The Student Room Group

Why are British people proud of NHS?

Scroll to see replies

Original post by AnnaBloveme
Lol a lot of my own relatives were shafted. And trying to get appointments myself. These are personal stories and my own experience not media hype. Also media stories can be correct and factual e.g ambulance waiting times in Wales are crazy

Ambulance waiting times are crazy because the NHS does not have the funding to hire an adequate amount of ambulance drivers. Once again, not an NHS problem, but a tory one.
Original post by hungrysalamander
Provide statistics of the percentage of jobs that actually provide private healthcare in the UK and what the jobs are.


Name the countries. I've already said that the NHS isn't perfect and every healthcare system has its flaws.

At this rate it's so far from perfect.
Australia, Germany, France, Sweden etc. all have better healthcare
Original post by AnnaBloveme
At this rate it's so far from perfect.
Australia, Germany, France, Sweden etc. all have better healthcare

And in those countries you will hear horror stories of people dying from papercuts because they couldn't afford to see a bloody doctor. I am so very confused why you seem so adamant that the solution to the NHS problem is simply to abandon it and everyone who can't afford to go private?
Original post by ghostbeansgirl
Ambulance waiting times are crazy because the NHS does not have the funding to hire an adequate amount of ambulance drivers. Once again, not an NHS problem, but a tory one.

Hahaha the NHS is underfunded partly because it's so expensive in the first place! How much should we be pumping into it? How many billions does it take to have decent healthcare. Just make everyone take out medical insurance. We pay for the dentist no-one complains about that constantly
Original post by ghostbeansgirl
And in those countries you will hear horror stories of people dying from papercuts because they couldn't afford to see a bloody doctor. I am so very confused why you seem so adamant that the solution to the NHS problem is simply to abandon it and everyone who can't afford to go private?

I just don't think the NHS was made to sustain such a massive ageing population. There's a reason why not many other countries have copied our free to point of use model...

Most countries have a cheap semi-private health scheme. Obviously the real poor in society would get it free just like everything else it would depend on your income level, benefits etc.
Original post by ghostbeansgirl
Even if it's "cheap" (this seems to be a rather relative term), there will still be those who cannot afford it. Plus the whole principal of having to pay to stay alive is ridiculous. We should focus on fixing the NHS, not selling it out and leaving behind the most vulnerable members of our society to die.


Naive. Those who can't afford it in other countries get it free. Just like the dentist - people on benefits don't pay or get a huge discount.

Australia has issues but people don't die on the street because they can't afford healthcare. Same in France or Germany?
You watched too much Breaking Bad

Also we do pay for the NHS technically. We just have no control over where the money goes. I wish i didn't get taxed for it.
Original post by AnnaBloveme
Hahaha the NHS is underfunded partly because it's so expensive in the first place! How much should we be pumping into it? How many billions does it take to have decent healthcare. Just make everyone take out medical insurance. We pay for the dentist no-one complains about that constantly

Once again, if you've never heard people saying anything about expensive dentist bills then I suggest you're living in a privilege bubble. If more effort was putting into streamlining the NHS it would not cost so much, and even then you cannot put a price on human life. It's not like the government doesn't spend truly exorbitant amounts on nuclear weapons development.
Original post by AnnaBloveme
At this rate it's so far from perfect.
Australia, Germany, France, Sweden etc. all have better healthcare

"Research other healthcare systems". Proceeds to list commonwealth/EU countries. France also has long wait times for non urgent cases, Germany and Australia doesn't cover dental care at all.

Original post by AnnaBloveme
Hahaha the NHS is underfunded partly because it's so expensive in the first place! How much should we be pumping into it? How many billions does it take to have decent healthcare. Just make everyone take out medical insurance. We pay for the dentist no-one complains about that constantly

You do realise that dental care is subsidised by the NHS, right? https://www.nhs.uk/nhs-services/dentists/dental-costs/how-much-will-i-pay-for-nhs-dental-treatment/
It is a lot cheaper to get dental care in the UK compared to the countries you listed. Why do you think that everyone can afford medical insurance? You're not provding alternatives to people who are less well-off and I can tell you made an account just to pick a fight with people as you dislike the NHS based on personal experience.
Original post by StriderHort
Never had to wait longer than a week in all my life.


Lucky
Original post by AnnaBloveme
Naive. Those who can't afford it in other countries get it free. Just like the dentist - people on benefits don't pay or get a huge discount.

Australia has issues but people don't die on the street because they can't afford healthcare. Same in France or Germany?
You watched too much Breaking Bad

Also we do pay for the NHS technically. We just have no control over where the money goes. I wish i didn't get taxed for it.

