing Cambridge's educational system).

I understand why people think they need to emphasise this aspect, but it isn't really important (excapt, perhaps, in a few cases).

Glutamic Acid
Yeah but, unless I'm misinformed, your college will have a large role in your time there.
It is. But *which* college you're at is far less important. Each, of course, has it's own distinctive feel & characteristics, but they vary very often. And, as people, repeatedly say, the vast majority of students end up very happy wherever they are. Remember, too, the pooling system: hundreds of people pooled every year to a college they didn't choose...and the vast majority of them aren't at ALL unhappy with that. Why? Because it simply doesn't often matter. Your college will form a large part of your experience here, but it doesn't really matter which experience you end up having! (I've not explained that well...)

Helenia
But if you don't want to go to any of them for any reason, try to pick a college, as they seem to be the ones receiving the most open applicants. For me, I really didn't want an all-girls college, so knew avoiding open application was a good idea

Absolutely.
But, also, don't demonise the female colleges, or those further out, or those that are modern, or whatever -- you could quite conceivably get a pool offer from them, and it would be daft to make them out to be tremendously awful. :wink:
Reply 701
Something no-one's mentioned: different colleges have different application proceedures, which certainly influenced my decision.

Not sure how it works for your subject, but some colleges might do exams as well as interviews, and some might not, and some might ask for submitted examples of work/essays before interview or whatever.

Also bear in mind how many ppl doing your course each college takes on - do you want to be with a crowd of 10, or maybe with just 1 or 2 other people?

Personally, since I didn't think I had any suitable essays to submit, I made a shortlist of colleges that didn't want essays, then cut that down by choosing those with a reasonable number of places for the course, and then chose one by coming to Cambridge, wandering around, and picking one which looked nice (lots of old mellow red bricks appealed to me, heh) :biggrin:
Reply 702
Tom
Something no-one's mentioned: different colleges have different application proceedures, which certainly influenced my decision.

Not sure how it works for your subject, but some colleges might do exams as well as interviews, and some might not, and some might ask for submitted examples of work/essays before interview or whatever.

Also bear in mind how many ppl doing your course each college takes on - do you want to be with a crowd of 10, or maybe with just 1 or 2 other people?

Personally, since I didn't think I had any suitable essays to submit, I made a shortlist of colleges that didn't want essays, then cut that down by choosing those with a reasonable number of places for the course, and then chose one by coming to Cambridge, wandering around, and picking one which looked nice (lots of old mellow red bricks appealed to me, heh)

Ah, yes! I'd forgotten about testy things, and you're right.
Saying that, I had a shortlist of ones that didn't want a test at interview...but then visited Cambridge, saw Newnham, decided on the spot to apply to it...and had to do their test. :wink: :biggrin:
Mr. Ed

In my interview, when they said 'why did you pick Clare', I said I liked the pictures :cool:

I thought they wernt supposed to ask that as people could have made an open application :confused:
thelostchild
I thought they wernt supposed to ask that as people could have made an open application :confused:


They are allowed to be inquisitive, you know. There is no such thing as unlawful discrimination over the college choice.
A very very easy way.... Write loads of names on pieces of paper and put it into a hat then pick one which your choice will be :biggrin:

Always works :wink:
I don't think anyone's mentioned this already, but you might want to check out what the list of colleges that actually offer architecture is becuase not all of them do (Catz doesn't for example) and that would cut your list of possibilities down a bit...

edit: on closer inspection of google... catz, homerton, christs and corpus christi don't offer it, so they're not options for you...
Reply 707
Mr. Ed
Take a look at the map, and see which college is closest to the Architecture faculty :wink:

In my interview, when they said 'why did you pick Clare', I said I liked the pictures :cool:



Genuinely, that was the deciding factor for me between Queens' and the other colleges I liked.

On my map in the prospectus, I drew a circle around the law faculty and visted the ones inside the circle. Queens' just happened to be the first one I went to see and the closest to the law faculty (and the town centre).

