The Student Room Group

My view on obesity.

Scroll to see replies

Reply 20
Original post by DasSnipez
So you watched the bbc news and "believe" there is some level of food addiction and your going to claim that these are facts?

You know what, I'm done, you don't even seem to understand what a fact actually is.

No, I just happen to have a degree in a scientific/health discipline so you'd think I'd know what I'm talking about.

http://www.webmd.com/mental-health/mental-health-food-addiction

Yes food addiction can affect people, sugar etc. release dopamine which interestingly affects similar areas of the brain to what cocaine, porn etc. affect.

I'm just using facts, simple LOGICKZZ mate.
They do irritate me. There's a woman at my work who became morbidly obese to the point of being classified as disabled, she can just about get to the office after being dropped off at the front door. It finally caught up with her in February and she was admitted to hospital where over the course of a few weeks, she had heart failure, kidney failure, she even flat lined at one point, her family were told at one point she wouldnt last the night, she had lymphedema and put on 5 stone in water weight around her legs. This is on top of the excessive amount of health problems she has had over the years as a result of her weight.

She eventually made it back to work in august and just this week she was talking about all the hospital appointments she needs to go to and her quote was "i'm sick of hospitals, i hate going to them i just wish i could see the back of them" whilst taking a swig of coke and cracking open a bag of crisps. When people are going out for lunch she always asks if we can bring her back an ice cream, a bottle of coke, this food, that food etc etc. I'd have no problem picking up a sandwhich from greggs if she hadn't just had a packed lunch. She's also one of these people who claims not to eat much and when she recalls what she's eaten in a day shhe missed out about 75% of what she's actually shovelled into her piggy mouth.




I'm sorry I just really can not be doing with fat people, I understand if you're a bit overweight and chubby, i get that it can be hard to have a decent diet and getthe motivation to do exercise, but to be more than a bit chubby is just a disgrace.
Food addiction is real. This interesting article details how food companies try and find the bliss point and try to hook consumers in their food so their pockets are lined. It mirrors the drug dealers in this world.

Also, the TLOs. "Awesome recycled burger, this week only!" and I have to have it asap. Of course, I stopped with them because the burgers brought nothing new to the table and two different TLO burgers actually tasted pretty identical.
It's no one else's business if someone is obese. I mean seriously. Get over it. Yes, obese people should lose weight, but because of their HEALTH, not because it's not pretty to look at, as someone said on this thread.
Reply 24
Original post by battycatlady
It's no one else's business if someone is obese. I mean seriously. Get over it. Yes, obese people should lose weight, but because of their HEALTH, not because it's not pretty to look at, as someone said on this thread.

See the OP and I've talked about health and how people can get food addictions similar to that of drug addicts. It's clearly a detriment to their health.

It's our business as you pay for these obese people to get treatment, same way you pay for people who have cancer to get treatment, you then decide to tell them to avoid getting into situations that require citizens to pay tax for the NHS to fund their treatment... It's our problem indirectly. It's like saying you don't care about the starving children in africa but your money is going to pay for aid in africa, so rather than giving a person a fish to eat for a day, you should teach them to fish to eat for a lifetime.

By that saying I mean don't pay for their treatment so the corporate companies get their money, help them become less obese so that their attitudes to losing weight transpires to the younger generations.
I dont mind seeing chubby people or a person slightly overweight. Thats fine but its a bit disturbing when you see a really obese person. On top of that nowadays you see many obese children as well who refuse to take part in exercise at school and that's worrying. 6/7 years ago i was obese and just started off jogging 15 minutes a day, fast forward to now and ive completed so many 5k, 10k and half marathons. I've never felt better and running and fitness in general has become part of me. Being obese causes so many health problems and i really worry for a person whose obese even though it really isnt my problem. Live and let live I've always reminded myself that and ignored it. I know it's hard to start fixing your diet and actually get off your butt to exercise and it is hard in the first few weeks but if you stay at it, you'll see the rewards at the end.
Reply 26
Original post by stargirl63

Those who are drug addicts, smokers, alcoholics etc seem to get a worse time because it's seen as rude to openly berate an obese person. They will say "urgggh...smoking is disgusting! Do you know what you're doing to yourself?" and then say absolutely nothing when the fat person at the table orders dessert.


