Turn on thread page Beta

Differentiation and Factorization Problem watch

    • Thread Starter
    Offline

    0
    ReputationRep:
    It's the thanksgiving holiday and I am still in my house studying for maths...
    We started differentiation about two weeks ago, and are currently doing further differentiation (the chain, power, and quotient rule, as well as the implicit thingy). I do not have any problems on how to use those formulas, but have problems in factorizing the final answers (when using the power and quotient formulas). When factorizing, I seem to be getting the wrong answers according to the math textbook. So since I know that the forum is my friend, I'm here to ask you what did I do wrong.

    Q1.

    1. y = x^3(3-x^4)^5

    2. dy/dx = x^3(5)(3-x^4)^4(-4x^3) + (3-x^4)^5(3x^2)

    3. = -20x^3(3-x^4)^4 + (3x^2)(3-x^4)^5

    4. = (x^2)(3-x^4)^4(-20x + 3(3-x^4))

    5. = (x^2)(3-x^4)^4(-20x + 9 - 3x^4))

    Q2.

    1. y = (x^2-7)(x^4+1)^2

    2. dy/dx = 8x^3(x^2-7)(x^4+1) + 2x(x^4+1)^2

    3. = x^2 - 7 + 2x(x^4 + 1)(4x^2(x^4+1))
    Offline

    1
    ReputationRep:
    (Original post by FurbyMaX)
    It's the thanksgiving holiday and I am still in my house studying for maths...
    We started differentiation about two weeks ago, and are currently doing further differentiation (the chain, power, and quotient rule, as well with the implicit thingy). I do not have any problems on how to use those formulas, but have problems in factorizing the final answers (when using the power and quotient formulas). When factorizing, I seem to be getting the wrong answers according to the math textbook. So since I know that the forum is my friend, I'm here to ask you what did I do wrong.

    Q1.

    1. y = x^3(3-x^4)^5

    2. dy/dx = x^3(5)(3-x^4)^4(-4x^3) + (3-x^4)^5(3x^2)

    3. = -20x^3(3-x^4)^4 + (3x^2)(3-x^4)^5

    4. = (x^2)(3-x^4)^4(-20x + 3(3-x^4))

    5. = (x^2)(3-x^4)^4(-20x + 9 - 3x^4))

    Q2.

    1. y = (x^2-7)(x^4+1)^2

    2. dy/dx = 8x^3(x^2-7)(x^4+1) + 2x(x^4+1)^2

    3. = x^2 - 7 + 2x(x^4 + 1)(4x^2(x^4+1))

    Are you joking? You started differentiation 2 weks ago and now yu are on this??
    • Thread Starter
    Offline

    0
    ReputationRep:
    (Original post by *dave*)
    Are you joking? You started differentiation 2 weks ago and now yu are on this??
    No, Im not joking, why?
    • Thread Starter
    Offline

    0
    ReputationRep:
    (Original post by FurbyMaX)
    No, Im not joking, why?
    ...?
    Offline

    1
    ReputationRep:
    God!

    After 2 weeks i was still trying to work out the equation for the tangent to the curve lol ... surely you need A2 knowledge of the binomical expansion in order to factorise some of those expressions, you surely wouldnt do them the long way would you?
    • Thread Starter
    Offline

    0
    ReputationRep:
    (Original post by *dave*)
    God!

    After 2 weeks i was still trying to work out the equation for the tangent to the curve lol ... surely you need A2 knowledge of the binomical expansion in order to factorise some of those expressions, you surely wouldnt do them the long way would you?
    Im doing the Ib, what's A2?