Although, I managed to blag my 'Why Queens'?' question in the interview slightly better :p:
Reply 708
epitome
But, also, don't demonise the female colleges, or those further out, or those that are modern, or whatever -- you could quite conceivably get a pool offer from them, and it would be daft to make them out to be tremendously awful. :wink:

Oh no, absolutely not. If I had been pooled to any of them (though Homerton don't do Medicine so I wouldn't have gone there), I would probably have ended up loving them if I had come. It would have made my decision to come here much harder back then though, so I might have ended up going elsewhere, because at the time I really didn't want to go to a girls' college. I know with 5 years' hindsight that it's not really the case, but I was so shy and had such a crap record with men that I thought if I went to a girls' college I'd never stand a chance! Plus after 5 years in a girls' boarding house, I wanted a bit more variety and less bitchiness - again, now I've been here ages I know this wouldn't necessarily have been the case, but this is what my views at the time were (and I didn't have TSR to tell me differently!).

Of course now it's easy to say I'd have been happy at any of the colleges if I'd been pooled there. But I had different views and priorities 6/7 years ago.
Good bloke
They are allowed to be inquisitive, you know. There is no such thing as unlawful discrimination over the college choice.

yea I can understand that, but on here
http://www.admin.cam.ac.uk/offices/admissions/handbook/appendices/interviewinfo.doc
which is the information the interviewers get for interviewing it says

The Admissions Forum has agreed that applicants should not be asked why they have chosen to apply to a particular College, as some will have submitted an Open application and therefore been allocated to rather than choosing a particular College. It is also difficult to see how such a question will elicit any worthwhile information about the applicant’s academic ability or potential.
Reply 710
I'd recommend looking at the stats for applications and offers. Using that information you can whittle it down to around 5-8 colleges, and then pick the one that you like :smile:
thelostchild
yea I can understand that, but on here
http://www.admin.cam.ac.uk/offices/admissions/handbook/appendices/interviewinfo.doc
which is the information the interviewers get for interviewing it says


Yes, the question is not a very helpful one but neither is asking how the journey to the university was, or asking if it will rain later and questions such as these are also commonly used as ice breakers with no intention of using them formally in the selection process.
Out of interest, are some colleges known to more forgiving with regards to waiving the GCSE Foreign Language requirement?
Reply 713
So far as I know its pretty much generally waived now.
Thanks. That's good to hear.
Reply 715
There is, in fact, a motion going to the Senate House soon-ish, to drop the requirement altogether. But I don't know how long that will take to filter down.
Just as a few points of information:

College choice counts for LESS for Architecture, because as a subject it is VERY centralised; you'll spend a very large majority of your time in the department. You may also be the only person in your college year doing Architecture.

Consider applying to a college that's close(ish) to the department (Peterhouse, etc.) because you won't want to mess around and spend all your time travelling to and from the department.
Reply 717
College choice counts for LESS for Architecture, because as a subject it is VERY centralised; you'll spend a very large majority of your time in the department. You may also be the only person in your college year doing Architecture.

Yup.
But...some colleges have rooms specifically for Architecture students (because of the amount of space/light you need). You might want to look into this as a factor? It gives you less of a choice of room, though, which might be a bit pants. We don't have designated rooms at Newnham, but our Architect just asked to change because she needed more space, and they let her. :smile:
epitome
Yup.
But...some colleges have rooms specifically for Architecture students (because of the amount of space/light you need). You might want to look into this as a factor? It gives you less of a choice of room, though, which might be a bit pants. We don't have designated rooms at Newnham, but our Architect just asked to change because she needed more space, and they let her. :smile:


Wow, really? I know that one of architects lives in the room in our gatehouse. Not exactly the most spacious or light place I can think of. :tongue:
epitome
Yup.
But...some colleges have rooms specifically for Architecture students (because of the amount of space/light you need). You might want to look into this as a factor? It gives you less of a choice of room, though, which might be a bit pants. We don't have designated rooms at Newnham, but our Architect just asked to change because she needed more space, and they let her. :smile:


Amy didn't get one of them :p:

Quick Reply

Latest