The largest number less than one
I got into an argument with a friend about this.
I asked him what is the largest number less than 1, he said 0.999 (recurring) then I pointed out that 0.999… is equal to 1 because 1/3=0.333… and 0.333…*3=0.999…
Then he argued that 0.333…*3 is 1 and we started arguing until we came to the conclusion that because of the fact that decimals are uncountably infinite there is no answer.
Now I’m asking .
I asked him what is the largest number less than 1, he said 0.999 (recurring) then I pointed out that 0.999… is equal to 1 because 1/3=0.333… and 0.333…*3=0.999…
Then he argued that 0.333…*3 is 1 and we started arguing until we came to the conclusion that because of the fact that decimals are uncountably infinite there is no answer.
Now I’m asking .
0.999... is equal to 1
Original post by kella3
I got into an argument with a friend about this.
I asked him what is the largest number less than 1, he said 0.999 (recurring) then I pointed out that 0.999… is equal to 1 because 1/3=0.333… and 0.333…*3=0.999…
Then he argued that 0.333…*3 is 1 and we started arguing until we came to the conclusion that because of the fact that decimals are uncountably infinite there is no answer.
Now I’m asking .
I asked him what is the largest number less than 1, he said 0.999 (recurring) then I pointed out that 0.999… is equal to 1 because 1/3=0.333… and 0.333…*3=0.999…
Then he argued that 0.333…*3 is 1 and we started arguing until we came to the conclusion that because of the fact that decimals are uncountably infinite there is no answer.
Now I’m asking .
The decimal representation isnt unique, so as you say 1 and 0.999... both represent the same number. So for any number with a finite decimal representation so say
1.23456
then its the same as
1.234559999....
Two numbers are different if there is a third number between them. Obviously thats not the case here. Also if you did assume there was a (different) number x closest to 1, then the number (1+x)/2 is different to both 1 and x and closer to 1 than x is, so contradiction. Uncountably infinite isnt really a proof.
(edited 10 months ago)
Original post by kella3
I got into an argument with a friend about this.
I asked him what is the largest number less than 1
~snip~
we started arguing until we came to the conclusion that because of the fact that decimals are uncountably infinite there is no answer.
I asked him what is the largest number less than 1
~snip~
we started arguing until we came to the conclusion that because of the fact that decimals are uncountably infinite there is no answer.
If you are talking about the real numbers or the rationals, then there is no "largest number less than 1" (since if x was supposedly such a number, then (x+1)/2 is both larger than x and less than 1).
Note that the rationals are countable, so you do not need your number system to be countably infinite for there to be no answer.
Note also that if you were talking about the integers, then 0 would work.
Quick Reply
Related discussions
- Maths - Statistics, cumulative probabilities
- further stats question
- Oxford colleges for maths
- Moles calculation
- Is 30k grad salary enough in London ?
- Cambridge college help medicine
- University of Bradford or Canterbury Christ Church University
- Is King's College London good?
- Uni of manchester vs uni of Nottingham
- proof by contradiction
- OCR 2023 A level maths pure and stats
- Participation crisis essay
- Which are the best colleges to study modern languages?
- Is this STEM Cambridge residential still good to go to if i’ve changed to Humanities?
- 1989 (Taylor’s Version) sold 693,000 copies on vinyl in its 1st week
- Lancaster University Private Accommodation First Year
- The biggest number under 10000 that is exactly divisible by 3, 7 and 11
- Mole Calculations.
- Is King's College really good?
- maths help!
Latest
Trending
Last reply 5 days ago
Did Cambridge maths students find maths and further maths a level very easy?Last reply 2 weeks ago
Edexcel A Level Mathematics Paper 2 unofficial mark scheme correct me if wrongMaths
71
Trending
Last reply 5 days ago
Did Cambridge maths students find maths and further maths a level very easy?Last reply 2 weeks ago
Edexcel A Level Mathematics Paper 2 unofficial mark scheme correct me if wrongMaths
71
