The Student Room Logo
This thread is closed

The Cambridge Chat Thread

Scroll to see replies

Craghyrax
Well if you have any questions I can tell you everything about that. I can also fish out specific good Bourdieu quotes for it, or send you my word document where I just typed up select bits from Outline of a Theory of Practice as I read through it.


That would be really quite appreciated :smile:, thankyou. I've studied him for a couple of years, on and off, obviously not in the depth that you have, and it would be interesting to see another approach to him, even if we both broadly agree with his program.

Craghyrax
I gave Latour a go over the summer after my dissertation supervisor insisted I'd have to know about him to write on Bourdieu. I was very underwhelmed. Maybe I wasn't patient enough.


It depends on what you're looking for in Latour. His major project, besides yet not disimilar from ANT, has been to redress what he sees as a disjunction between the prominence attributed to society over the material world, in which case he is one of the chief taproots of Materialization studies. He seeks, as it were, the place that habitus emerges from. You can encapsulate this approach in that aphorism of his, that "a pilot does not fly, nor does a B-52 bomber; the U.S. airforce flies". Like Giddens, he looks for the structures where technological choice, knowledge, tradition, practice, materiality, and so on, intersect and create the ontological world. He's particularly useful for archaeologists of my approach, those interested in STS (science, technology and society). Have you read Alfred Gell at all? Doing this makes Latour a lot easier to 'position'. I'm more skeptical about his epistemology of science side, but that's not something I have any time to pursue, really :rolleyes:.
Reply 8141
Catsmeat
That would be really quite appreciated :smile:, thankyou. I've studied him for a couple of years, on and off, obviously not in the depth that you have, and it would be interesting to see another approach to him, even if we both broadly agree with his program.

Well not necessarily. Do you want supervision essays or just notes? (my notes are just book extracts) Can you PM your hermes?
Catsmeat

It depends on what you're looking for in Latour. His major project, besides yet not disimilar from ANT, has been to redress what he sees as a disjunction between the prominence attributed to society over the material world, in which case he is one of the chief taproots of Materialization studies. He seeks, as it were, the place that habitus emerges from. You can encapsulate this approach in that aphorism of his, that "a pilot does not fly, nor does a B-52 bomber; the U.S. airforce flies". Like Giddens, he looks for the structures where technological choice, knowledge, tradition, practice, materiality, and so on, intersect and create the ontological world. He's particularly useful for archaeologists of my approach, those interested in STS (science, technology and society). Have you read Alfred Gell at all? Doing this makes Latour a lot easier to 'position'. I'm more skeptical about his epistemology of science side, but that's not something I have any time to pursue, really :rolleyes:.
Yeh that's basically why I didn't get on with him, as that side of things didn't feel as relevant to my areas of interest as a social world focus does. But I should take more time with it.
Is there anything objectively worse than circuits? (in the electricity moving sense, not in the huzzah let's get fit for rowing sense)
BigFudamental
Is there anything objectively worse than circuits? (in the electricity moving sense, not in the huzzah let's get fit for rowing sense)


ML? :p:
Reply 8144
Anyone fancing linking me to this mythical place I can maybe find supervisors reports?
ukdragon37
ML? :p:


:biggrin: Close one. ML I don't dislike as much as I'm just not good at it. Circuits I can hack, but I just loathe them anyway.
Slumpy
Anyone fancing linking me to this mythical place I can maybe find supervisors reports?


http://www.camcors.cam.ac.uk/

Login in the top right (Raven). I get three links, it should be obvious.
Slumpy
Anyone fancing linking me to this mythical place I can maybe find supervisors reports?


http://www.camcors.cam.ac.uk/
BigFudamental
Is there anything objectively worse than circuits? (in the electricity moving sense, not in the huzzah let's get fit for rowing sense)


Yeah, all the mechanics/pendulums swinging stuff before that. I just can't get a handle on it for some reason. Circuits I'm still mince at, but I can blunder through it a bit more easily.
Stratocaster
...

etp
...

(+ any other interested party)

65daysofstatic at the Junction in May.
Reply 8150
TheUnbeliever
http://www.camcors.cam.ac.uk/

Login in the top right (Raven). I get three links, it should be obvious.



Thanks guys.
This years reports unavailable.
Looked over some of last years, pretty depressing reading really!
TheUnbeliever
Yeah, all the mechanics/pendulums swinging stuff before that. I just can't get a handle on it for some reason. Circuits I'm still mince at, but I can blunder through it a bit more easily.


Really? Mechanics is my favourite physics topic by far (which is sad because I don't think it features very heavily after first year).... with circuits it got to the point that I'm handing in incomplete problem sets not so much because I can't do them but because I just can't face the tedium of drudging through the questions...
Reply 8152
and though the news was rather sad, well i just har to laugh...

tey'd seen his face befor;, nobody was really sure if her was from the house of lords...

but i just had to look, having read the book...
:confused:
Reply 8154
BigFudamental
with circuits it got to the point that I'm handing in incomplete problem sets not so much because I can't do them but because I just can't face the tedium of drudging through the questions...


join the club.
Reply 8155
Lindt dark chocolate with chilli is very good :ninja2:
Reply 8156
Ugh, supervisor is being difficult. Emailed us an assignment "due on tuesday", is now sending me and my supervision partner angry emails asking why we haven't handed it in. And they think the supervision was arranged for a time different to what me and my partner have written down - a time I cannot make. So frustrating!
Slumpy
Thanks guys.
This years reports unavailable.
Looked over some of last years, pretty depressing reading really!


Really? :s-smilie:

I'm quite looking forward to next term's ones now I've read some of mine... :o:
Reply 8158
Craghyrax
Lindt dark chocolate with chilli is very good :ninja2:


No. Had it a couple of weeks ago, was not unpleasant, but no more that the sum of its parts.
Reply 8159
Rich19
Ugh, supervisor is being difficult. Emailed us an assignment "due on tuesday", is now sending me and my supervision partner angry emails asking why we haven't handed it in. And they think the supervision was arranged for a time different to what me and my partner have written down - a time I cannot make. So frustrating!

Just email back an icily polite reply pointing that out. They can't expect you to magic up work if you didn't know it was due in because they forgot what time they agreed to.

Latest