The Killers, by a mile. There's always gonna be sad indie freaks who class them as pop, or that they're too mainstream, but they are an indie band. And a great one at that. Their best song has to be Mr. Brightside, but their album is full of gems (All These Things That I've Done, Smile Like You Mean It, On Top, Andy You're A Star, Under The Gun, Believe Me Natalie, Who Let You Go etc). However, does anyone else think that Somebody Told Me is their shittest song, even though it's regarded as their most successful? The album's great though. Jenny Was A Friend of Mine is a bit irratating though - the song on the whole is good, it's just the chorus pisses me off!
Anyway, yeah The Killers by far - fantastically talented. And Brandon Flowers is gorgeous! The Used are *****, but to be honest, I've never heard of the other band.