onearmedbandit,
This happened to me (kind of). My right toe became ingrown, and so they normally cut the side off, and burn the roots with acid. But it still would get ingrown. Anyway, this happened twice, and the third time, I said to the lady, get rid of the whole nail, I couldn't stand the cycle of extremely painful injections (they shove it in one side of the toe, and I think the needle is bent slightly, and then shove it around, all this while the patient is in extreme agony, and then they're like, "OK, we need to do the other side now.") and then the swollen toe, and then the watery ingrown area, and not being able to play football for bleeding etc. etc.
I feel for you!