I've never actually heard anyone say this publicly to a smoker in real life. :confused:
Reply 27
Original post by x_x
I've never actually heard anyone say this publicly to a smoker in real life. :confused:

Well I have so if you want to go by anecdotal evidence it's 1-1.
Original post by x_x
I've never actually heard anyone say this publicly to a smoker in real life. :confused:


Same here.

It's easy to talk big on the internet though, you're not going to have some chav smacking you in the mouth.
Obesity is a personal choice its only them harming themselves. Just because we have a socialised healthcare system does not mean we should target fat people.

Some fat people are wealthy and can afford to go private if they want :tongue:
Reply 30
Original post by WeOnlyLiveOnce
I dont mind seeing chubby people or a person slightly overweight. Thats fine but its a bit disturbing when you see a really obese person. On top of that nowadays you see many obese children as well who refuse to take part in exercise at school and that's worrying. 6/7 years ago i was obese and just started off jogging 15 minutes a day, fast forward to now and ive completed so many 5k, 10k and half marathons. I've never felt better and running and fitness in general has become part of me. Being obese causes so many health problems and i really worry for a person whose obese even though it really isnt my problem. Live and let live I've always reminded myself that and ignored it. I know it's hard to start fixing your diet and actually get off your butt to exercise and it is hard in the first few weeks but if you stay at it, you'll see the rewards at the end.

well done bro.

i need to get into this jogging ting as well. I can get into hours of cycling, used to do 40miles every saturday which was tough at first but when I got into it is was very good.
Reply 31
Original post by DasSnipez
Same here.

It's easy to talk big on the internet though, you're not going to have some chav smacking you in the mouth.

Why have you not answered my points? You just went and berated something I said with no evidence, I provide you with evidence that there is such a thing known as food addiction and others have too and you have no answer, so decide to go to the next point.
Original post by jam278
well done bro.

i need to get into this jogging ting as well. I can get into hours of cycling, used to do 40miles every saturday which was tough at first but when I got into it is was very good.


Just goes to show hard work really pays off. I know a few people who keep complaining that they're fat and they cant get rid of it yet after talking to them after a bit, you find out they stopped doing exercise because they didn't see results after 3 days :lolwut:. They just seem to be avoiding exercise because it's hard work. I guess it all comes down to motivation and sustaining your motivation to have a better lifestyle.

Trust me you need to get into jogging :lol:. It helps with everything like stress (well all exercises do) and I usually find myself lost in my thoughts while jogging.

Ah that's really good. Good luck with your cycling!
Original post by jam278
There seems to be a disparity in opinions to the drug addicts and the obese person. People say that the drug addict did it to themselves and people say that they don't need help yet obesity is done largely by the person as well. Take for example hyperthyroidism which is supposed a factor for obesity, it is supposedly responsible for 0.1% of the cases of obesity.

Now overweight people dislike the facts, but it's simple calorie intake vs calories burnt. If you're eating dense calories like grilled chicken, brown rice, beans etc. over fried beef, burgers, biscuits, coca cola and beer you will lose weight or not gain weight as you will feel more full. This low metabolism stuff makes less sense because you will increase your metabolism regardless if you exercise more.

These are the facts. Disagree with them all you want but doesn't make them any less correct than they are.

I will include a poll to see people's views on obesity. I also would like to say that people's threads on disapproving of multiculturalism go on far longer than a thread with much less discriminating opinions(that overweight people do this to themselves and should lose weight).

Food for thought definitely. Let me get a banana.


It's not a simple question of calories in vs calories out. Genetics has an absolutely massive impact on a person's metabolism, fitness, liability to addiction, etc. It is a simple fact that it is vastly easier for some people to remain fit and healthy than others. Now, that doesn't mean that people should simply give in to their genetic dispositions, but it does mean that it's very unfair to act as if it's as simple as a choice - because it really isn't.

I would also add that money is a massive factor. In a recent National Geographic article, they showed how regions of poverty correlate perfectly with regions of obesity. Fresh, healthy food is more expensive than fast food. Many people living in poverty don't actually have a choice to eat a healthy diet because they have neither the time, money or resources. It's very easy to sneer at people from the perspective of someone who has had proper education on healthy eating and the money and time to invest in a healthy diet, but some people don't have that option. Obesity is a function of inequality, something that you will see clearly if you look at global trends or even trends within countries. I can say with absolute certainty that the rate of obesity in, for instance, South Kensington is much lower than in Tottenham.
(edited 9 years ago)
Original post by DasSnipez
When you have a heart attack, a stroke, a brain aneurysm, dementia, parkinsons disease, break your leg, break your spine, cut your hand off with a table saw these all become everybodies problem, the moment you step foot in a&e it becomes everybodies problem.

We all pay in we and we all get treatment.

Do I get to complain if your injury is your own fault?

No.

Because you have paid just as much as you (proportionally) have to have access to that service.

What...

Wow man, looks like I struck a nerve there I was just answering your question.
Also how are any of the injuries listed anyone's fault?
Why are people on TSR obsessed with fat people? If someone wants to gorge on fatty on food let them. What's it to you?


Honestly sometimes I wonder whether TSR is the go-to forum for people with angst about nonexistent issues irl.
Original post by Marky Mark
Why are people on TSR obsessed with fat people? If someone wants to gorge on fatty on food let them. What's it to you?


Honestly sometimes I wonder whether TSR is the go-to forum for people with angst about nonexistent issues irl.


Sitting on a bus next to a fat person is an ordeal. they take up to much space, they cant breath properly and they sweat more than normal people. same applies for planes & trains.

walking down a narrow corridor when a fatty comes along means you have to squeeze past their discusting bulk.

clothes come in odd sizes and are inconsistent from shop to shop because some brands cater to larger people rather than taller people.

The diet industry is rife with false claims trying to sucker in fatties with an instant fix to their problems.

Food is labelled as 'low fat' in order to appear healthy to those trying to loose weight despite the fact that polyunsaturated fat is a key macro nutrient especially for those who have high blood pressure or clogged arteries. ('fat' has been demonised when sugar and sat fat are the problem)

Fat people use their weight as an excuse not to do things.

fat people are ugly. This causes adolescent girls who don't know much about the difference between healthy and skinny to become unhealthy.

fat people are more likely to become depressed or have a poor opinion of them selves.

The world would be a better place if people cared more about their health.
Original post by Chlorophile
It's not a simple question of calories in vs calories out. Genetics has an absolutely massive impact on a person's metabolism, fitness, liability to addiction, etc. It is a simple fact that it is vastly easier for some people to remain fit and healthy than others. Now, that doesn't mean that people should simply give in to their genetic dispositions, but it does mean that it's very unfair to act as if it's as simple as a choice - because it really isn't.


Genetic conditions that affect metabolism are rare. Hyperthyroidism (a condition that affects metabolism) is estimated to affect 2.5% of the UK population (http://www.webmd.boots.com/a-to-z-guides/underactive-thyroid-hypothyroidism) and yet a quarter of adults are obese (http://www.nhs.uk/Conditions/Obesity/Pages/Introduction.aspx).
Original post by Marky Mark
Why are people on TSR obsessed with fat people? If someone wants to gorge on fatty on food let them. What's it to you?


Honestly sometimes I wonder whether TSR is the go-to forum for people with angst about nonexistent issues irl.


Lool you think obesity is a non-existent issue? It's actually more common than you think.


I also notice this trend where people practically say 'live and let live' with obesity. Apparently helping people stay healthy is bad.
Reply 39
Original post by Chlorophile
It's not a simple question of calories in vs calories out. Genetics has an absolutely massive impact on a person's metabolism, fitness, liability to addiction, etc. It is a simple fact that it is vastly easier for some people to remain fit and healthy than others. Now, that doesn't mean that people should simply give in to their genetic dispositions, but it does mean that it's very unfair to act as if it's as simple as a choice - because it really isn't.

I would also add that money is a massive factor. In a recent National Geographic article, they showed how regions of poverty correlate perfectly with regions of obesity. Fresh, healthy food is more expensive than fast food. Many people living in poverty don't actually have a choice to eat a healthy diet because they have neither the time, money or resources. It's very easy to sneer at people from the perspective of someone who has had proper education on healthy eating and the money and time to invest in a healthy diet, but some people don't have that option. Obesity is a function of inequality, something that you will see clearly if you look at global trends or even trends within countries. I can say with absolute certainty that the rate of obesity in, for instance, South Kensington is much lower than in Tottenham.

Genetics is quite rare as shown already hyperthyroidism affects 2.5% of the population. If we were to look at less frequent obesity conditions and say that it is 5% then the 20% that adds up to the quarter of adults being obese means 80% of people who are obese have no disposition to being obese. Just run or cycle more and you'll be fine.

It is a choice for most fat people. The colour of your skin is mainly not a choice, being fat however is a choice.

Quick Reply

Latest