The Student Room Group

Why are British people proud of NHS?

Scroll to see replies

Reply 80
Original post by ghostbeansgirl
Once again, if you've never heard people saying anything about expensive dentist bills then I suggest you're living in a privilege bubble. If more effort was putting into streamlining the NHS it would not cost so much, and even then you cannot put a price on human life. It's not like the government doesn't spend truly exorbitant amounts on nuclear weapons development.

also people with life long illness or have difficulty paying for dentist bills get it for free....from the NHS
Original post by ghostbeansgirl
It's not that hard, the last labour government just had a very expensive war to fund (**** you Tony Blair) and the tory government actually stands to benefit off a defunct NHS. What is so hard for your brain to grasp here? You're refusing to give statistics, refusing to give more than the same 3 EU countries as examples and then saying that we're changing the subject when we point out flaws in your logic. Are you sure you just don't like sharing?

Mate you haven't given stats to say why NHS is so wonderful.

Gov website:
Despite this, cancer survival in England remains lower than similar countries in Europe and around the world according to recent studies. These international comparisons have been reported by International Cancer Benchmarking Partnership (ICBP), EUROCARE-5 and CONCORD-3.

You can cover labour but they did the same as Tories are doing. Neither parties funded it properly
Original post by AnnaBloveme
I agree we worship it just because it's free..

People think if we don't have NHS we have to have USA style medical.
They forget most European countries & Australia have decent cheap healthcare too.

There was a 49 week wait to see a specialist at my local - that's a year to see one person! Ridiculous!
With private medical it was 4 week wait.


One recommended site when comparing other national health care services: https://www.kingsfund.org.uk/publications/articles/big-election-questions-nhs-international-comparisons

Most other EU countries have the same waiting times generally. At the end of the day, how long your waiting time is depends on where your local area is anyway. Can't always blame the NHS for it.

Don't need to argue as if long waiting times is due to public funding. Once you remove the public-funding bit and become fully privatized, the patients will just flock onto the same medical centre anyway. It is not as if 60% or 70% of patients in your local are people living in poverty. You would even get ridiculous waiting lists in the US too.

Logically, this entire argument is just pitiful and faulty honestly.
Original post by summerbirdreads
You said countries...Australia is only a country.

I lived there so I have more in depth knowledge of Australia. I can explain it in more detail but I doubt you will care. Do you have a legit response?
Original post by AnnaBloveme
Mate you haven't given stats to say why NHS is so wonderful.

Gov website:
Despite this, cancer survival in England remains lower than similar countries in Europe and around the world according to recent studies. These international comparisons have been reported by International Cancer Benchmarking Partnership (ICBP), EUROCARE-5 and CONCORD-3.

You can cover labour but they did the same as Tories are doing. Neither parties funded it properly


One site gives a decent overview in my opinion: https://www.kingsfund.org.uk/publications/articles/big-election-questions-nhs-international-comparisons
Original post by AnnaBloveme
I lived there so I have more in depth knowledge of Australia. I can explain it in more detail but I doubt you will care. Do you have a legit response?


Original post by AnnaBloveme
Naive. Those who can't afford it in other countries get it free.

You said that earlier, yet you can't list a few countries for me. It just isn't true, I can tell you. Maybe in a few developed countries especially the ones in Europe and North Americas but not everywhere..
Original post by AnnaBloveme
we happily pay for the dentist but paying for the GP would be really bad? Why?

That’s a good question and the answer is because if all dental work was completely subsidised by the NHS, it would become bankrupt before the end of the year.

When the NHS was set up in 1948, dental care was actually completely free. However by 1952, the demand for dentures, amongst other care, was so high that it did almost bankrupt the system. As such, fees for dental treatment were introduced to avoid the collapse of the NHS.

People complain about dentistry being expensive, which is fair enough, but that’s because it genuinely is an expensive industry, rather than dentists just being greedy and wanting to pocket 99% of your money.
(edited 2 years ago)
Original post by wifd149
One recommended site when comparing other national health care services: https://www.kingsfund.org.uk/publications/articles/big-election-questions-nhs-international-comparisons

Most other EU countries have the same waiting times generally. At the end of the day, how long your waiting time is depends on where your local area is anyway. Can't always blame the NHS for it.

Don't need to argue as if long waiting times is due to public funding. Once you remove the public-funding bit and become fully privatized, the patients will just flock onto the same medical centre anyway. It is not as if 60% or 70% of patients in your local are people living in poverty. You would even get ridiculous waiting lists in the US too.

