The Student Room Group

Trigonometric Identities Help!!

So I started AS maths last week and I'm having some trouble with identities. Please please please can someone try to help me!

1. (1/sinx) - tanxcosx = cos^2x/sinx
2. tanxsinx/1-cosx = 1 + 1/cosx
3. (cosx+sinx)^2 + (cosx-sinx)^2 =2
4. sinxtanx + cosx = 1/cosx
5. 1/sinx - 1/tanx = 1 - cosx/sinx

Any help would be greatly appreciated!

Scroll to see replies

Original post by Alex.trin
So I started AS maths last week and I'm having some trouble with identities. Please please please can someone try to help me!

1. (1/sinx) - tanxcosx = cos^2x/sinx
2. tanxsinx/1-cosx = 1 + 1/cosx
3. (cosx+sinx)^2 + (cosx-sinx)^2 =2
4. sinxtanx + cosx = 1/cosx
5. 1/sinx - 1/tanx = 1 - cosx/sinx

Any help would be greatly appreciated!


What are you stuck on exactly? At this point you should know that:

sin2x+cos2x1\displaystyle \sin^2x+\cos^2x\equiv 1

sinxcosxtanx \displaystyle \frac{\sin{x}}{\cos{x}}\equiv \tan{x}

and work from these.
Reply 2
Original post by RDKGames
What are you stuck on exactly? At this point you should know that:

sin2x+cos2x1\displaystyle \sin^2x+\cos^2x\equiv 1

sinxcosxtanx \displaystyle \frac{\sin{x}}{\cos{x}}\equiv \tan{x}

and work from these.


Yes I found those in the textbook but I don't understand how to rearrange them to simplify those equations
Original post by Alex.trin
Yes I found those in the textbook but I don't understand how to rearrange them to simplify those equations


I'll do the first one for you as an example:

First rewrite tanx\tan{x} as sinxcosx\displaystyle \frac{\sin{x}}{\cos{x}}. You can see that multiplying this by cosx\cos{x} cancels out the denominator right away.

You are left with: 1sinxsinx=cos2xsinx\displaystyle \frac{1}{\sin{x}}-\sin{x}=\frac{\cos^2x}{\sin{x}}

Now multiply through by sin(x) to cancel the 1/sinx and you are left with: 1sin2x=cos2x \displaystyle 1-\sin^2x=\cos^2x which is a true identity.

Do the similar procedure for the other ones.
(edited 7 years ago)
Reply 4
Original post by RDKGames
I'll do the first one for you as an example:

First rewrite tanx\tan{x} as sinxcosx\displaystyle \frac{\sin{x}}{\cos{x}}. You can see that multiplying this by cosx\cos{x} cancels out the denominator right away.

You are left with: 1sinxsinx=cos2xsinx\displaystyle \frac{1}{\sin{x}}-\sin{x}=\frac{\cos^2x}{\sin{x}}

Now multiply through by sin(x) to cancel the 1/sinx and you are left with: 1sin2x=cos2x \displaystyle 1-\sin^2x=\cos^2x which is a true identity.

Do the similar procedure for the other ones.


Oh my goodness you are a genius! I'll have a go at the others and see how I get on. Thank you!!
Reply 5
Original post by RDKGames
I'll do the first one for you as an example:

First rewrite tanx\tan{x} as sinxcosx\displaystyle \frac{\sin{x}}{\cos{x}}. You can see that multiplying this by cosx\cos{x} cancels out the denominator right away.

You are left with: 1sinxsinx=cos2xsinx\displaystyle \frac{1}{\sin{x}}-\sin{x}=\frac{\cos^2x}{\sin{x}}

Now multiply through by sin(x) to cancel the 1/sinx and you are left with: 1sin2x=cos2x \displaystyle 1-\sin^2x=\cos^2x which is a true identity.

Do the similar procedure for the other ones.

It is very bad practice to assume that an identity is true and manipulate it to arrive at something true.

If you do this you have to be sure that every step you make is reversible which isn't always obvious.

With trig identities you should always start from one side and show that the other side is true.
Reply 6
Right I'm stuck again. On number 3, cos^2x + sin^2 simplifies to 1, but how do I simplify cos^2x - sin^2x?
Reply 7
Original post by Alex.trin
Oh my goodness you are a genius! I'll have a go at the others and see how I get on. Thank you!!

Please do not do what RDKGames has done for trig identities.

You should always start from one side of a trig identity and aim to arrive at the other side. Never manipulate the whole identity like you would an equation.
Original post by notnek
It is very bad practice to assume that an identity is true and manipulate it to arrive at something true.

If you do this you have to be sure that every step you make is reversible which isn't always obvious.

With trig identities you should always start from one side and show that the other side is true.


The question didn't really make it clear and I assumed they want you to prove whether something turns out to be a true identity or not.
Original post by Alex.trin
Right I'm stuck again. On number 3, cos^2x + sin^2 simplifies to 1, but how do I simplify cos^2x - sin^2x?


Show your working, it shouldn't simplify down to a minus. Also as the person above said, leave the right hand side along and work with left one.
Reply 10
Original post by notnek
Please do not do what RDKGames has done for trig identities.