    I've got the terms messed up, am I doing factorization the long way? :confused:

    Thanks
    Offline

    1
    ReputationRep:
    (Original post by FurbyMaX)
    Im doing the Ib, what's A2?

    I've got the terms messed up, am I doing factorization the long way? :confused:

    Thanks
    To multiply out this bracket:

    y = x^3(3-x^4)^5

    Surely you would need knowledge of binomical exapnsion, surely you would write out (3-x^4)(3-x^4)(3-x^4)(3-x^4)(3-x^4)

    ??
    Offline

    1
    ReputationRep:
    (Original post by *dave*)
    To multiply out this bracket:

    y = x^3(3-x^4)^5

    Surely you would need knowledge of binomical exapnsion, surely you would write out (3-x^4)(3-x^4)(3-x^4)(3-x^4)(3-x^4)

    ??
    Or you could use t = (3-x^4) god im being thick today lol
    Offline

    1
    ReputationRep:
    (Original post by *dave*)
    To multiply out this bracket:

    y = x^3(3-x^4)^5

    Surely you would need knowledge of binomical exapnsion, surely you would write out (3-x^4)(3-x^4)(3-x^4)(3-x^4)(3-x^4)

    ??
    Why do you want to multiply that thingy out anyway? Isn't that already fully facterised? Oh and it's Bionomial not bionomical.

    (Original post by *dave*)
    Are you joking? You started differentiation 2 weks ago and now yu are on this??
    You can pretty much finish P1 in a month and P2 (where chain, product and quotient rules are) in another month. No big deal. A'Level these days are just too easy. Maths is getting a little bit stupid I think...Ever seen anything from 20 years ago? Gosh...they were hard.
    • Thread Starter
    Offline

    0
    ReputationRep:
    (Original post by *dave*)
    To multiply out this bracket:

    y = x^3(3-x^4)^5

    Surely you would need knowledge of binomical exapnsion, surely you would write out (3-x^4)(3-x^4)(3-x^4)(3-x^4)(3-x^4)

    ??
    I guess, yes. Is there another way?
    Offline

    14
    ReputationRep:
    y = x^3(3-x^4)^5

    u = x^3
    du/dx = 3x^2

    v = (3-x^4)^5
    w = 3-x^4
    dw/dx = -4x^3
    v = w^5
    dv/dw = 5w^4

    dv/dx = dw/dx . dv/dw
    =(-4x^3)(5w^4)
    =(-4x^3)(5(3-x^4)^4)

    then product rule
    dy/dx = v du/dx + u dv/dx
    =(3-x^4)^5(3x^2) + x^3(-4x^3)(5(3-x^4)^4)

    that should work
    Offline

    0
    ReputationRep:
    (Original post by FurbyMaX)
    It's the thanksgiving holiday and I am still in my house studying for maths...
    We started differentiation about two weeks ago, and are currently doing further differentiation (the chain, power, and quotient rule, as well as the implicit thingy). I do not have any problems on how to use those formulas, but have problems in factorizing the final answers (when using the power and quotient formulas). When factorizing, I seem to be getting the wrong answers according to the math textbook. So since I know that the forum is my friend, I'm here to ask you what did I do wrong.

    Q1.

    1. y = x^3(3-x^4)^5

    2. dy/dx = x^3(5)(3-x^4)^4(-4x^3) + (3-x^4)^5(3x^2)

    3. = -20x^3(3-x^4)^4 + (3x^2)(3-x^4)^5

    4. = (x^2)(3-x^4)^4(-20x + 3(3-x^4))

    5. = (x^2)(3-x^4)^4(-20x + 9 - 3x^4))

    Q2.

    1. y = (x^2-7)(x^4+1)^2

    2. dy/dx = 8x^3(x^2-7)(x^4+1) + 2x(x^4+1)^2

    3. = x^2 - 7 + 2x(x^4 + 1)(4x^2(x^4+1))
    Q1:
    You made a mistake in step 3. The first term should be -(20x^6)(3-x^4)^4 (you forgot to square x^3). So you get:-
    dy/dx = -(20x^6)(3-x^4)^4 + (3x^2)(3-x^4)^5
    = [(3-x^4)^4][(3x^2)(3-x^4) - (20x^6)]

    Q2:
    I don't understand how you went from step 2 to 3. You should get:-
    dy/dx = (8x^3)(x^2-7)(x^4+1) + 2x(x^4+1)^2
    = (x^4+1)[(8x^3)(x^2-7) + 2x(x^4+1)]