Logically, this entire argument is just pitiful and faulty honestly

The fact is if governments have to spend ridiculous amounts on the NHS when they could copy most other countries and introduce semi-private system. It can't get worse than it currently is now...

Switzerland has one of the lower waiting times. Only 12% have to wait over a day to see a doctor. In Switzerland it's also compulsory to have private medical insurance. Compare to the worst Canada 33% who have a similar system to us with tax funded healthcare. In UK it's 21% which isn't awful but certainly not good. From these stats there's an argument that tax funded healthcare systems tend to have longer waiting times to see doctors.

https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/health-care-wait-times-by-country
Original post by Mesopotamian.
That’s a good question and the answer is because if all dental work was completely subsidised by the NHS, it would become bankrupt before the end of the year.

When the NHS was set up in 1948, dental care was actually completely free. However by 1952, the demand for dentures, amongst other care, was so high that it did almost bankrupt the system. As such, fees for dental treatment were introduced to avoid the collapse of the NHS.

People complain about dentistry being expensive, which is fair enough, but that’s because it genuinely is an expensive industry, rather than dentists just being greedy and wanting to pocket 99% of your money

That's interesting tbf
Original post by AnnaBloveme
The fact is if governments have to spend ridiculous amounts on the NHS when they could copy most other countries and introduce semi-private system. It can't get worse than it currently is now...

Switzerland has one of the lower waiting times. Only 12% have to wait over a day to see a doctor. In Switzerland it's also compulsory to have private medical insurance. Compare to the worst Canada 33% who have a similar system to us with tax funded healthcare. In UK it's 21% which isn't awful but certainly not good. From these stats there's an argument that tax funded healthcare systems tend to have longer waiting times to see doctors.

https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/health-care-wait-times-by-country

Gosh, that's awfully familiar, that style of posting. And you just joined today to contribute 20+ posts to this thread, which just happened to be in Chat.
The NHS is objectively very good by global healthcare standards, and its a good asset as a country, although im not sure I would say im proud of it.

I’ve always hated how healthcare in the UK is presented as a binary option, and that having any pragmatic discussion about healthcare means you hate the NHS. The NHS does get a giant amount of funding, its revenue dwarfs that of the UKs most successful private sector companies and even that of global conglomerates.

I really think we have a generally decent system but we should have a full evaluation of what can be achieved with the amount of public sector money put into it, im also not against partial privatisation, their are excellent examples of how public & private healthcare can be integrated well in lots of ‘western-esque societies’ including the EUs biggest economy.

I think we have gotten to a point where the hard ideological take of all hail the NHS isn’t actually practical way of ensuring its as good as it can be with the huge flow of public resources it uses.
Original post by StriderHort
I don't think they are right in that referencing one countries healthcare weakens the argument for another's, that's just a petty argument tactic imo. But I'd agree it does provide us with a 'super evil' baseline to compare ourselves to positively.

But they're also claiming 3 months and more to see a Doctor! and other such suss statements, so 0 right points. None.

literally if it wasn't called something ('the NHS') like our comprehensive schooling system isn't called "the almighty NES" people wouldn't have any idol to worship and would just see it as part of the public sector like anything else...
Original post by AnnaBloveme
Yep NHS has done jack for people I know.
It's subsided by the government but my point still stands - we happily pay for the dentist but paying for the GP would be really bad? Why?
What's wrong with listing EU/commonwealth countries?
At the end of the day NHS model has not been vastly copied. Going semi private is what most countries have - it's not that scandalous to suggest it.

We don't, many people can't even get an NHS dentist despite needing to pay for it and if there was an option to make it free, majority of people would be in favour
Original post by artful_lounger
In that case why aren't you complaining about how the firefighters arent' "free"?

Because I'm getting a good service from them, my money is getting spent well.
Original post by niloomiloo
Because I'm getting a good service from them, my money is getting spent well.

Do you have house fires often, then?
Reply 95
ngl if I call the GP for an appointment I can get one same day. it really is just your local area and what GP you use
Original post by Reality Check
Do you have house fires often, then?

Haha that was quite hilarious ngl....
Original post by summerbirdreads
Haha that was quite hilarious ngl....

:laugh: sounds awfully inconvenient, non?
Original post by Reality Check
:laugh: sounds awfully inconvenient, non?

I mean at least the money is getting spent well.
Original post by Reality Check
Do you have house fires often, then?

They really have to stop putting grease fires out with water.

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending