The Student Room Logo

Oxford PPE (Philosophy, Politics and Economics) Students and Applicants

Scroll to see replies

jbowles
So basically I've been made an offer on condition that I don't take a gap year - a sacrifice I'm willing to make, to be honest. Pretty shocked, but ofc extremely happy too :biggrin:


First positive result of the year! Congratulations. :danceboy: :thumbsup: :danceboy:

DtS
jbowles
I'm in a slight state of disbelief right now (so figured it was as good a time as any to create an account rather than just lurking all the time!)

I applied for 2010 entry PPE at St. John's this year (i.e. deferred entry, taking a gap year), and had my interviews earlier this week just like everyone else. Anyway, about an hour ago I had a phone call from the admissions secretary, asking whether I would consider 2009 entry instead. I queried why, and was informed that they were formally making me an offer!

So basically I've been made an offer on condition that I don't take a gap year - a sacrifice I'm willing to make, to be honest. Pretty shocked, but ofc extremely happy too :biggrin:


Congrats, and so early. You must've really impressed so well done to you.:yep:
zvorran
If the tutors would want to have any greater accuray the test would have been taken place several times so you write more essays.

The point is, they don't need any greater accuracy; certainly not to the extent of marking loads more essays. They have a huge over-supply of really good applicants.

zvorran
However, they only have 1 essay. That would almost be equivalent to just having one multiple-choice question. Not much room for error.

That's right: and you (probably) were rejected because of that. It's quite simple; you didn't do as well as many others: you got dropped. They have plenty more to choose from. The tutors don't owe you any favours.

Can we leave this now, please?

DtS
Reply 3163
Derek_the_Sheep
The point is, they don't need any greater accuracy; certainly not to the extent of marking loads more essays. They have a huge over-supply of really good applicants.


That's right: and you (probably) were rejected because of that. It's quite simple; you didn't do as well as many others: you got dropped. They have plenty more to choose from. The tutors don't owe you any favours.

Can we leave this now, please?

DtS


Sounds like you're grumpy.

Anyway, if I was rejected because of the considered that my essay was not so great I believe it was an unfair decision, but it was theirs to make, so **** happends.
zvorran
Sounds like you're grumpy.

Anyway, if I was rejected because of the considered that my essay was not so great I believe it was an unfair decision, but it was theirs to make, so **** happends.


You will have been rejected because you didn't have a realistic chance of getting in. From what others have said your grades seem fine so maybe your TSA didn't go well, or your essay wasn't good enough, or maybe you had a poor reference, or even a poor personl statement. All these things are looked at and in their opinion a couple weren't good enough and so you would not have had any chance of getting in even after interview, to invite you would have been a waste of time for the uni and for you. I'm not saying they were right but that's what would've motivated them, just be happy that you will have the opportunity go to another excellent uni.
Reply 3165
zvorran
Sounds like you're grumpy.

Possibly, but he's also right.
Reply 3166
Leviathon
You will have been rejected because you didn't have a realistic chance of getting in. From what others have said your grades seem fine so maybe your TSA didn't go well, or your essay wasn't good enough, or maybe you had a poor reference, or even a poor personl statement. All these things are looked at and in their opinion a couple weren't good enough and so you would not have had any chance of getting in even after interview, to invite you would have been a waste of time for the uni and for you. I'm not saying they were right but that's what would've motivated them, just be happy that you will have the opportunity go to another excellent uni.


If my grades are fine, then the only thing that could have been the reason was that my essay on the TSA wasn't good enough.

I'll just have to wait sometime in January to get feedback on my application.
jbowles
I'm in a slight state of disbelief right now (so figured it was as good a time as any to create an account rather than just lurking all the time!)

I applied for 2010 entry PPE at St. John's this year (i.e. deferred entry, taking a gap year), and had my interviews earlier this week just like everyone else. Anyway, about an hour ago I had a phone call from the admissions secretary, asking whether I would consider 2009 entry instead. I queried why, and was informed that they were formally making me an offer!

So basically I've been made an offer on condition that I don't take a gap year - a sacrifice I'm willing to make, to be honest. Pretty shocked, but ofc extremely happy too :biggrin:

Congratulations!
zvorran
If my grades are fine, then the only thing that could have been the reason was that my essay on the TSA wasn't good enough.


Jesus Christ, how hard is it to read? In all the stuff oxford sends you and on the website they give you a list of things that they consider, and it goes beyond the TSA essay and your grades. So no, your TSA essay wasn't necessarily the only reason.
Reply 3169
Just got rejected by Warwick :frown:
Bad luck Guy, do you mind if I ask when you got your offer from York? I'm still waiting on one.
Has any of the international applicants been given a telephone interview yet. And if yes, how were you notified
Reply 3172
Leviathon
Bad luck Guy, do you mind if I ask when you got your offer from York? I'm still waiting on one.


I got it over a month ago, I met quite a few people who still hadn't heard yet though =/

From what I can tell most people seem to have York or Warwick, although there are a few lucky types who have both!

-Guy
Reply 3173
bad luck mate...

there are a few *cough* who just have manchester though!
I just got rejected by Warwick as well. So far, the unis that I shoved on there as filler (after York and Oxford) have all rejected me. Luckily, I've got an offer from York, which, along with Oxford, is one of the two places I actually want to go.

Not particularly hopeful about Oxford though. :rolleyes:
Reply 3175
GuyM
Just got rejected by Warwick :frown:


Sorry to hear :frown:

I haven't got any answer from Warwick yet; maybe a rejection as well for me :frown:
jgupta
bad luck mate...

there are a few *cough* who just have manchester though!


:biggrin: Yeah, I've just got one offer from Hull, fortunately though that's my first choice apart from Oxord.
Reply 3177
heh nice one :smile:
Reply 3178
**** the competition on the interviews was unbelievable...i so expect a rejection. but when i get it i will get so wasted....
GuyM
Just got rejected by Warwick :frown:


aw...cheer up! and you've got oxford, hopefully, to look forward to :smile:

Quick Reply