You should always start from one side of a trig identity and aim to arrive at the other side. Never manipulate the whole identity like you would an equation.


Ok, please may you show me how you'd answer the question then?
Reply 11
Original post by RDKGames
The question didn't really make it clear and I assumed they want you to prove whether something turns out to be a true identity or not.

That doesn't make sense.

I'm busy now but if you have time can you please show the OP how to do question 1 using the correct method?
Reply 12
Original post by RDKGames
Show your working, it shouldn't simplify down to a minus. Also as the person above said, leave the right hand side along and work with left one.


Oh yes I see now. (-sin^2x)^2 is positive, not negative. Thanks again
Original post by notnek
That doesn't make sense.

I'm busy now but if you have time can you please show the OP how to do question 1 using the correct method?


To me it does, but okay.

Original post by Alex.trin
Oh yes I see now. (-sin^2x)^2 is positive, not negative. Thanks again


Q1 corrected:

Rewrite tanx as sinx over cosx, the cosx cancels with the denominator as before. The RHS wants the answer to be as something over sinx, so you need to combine the LHS into a single fraction under the same denominator. The first term already has sinx as denominator, we can leave it. The second term, sinx, can be turned into a fraction with denominator sinx by:

sinx1=sinxsinxsinx=sin2xsinxsinx \cdot 1 = sinx \cdot \frac{sinx}{sinx} = \frac{sin^2x}{sinx}

Now add the two fractions and you get: 1sin2xsinx=cos2xsinx\frac{1-sin^2x}{sinx}=\frac{cos^2x}{sinx} at which point we need to show that the numerator is equal to cos2xcos^2x and indeed this is true from rearranging sin2x+cos2x=1sin^2x+cos^2x=1
(edited 7 years ago)
Reply 14
Original post by RDKGames
To me it does, but okay.



Q1 corrected:

Rewrite tanx as sinx over cosx, the cosx cancels with the denominator as before. The RHS wants the answer to be as something over sinx, so you need to combine the LHS into a single fraction under the same denominator. The first term already has sinx as denominator, we can leave it. The second term, sinx, can be turned into a fraction with denominator sinx by:

sinx1=sinxsinxsinx=sin2xsinxsinx \cdot 1 = sinx \cdot \frac{sinx}{sinx} = \frac{sin^2x}{sinx}

Now add the two fractions and you get: 1sin2xsinx=cos2xsinx\frac{1-sin^2x}{sinx}=\frac{cos^2x}{sinx} at which point we need to show that the numerator is equal to cos2xcos^2x and indeed this is true from rearranging sin2x+cos2x=1sin^2x+cos^2x=1


Oh right I see now! So would the answer be cos^2x/sinx = cos^2x/sinx??
Original post by Alex.trin
Oh right I see now! So would the answer be cos^2x/sinx = cos^2x/sinx??


Exactly. With these what you are essentially doing is turning the left hand side of the identity into the right hand side.
Reply 16
Original post by RDKGames
To me it does, but okay.


Call the identity a statement AA and your (true) hypothesis BB (that's stuff like sin^2 + cos^2 = 1, etc...)

You want to show that BAB \Rightarrow A. You're trying to show ABA \Rightarrow B. These are the same things only when A    BA \iff B is true.

For a concrete example, take AA to be the statement (x2)(x1)=0(x-2)(x-1) = 0 and BB the statement x=2x=2.

Then whilst it's true that BAB \Rightarrow A it does not hold that ABA \Rightarrow B.
Reply 17
Original post by RDKGames
Exactly. With these what you are essentially doing is turning the left hand side of the identity into the right hand side.

So I've moved on to question 4 now. I've turned sinx into tanx/cosx and tanx into sinx/cosx. Then I've combined the two fractions to make tanxsinx/cosx. Now I'm stuck because I can't just cross out the cosx's. Please please please can someone help!
Original post by Alex.trin
So I've moved on to question 4 now. I've turned sinx into tanx/cosx and tanx into sinx/cosx. Then I've combined the two fractions to make tanxsinx/cosx. Now I'm stuck because I can't just cross out the cosx's. Please please please can someone help!


Er, just turn tan(x) into sinx over cosx. Don't try to go from sin or cos into tan right away, deal with the basic functions first. The first term should then read sin squared over cos which is okay as far as the RHS is concerned, then deal with the second term and get it under the same denominator.
Reply 19
Original post by Alex.trin
So I've moved on to question 4 now. I've turned sinx into tanx/cosx and tanx into sinx/cosx. Then I've combined the two fractions to make tanxsinx/cosx. Now I'm stuck because I can't just cross out the cosx's. Please please please can someone help!


Why would you want to do that? Think about it! You're starting from the left hand side which is in terms of tans, sines and cosines and you wnat to show that's the same thing as the right hand side which is made up only of cosines. So the logical thing to do in the RHS is to turn the tan into a sine and cosine, and then hopefully get rid of sines altogether.

So try: sinxsinxcosx+cosx=sin2xcosx+cosx1\sin x \frac{\sin x}{\cos x} + \cos x = \frac{\sin^2 x}{\cos x} + \frac{\cos x}{1} - now do common denominators, then add the numerator and you get something nice in the numerator that simplies very nicely and gets you what you want!

Quick Reply

Latest