There will be no mercy for the Scots

If that were true, why does the SNP want more immigration.

If that were true, why does the SNP want more immigration.

In fact, what you acknowledge, is that the mass immigration that has happened in the UK is in fact an attack on our identities. Haha.

I've certainly not lost my identity through mass immigration.

What i make a point of is that Salmond wants even higher immigration than now (not suprising as a Euro-Federalist as recently as 2007).

His immigration stance has nothing to do with the underlying psychological aspects that is driving this yearning for Scottish identity.

True but if i recall your original point prompting my reply you seemed to be suggesting that an independent Scotland would be a purer, less immigrant filled nation. That's unlikely to be true.

No, that is not what I meant.

Although any country that has less diversity will be better off.

Although any country that has less diversity will be better off.

I think this is an important point. Isn't the truth that Westminster politicians have taken diversity as a good in itself regardless of the results of it. When in actual fact, mass immigration has been a disaster for the United Kingdom. We now need to see UKIP immigration policy.

Multiculturalism has been a disaster for the United Kingdom. Little clusters of migrants have formed in certain areas, people have asked for incentives to integrate. No you don't get them, if you are lucky enough to come here you integrate. If you want to be surrounded by people from your own culture then stay in your own country.

On the OPs issue, if they'd have voted Yes I'd have wanted to make it as difficult as possible for them, give them the maximum amount of the debt and the minimum amount of money. But it's all irrelevant now.

Multi-culturalism has been ongoing in Britain for thousands of years-the only difference is that since the war these cultures are of those with different coloured skin. Where I come from in the West Midlands there has been substantial immigration from the sub continent since the 1960s and they are as integrated as anyone else. And the community has benefited enormously from them doing so.

Sparkhill? A categorical example of the failures of multiculturalism surely? It's like South East Asia in Britain.

Multi-culturalism has been ongoing in Britain for thousands of years-the only difference is that since the war these cultures are of those with different coloured skin. Where I come from in the West Midlands there has been substantial immigration from the sub continent since the 1960s and they are as integrated as anyone else. And the community has benefited enormously from them doing so.

Well this is a trendy sound-bite, but it does not survive more than a moments careful reflection. Firstly you are conflating multi-multiculturalism with immigration and the two are obvious not the same, in the past integration was essentially total. There are many descendants of huguenots in Norwich, Vikings in York, Irish in Liverpool and Jews in Essex but who are they? Where are the Irish 'community leaders' or any of the nonsense we have today? They blended in, this was natural without some artificial policy of multi-culturalism imposed from the state.

But those 3rd generation Bangladeshis in Tower Hamlets who vote solely along ethnic lines, those muslims with radically different social/political/cultural ideas etc etc are not going to blend into the fabric of the country like the Whitechapel Jews did a century ago. They are perfectly aware that they have much to gain from resisting that, and so here we are. A country in which neighbours in many major cities neither understand, trust or can even stand each other. Fractured down these lines as a consequence of this nonsense.

Of course many groups are well integrated, but this is in spite of the disastrous policy of mass immigration and state multiculti

What's your problem with it?