The Student Room Group

Scroll to see replies

Reply 2



That would be integrating f(x) * g(x) ?

I dont think you can, or maybe you can but it would be useless.

When you differentiate an implicit function, you are differentiating each term with respect to a rate of change to another variable.

When integrating an explicit function, the function itself is a rate of change of its area, so when you have an implicit function and you integrate it you might mess things up :s-smilie:

Though im not sure :smile:

Reply 3

ShortRef
That would be integrating f(x) * g(x) ?

I dont think you can, or maybe you can but it would be useless.

When you differentiate an implicit function, you are differentiating each term with respect to a rate of change to another variable.

When integrating an explicit function, the function itself is a rate of change of its area, so when you have an implicit function and you integrate it you might mess things up :s-smilie:

Though im not sure :smile:


Okay I'm wrong :o: I can't think of anything else that may help now though :s-smilie: , sorry OP.

Reply 4

yup, exactly that sort of thing.

+ thanks Shortref and scott8anthony

Reply 5

I dont know if im right....:smile:

Reply 6

hmm, ok, thanks for your help :smile:

shortref, wouldn't it be useful if you were given a derived function in the form f(xy) and you wanted to find the original function?

Reply 7

FatNoel
hmm, ok, thanks for your help :smile:

shortref, wouldn't it be useful if you were given a derived function in the form f(xy) and you wanted to find the original function?


If you were given a derived function in the form f(xy) it would just be a differential equation.

Say x2+y2=1x^2 + y^2 = 1

differentiating this with respect to x

2x+2ydydx=02x + 2y\frac{dy}{dx} = 0

If you wanted to integrate this, you wouldnt need any magical 'implicit integration' but you just need to solve this differential equation.

Reply 8

ShortRef
If you were given a derived function in the form f(xy) it would just be a differential equation.

Say x2+y2=1x^2 + y^2 = 1

differentiating this with respect to x

2x+2y=02x + 2y = 0

If you wanted to integrate this, you wouldnt need any magical 'implicit integration' but you just need to solve this differential equation.


can you do that for something like, say

dydx=xsin(x+y) \frac{dy}{dx} = xsin(x+y)

Reply 9

FatNoel
can you do that for something like, say

dydx=xsin(x+y) \frac{dy}{dx} = xsin(x+y)


then

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple_integral

Reply 10

FatNoel
i was looking at differentiating implicitly ... which got me thinking... how would you integrate an implicit function?

obviously you can do certain ones by recognition but is there a method to do stuff like this?

google didn't shed much light...

any help is much appreciated :smile:

Do you mean functions of the sort F(x,y) = 0?
Which ones can you do by recognition?

Reply 11


That's a different thing to what the OP is asking for I think. Multiple integrals are integrals of a function over a area/domain.

Reply 12

yusufu
Do you mean functions of the sort F(x,y) = 0?
Which ones can you do by recognition?


The volume of a sphere one you could probably do by recognition:

Volume=02πdϕ0πsinθdθ0Rρ2dρ=2π0πsinθR33dθ=23πR3[cosθ]0π=43πR3.\mathrm{Volume} = \int_0^{2 \pi }\, d \phi \int_0^{ \pi } \sin \theta\, d \theta \int_0^R \rho^2\, d \rho = 2 \pi \int_0^{ \pi } \sin \theta \frac{R^3}{3 }\, d \theta = \frac{2}{3 } \pi R^3 [- \cos \theta]_0^{ \pi } = \frac{4}{3 } \pi R^3.

But actually I dont think there are any multivariable functions that you can integrate by recognition :smile:

Reply 13

FatNoel
can you do that for something like, say

dydx=xsin(x+y) \frac{dy}{dx} = xsin(x+y)

I'm afraid not. :frown:

Reply 14

ShortRef
The volume of a sphere one you could probably do by recognition:

Volume=02πdϕ0πsinθdθ0Rρ2dρ=2π0πsinθR33dθ=23πR3[cosθ]0π=43πR3.\mathrm{Volume} = \int_0^{2 \pi }\, d \phi \int_0^{ \pi } \sin \theta\, d \theta \int_0^R \rho^2\, d \rho = 2 \pi \int_0^{ \pi } \sin \theta \frac{R^3}{3 }\, d \theta = \frac{2}{3 } \pi R^3 [- \cos \theta]_0^{ \pi } = \frac{4}{3 } \pi R^3.

But actually I dont think there are any multivariable functions that you can integrate by recognition :smile:

I thought the OP was asking: can you do f(x,y) dx\int f(x,y) \ dx? In which case the answer is a straightforward no.

Reply 15

yusufu
I thought the OP was asking: can you do f(x,y) dx\int f(x,y) \ dx? In which case the answer is a straightforward no.


The multiple integral is a type of definite integral extended to functions of more than one real variable, for example, f(x, y)


Whats wrong with this? Apart from that fact that its definite?

Reply 16

yusufu
Do you mean functions of the sort F(x,y) = 0?
Which ones can you do by recognition?


i was thinking about stuff like

Unparseable latex formula:

\fract {dy}/{dx} = -\fract {x}/{y}



which you could recognise as the gradient function of

x2+y2=c x^2 + y^2 = c

although i phrased it in a pretty crap way.

so it's a big no to integrating stuff given implicitly?

Reply 17

ShortRef
Whats wrong with this? Apart from that fact that its definite?

Multiple integral involves integrating over all the variables. ie. f(x,y)dxdy\int f(x,y) dx dy not f(x,y)dx\int f(x,y) dx.

Reply 18

FatNoel
i was thinking about stuff like

Unparseable latex formula:

\fract {dy}/{dx} = -\fract {x}/{y}



which you could recognise as the gradient function of

x2+y2=c x^2 + y^2 = c

although i phrased it in a pretty crap way.

so it's a big no to integrating stuff given implicitly?


That is just a differential equation....just treat dy and dx as separate differentials and try solve it :smile:

Reply 19

FatNoel
i was thinking about stuff like

Unparseable latex formula:

\fract {dy}/{dx} = -\fract {x}/{y}



which you could recognise as the gradient function of

x2+y2=c x^2 + y^2 = c

although i phrased it in a pretty crap way.

so it's a big no to integrating stuff given implicitly?

Well that has a dy/dx in it, so you're just integrating a differential equation, which is often doable.
Integrating x^2 + y^2 = c (for example) wrt x is something else.