    It would be advisable to do binomial expansions only if the question explicitly demands it. I agree that A-level maths today is too easy, which is why the top universities require additional exams.
    Offline

    10
    ReputationRep:
    For Q.1 I get:

    dy/dx = x^2(3-x^4)^5(3-20x^4(3-x^4))

    Q2. dy/dx = 2x(x^4+1)(4x^2(x^2-7)+x^4+1)
    • Thread Starter
    Offline

    0
    ReputationRep:
    Thanks guys, I'll see if the answers u gave me are correct tomorrow, now I just wanna play some games
    Offline

    12
    ReputationRep:
    (Original post by Camford)
    Why do you want to multiply that thingy out anyway? Isn't that already fully facterised? Oh and it's Bionomial not bionomical.



    You can pretty much finish P1 in a month and P2 (where chain, product and quotient rules are) in another month. No big deal. A'Level these days are just too easy. Maths is getting a little bit stupid I think...Ever seen anything from 20 years ago? Gosh...they were hard.

    I found my A level maths hard...
    Offline

    1
    ReputationRep:
    (Original post by MadNatSci)
    I found my A level maths hard...
    Not the end of everything though, is it?
    Offline

    12
    ReputationRep:
    (Original post by Camford)
    Not the end of everything though, is it?

    Well, no... it's do-able, if that's what you mean! And even if you fail it, it isn't the end of the world... but I wouldn't call it easy. Having said that, I'm not that mathematically strong (ask my poor patient maths supervisor)!
    Offline

    0
    ReputationRep:
    However easy some people find it, and I'm certain a small minority of people find it very easy, it has to be said Maths is one of the tougher A-Levels with lots to learn, and combined with a poor national standard of teaching, makes Maths one of the toughest A-Levels, especially given the two jumps (from gcse - as and as-a2) are both reasonably big.
    Offline

    15
    ReputationRep:
    i make the answer to q1
    dy/dx = [(3x^2)(3-x^4)^5] - [(20x^6)(3-x^4)^4]
    or factorised a bit (pointlessly):

    dy/dx = [x^2(3-x^4)^4] * [3(3-x^4) - 20x^4]
    Offline

    1
    ReputationRep:
    (Original post by FurbyMaX)
    It's the thanksgiving holiday and I am still in my house studying for maths...
    We started differentiation about two weeks ago, and are currently doing further differentiation (the chain, power, and quotient rule, as well as the implicit thingy). I do not have any problems on how to use those formulas, but have problems in factorizing the final answers (when using the power and quotient formulas). When factorizing, I seem to be getting the wrong answers according to the math textbook. So since I know that the forum is my friend, I'm here to ask you what did I do wrong.

    Q1.

    1. y = x^3(3-x^4)^5

    2. dy/dx = x^3(5)(3-x^4)^4(-4x^3) + (3-x^4)^5(3x^2)

    3. = -20x^3(3-x^4)^4 + (3x^2)(3-x^4)^5

    4. = (x^2)(3-x^4)^4(-20x + 3(3-x^4))

    5. = (x^2)(3-x^4)^4(-20x + 9 - 3x^4))

    Q2.

    1. y = (x^2-7)(x^4+1)^2

    2. dy/dx = 8x^3(x^2-7)(x^4+1) + 2x(x^4+1)^2

    3. = x^2 - 7 + 2x(x^4 + 1)(4x^2(x^4+1))
    =1
 
 
 
Poll
Could you cope without Wifi?
Useful resources

The Student Room, Get Revising and Marked by Teachers are trading names of The Student Room Group Ltd.

Register Number: 04666380 (England and Wales), VAT No. 806 8067 22 Registered Office: International House, Queens Road, Brighton, BN1 3XE

Write a reply...
Reply
Hide
Reputation gems: You get these gems as you gain rep from other members for making good contributions and giving helpful advice.