Okay so I'm obviously arguing with a baby tory here, so I may as well save my breath. We also pay for the queen to sit around on her royal arse all year, but I really don't see you complaining about that. I for one have absolutely no problem with paying for the NHS if it means that I and the rest of the country get access to it when we need it. Putting barriers up to accessing this healthcare will kill people REGARDLESS of if there's new systems put in place, as there will always be those who slip through the gaps. Why shouldn't we just have a catch-all service? Why are you so against helping people stay alive, at little to no cost to you?
Original post by AnnaBloveme
Naive. Those who can't afford it in other countries get it free.

What countries?
Original post by hungrysalamander
"Research other healthcare systems". Proceeds to list commonwealth/EU countries. France also has long wait times for non urgent cases, Germany and Australia doesn't cover dental care at all.


You do realise that dental care is subsidised by the NHS, right? https://www.nhs.uk/nhs-services/dentists/dental-costs/how-much-will-i-pay-for-nhs-dental-treatment/
It is a lot cheaper to get dental care in the UK compared to the countries you listed. Why do you think that everyone can afford medical insurance? You're not provding alternatives to people who are less well-off and I can tell you made an account just to pick a fight with people as you dislike the NHS based on personal experience.

Yep NHS has done jack for people I know.
It's subsided by the government but my point still stands - we happily pay for the dentist but paying for the GP would be really bad? Why?
What's wrong with listing EU/commonwealth countries?
At the end of the day NHS model has not been vastly copied. Going semi private is what most countries have - it's not that scandalous to suggest it.
Original post by ghostbeansgirl
Once again, if you've never heard people saying anything about expensive dentist bills then I suggest you're living in a privilege bubble. If more effort was putting into streamlining the NHS it would not cost so much, and even then you cannot put a price on human life. It's not like the government doesn't spend truly exorbitant amounts on nuclear weapons development.

Privileged bubble 😂 sorry I don't kiss NHS ass.
Why make this about nuclear weapons - you're changing the topic. We spend vast amounts of money on NHS and it's still not very good.
Tory & labour governments both underfunded it because it's so hard to fully fund.
Original post by AnnaBloveme
Privileged bubble 😂 sorry I don't kiss NHS ass.
Why make this about nuclear weapons - you're changing the topic. We spend vast amounts of money on NHS and it's still not very good.
Tory & labour governments both underfunded it because it's so hard to fully fund.

It's not that hard, the last labour government just had a very expensive war to fund (**** you Tony Blair) and the tory government actually stands to benefit off a defunct NHS. You're refusing to give statistics, refusing to give more than the same 3 EU countries as examples and then saying that we're changing the subject when we point out flaws in your logic. Are you sure you just don't like sharing?
Original post by AnnaBloveme
Yep NHS has done jack for people I know.
It's subsided by the government but my point still stands - we happily pay for the dentist but paying for the GP would be really bad? Why?
What's wrong with listing EU/commonwealth countries?
At the end of the day NHS model has not been vastly copied. Going semi private is what most countries have - it's not that scandalous to suggest it.

I'm wondering what level of "semi-private" you are speaking about? From what I understood, a lot of NHS functions are also largely supported by private tenders and contracts. Not everything they do is fully based on the government either.
Original post by summerbirdreads
What countries?


Australia has Medicare which allows people to get access to public hospitals including inpatient care, medical services, drugs. Students & low income residents get medical treatment free
Reply 76
Original post by AnnaBloveme
Hahaha the NHS is underfunded partly because it's so expensive in the first place! How much should we be pumping into it? How many billions does it take to have decent healthcare. Just make everyone take out medical insurance. We pay for the dentist no-one complains about that constantly

Thats a lot less fair though.
Original post by AnnaBloveme
Australia has Medicare which allows people to get access to public hospitals including inpatient care, medical services, drugs. Students & low income residents get medical treatment free

You said countries...Australia is only a country.
Original post by AnnaBloveme
Yep NHS has done jack for people I know.
It's subsided by the government but my point still stands - we happily pay for the dentist but paying for the GP would be really bad? Why?
What's wrong with listing EU/commonwealth countries?
At the end of the day NHS model has not been vastly copied. Going semi private is what most countries have - it's not that scandalous to suggest it.

Yeah done jack for the private posh people you know. Listing only developed countries show that healthcare is a luxury for some people. We are fortunate enough to have access to free healthcare while you're trying to dismantle it. Each country has its own needs so no country will replicate a model exactly, but most countries with public healthcare systems usually have a higher life expectancy and quality of life.
(edited 2 years ago)
Original post by hungrysalamander
Yeah done jack for the private posh people you know. You see your GP who would refer you to a specialist when appropriate. Costs would pile up quickly if many referrals are needed or for costly treatments/scans. Dentists usually only refer to specialists when they detect other problems or needs more facilities. Listing only developed countries show that healthcare is a luxury for some people. We are fortunate enough to have access to free healthcare while you're trying to dismantle it. Each country has its own needs so no country will replicate a model exactly, but most countries with public healthcare systems usually have a higher life expectancy and quality of life.

PRSOM

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending