The Student Room Group

Why are British people proud of NHS?

Scroll to see replies

Reply 40
I got diagnosed with a chronic illness at age 12. Without the NHS I would have died aged 12. I'm 17 and have an average life expectancy.
Original post by A Rolling Stone
he's right. it's because of the US 'die if you can't afford insurance' system which is responsible for brainwashing Brits into thinking their system of public healthcare is somehow special

I don't think they are right in that referencing one countries healthcare weakens the argument for another's, that's just a petty argument tactic imo. But I'd agree it does provide us with a 'super evil' baseline to compare ourselves to positively.

But they're also claiming 3 months and more to see a Doctor! and other such suss statements, so 0 right points. None.
(edited 2 years ago)
Original post by StriderHort
I don't think they are right in that referencing one countries healthcare weakens the argument for another's, that's just a petty argument tactic imo. But I'd agree it does provide us with a 'super evil' baseline to compare ourselves to positively.

But they're also claiming 3 months and more to see a Doctor! and other such suss statements, so 0 right points. None.

What I don't get is people who complain about the NHS can always go private, private healthcare is still an option here in case some people think the NHS is ****
Some British people are, while others are not.
Mostly because they are very grateful to the nhs for providing them with taxpayer funded treatment with no direct financial cost at point of use, for nhs staff/equipment saving their life in the past or saving a family member/friend/someone else they know.
Original post by The RAR
What I don't get is people who complain about the NHS can always go private, private healthcare is still an option here in case some people think the NHS is ****

Spoiler: people who complain but don't go privare can't afford private
Original post by niloomiloo
How is a system that makes you wait 3 months or more to see a doctor can be considered functional, let alone something to be proud of?

I agree we worship it just because it's free..

People think if we don't have NHS we have to have USA style medical.
They forget most European countries & Australia have decent cheap healthcare too.

There was a 49 week wait to see a specialist at my local - that's a year to see one person! Ridiculous!
With private medical it was 4 week wait.
The NHS wasn't always like this - if the tories weren't purposefully driving it into the ground to make going private seem like a necessity in order to appease their big pharma buddies, it would be perfectly functional. We should be proud as a country to have the NHS, it proves that we at least believe that being healthy is a human right, not only reserved for the rich. You should understand that this isn't a NHS problem, it's a leadership one.
Original post by hungrysalamander
Spoiler: people who complain but don't go privare can't afford private

Actually - many jobs give our private medical care as a perk of the job. Not many pay out of their own pocket
Original post by AliceKS
for me, it's the equality we show everyone no matter their job or income which I am most proud of the NHS. Using the US as the example, people on a lower income are treated as lower class citizens with regards to healthcare and often have to choose between rent and healthcare. Life and death is treated more as a commodity with that kind of system
Edit: also for the elderly, you essentially pay into a pot your whole life, for when you need it so essentially a rainy day fund you don't control

Yeah everyone gets equally shite treatment even if you've never contributed to it or contributed your whole life. Very fair lol
Original post by AnnaBloveme
I agree we worship it just because it's free..

People think if we don't have NHS we have to have USA style medical.
They forget most European countries & Australia have decent cheap healthcare too.

There was a 49 week wait to see a specialist at my local - that's a year to see one person! Ridiculous!
With private medical it was 4 week wait.

Even if it's "cheap" (this seems to be a rather relative term), there will still be those who cannot afford it. Plus the whole principal of having to pay to stay alive is ridiculous. We should focus on fixing the NHS, not selling it out and leaving behind the most vulnerable members of our society to die.
Original post by ghostbeansgirl
The NHS wasn't always like this - if the tories weren't purposefully driving it into the ground to make going private seem like a necessity in order to appease their big pharma buddies, it would be perfectly functional. We should be proud as a country to have the NHS, it proves that we at least believe that being healthy is a human right, not only reserved for the rich. You should understand that this isn't a NHS problem, it's a leadership one.

you can't just say it's their fault all the time
Original post by hungrysalamander
Because you don't end up in a massive amount of debt after surgery, you don't have to take an uber to the hospital, and medications like insulin is actually affordable unlike the states. I'm not saying that it's perfect and there are definitely improvements to be made, but it's a lot better than what Americans have.

Why compare it with America that's extreme. Plenty of countries offer very cheap healthcare better than the UK. With shorter waiting lists. Please research healthcare of places other than USA
Original post by AnnaBloveme
Actually - many jobs give our private medical care as a perk of the job. Not many pay out of their own pocket

Both my parents have worked all their life. Both of them have had many different jobs. Both now have relatively well paid jobs. Neither of them have EVER been offered free access to private health care. It seems as though you may be living inside a bit of a privilege bubble.
Original post by Reality Check
How is a system which is free at the point of delivery and available to all based on clinical need rather than ability to pay not something to be proud of?

Cause it's free but shite. Cancer survival rates are awful compared to 1st world countries & out waiting lists can be up to 12 months for simple stuff.
I haven't heard many good stories about it personally
Original post by englishhopeful98
you can't just say it's their fault all the time

It's not pointing the finger if they're actually to blame. Look at everything the tories have done to the NHS (the underfunding, the pay cuts, the abysmal treatment of the staff) and tell me the piss poor state of it aren't a direct consequence.
Original post by ghostbeansgirl
Both my parents have worked all their life. Both of them have had many different jobs. Both now have relatively well paid jobs. Neither of them have EVER been offered free access to private health care. It seems as though you may be living inside a bit of a privilege bubble.


Honestly I have a **** paying job but have medical insurance. As does my dad. It's not that usual depending on the sector and company. Most people can straight up not afford private themselves
Original post by AnnaBloveme
Cause it's free but shite. Cancer survival rates are awful compared to 1st world countries & out waiting lists can be up to 12 months for simple stuff.
I haven't heard many good stories about it personally

That's because nobody's going to go swinging from the rafters screaming about how they had eye surgery and didn't lose their eye. It's sensationalised media that's giving the idea that everyone gets a bad treatment from the NHS, many of which are in the tory pocket.
Original post by englishhopeful98
you can't just say it's their fault all the time

They've been in government for 11 years. It's reasonable to blame the government for things it governs.
Original post by AnnaBloveme
Actually - many jobs give our private medical care as a perk of the job. Not many pay out of their own pocket

Provide statistics of the percentage of jobs that actually provide private healthcare in the UK and what the jobs are.

Original post by AnnaBloveme
Why compare it with America that's extreme. Plenty of countries offer very cheap healthcare better than the UK. With shorter waiting lists. Please research healthcare of places other than USA

Name the countries. I've already said that the NHS isn't perfect and every healthcare system has its flaws.
Original post by ghostbeansgirl
That's because nobody's going to go swinging from the rafters screaming about how they had eye surgery and didn't lose their eye. It's sensationalised media that's giving the idea that everyone gets a bad treatment from the NHS, many of which are in the tory pocket.

Lol a lot of my own relatives were shafted. And trying to get appointments myself. These are personal stories and my own experience not media hype. Also media stories can be correct and factual e.g ambulance waiting times in Wales are crazy

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending