The Student Room Group

Edexcel Government and Politics Unit 2 Exam 4th June 2015

Scroll to see replies

Original post by xxvine
Thats the thing
constitution questions are limited

codified or uncodified?

assess labours constitutional reforms?

strengths of the constitution?

What else can they possibly ask for a 40 marker?


Could be a 40 marker on something like 'Is parliament still sovereign?'
Original post by marthakirby
Could be a 40 marker on something like 'Is parliament still sovereign?'


is that a constitution question or parliament question?

for that question how would you answer it? I have never come across that question before. scared now
is constitutional reforms since 1997 likely to come up?
Original post by xxvine
is that a constitution question or parliament question?

for that question how would you answer it? I have never come across that question before. scared now


I think its in constitution because the specification has parliamentary sovereignty... but I could be wrong!

I think just define sovereignty - legal sov. & political sov.

WAYS SOVEREIGNTY HAS CHANGED:
EU MEMBERSHIP: challenges legal sov. due to transfer of power in some areas e.g agriculture - policy decided by EU for example CAP, CFP. supranational nature of EU = EU law superior to national law. Decline of national veto due to 2007 Lisbon Treaty.
DEVOLUTION: de facto transfer of sovereignty - power taken from Parl. to local bodies - power fragmentation - cannot intervene in devolved issues e.g health.
REFERENDUMS (?): increased use - people make decisions = have more power. Especially in binding referendums - cannot repeal due to popular sovereignty for example Bristol referendum 2001 - not raise council tax.

WAYS PARLIAMENT IS STILL SOVEREIGN:
EU: can leave EU by repealing EU Community Act - power/sovereignty is 'pooled' not lost.
DEVOLUTION: can repeal - mostly spending powers not law making so does not really affect sovereignty.
REFERENDUMS: gov chooses when to hold and the topic - easy way to pass laws e.g 1975 EU referendum (gov sure on a yes vote) - voting on a fait accompli. Referendums are also not held as regularly as in other countries e.g Switzerland.

(Legal sovereignty will always remain with Parl)
Original post by lizmoo0721
is constitutional reforms since 1997 likely to come up?


Came up last year as 25 marker so its unlikely! :smile:
yesssssssssssssssss woooo
Well, The Constitution hasn't come up as a 40 marker in the last two papers, so it probably will this time?

Maybe it will be "Should the UK have a codified constitution?"
Reply 187
Original post by marthakirby
Statute law is written law passed by legislative body/Parliament.
Common law is case law that has developed from decisions made by the judiciary/courts (after they interpret the meaning of statutes it is binding on all lower courts).


Thankyouuu


Posted from TSR Mobile
Original post by marthakirby
I think its in constitution because the specification has parliamentary sovereignty... but I could be wrong!

I think just define sovereignty - legal sov. & political sov.
Wow thanks

WAYS SOVEREIGNTY HAS CHANGED:
EU MEMBERSHIP: challenges legal sov. due to transfer of power in some areas e.g agriculture - policy decided by EU for example CAP, CFP. supranational nature of EU = EU law superior to national law. Decline of national veto due to 2007 Lisbon Treaty.
DEVOLUTION: de facto transfer of sovereignty - power taken from Parl. to local bodies - power fragmentation - cannot intervene in devolved issues e.g health.
REFERENDUMS (?): increased use - people make decisions = have more power. Especially in binding referendums - cannot repeal due to popular sovereignty for example Bristol referendum 2001 - not raise council tax.

WAYS PARLIAMENT IS STILL SOVEREIGN:
EU: can leave EU by repealing EU Community Act - power/sovereignty is 'pooled' not lost.
DEVOLUTION: can repeal - mostly spending powers not law making so does not really affect sovereignty.
REFERENDUMS: gov chooses when to hold and the topic - easy way to pass laws e.g 1975 EU referendum (gov sure on a yes vote) - voting on a fait accompli. Referendums are also not held as regularly as in other countries e.g Switzerland.

(Legal sovereignty will always remain with Parl)

Wow thanks
Original post by marthakirby
came up last year as 25 marker so its unlikely! :smile:


woooooooooooooooooo
Reply 190
2 thingssss
1- what is case law
2- is fixed term parliaments a proposed or actual reform of 2010?
Original post by Sot15
2 thingssss
1- what is case law
2- is fixed term parliaments a proposed or actual reform of 2010?


Actual 2011
Reply 192
ohhh and what year was power transferred to eu?
Reply 193
Original post by RussMo124
Actual 2011

oops
Original post by marthakirby
Came up last year as 25 marker so its unlikely! :smile:


So what can come up?
Original post by xxvine
So what can come up?


constitutional reforms since 1997
:smile:
Original post by xxvine
So what can come up?


For constitution if its 40 marker probably one of:

Advantages/disadvantages of UK constitution
Should UK have codified constitution?
How has location of sovereignty changed in UK?
How far is UK constitution out of date?

Unless they ask another about 1997 reforms / bring up 2010 proposed reforms etc.

It could be more specific about reforms e.g how have reforms since 1997 affected power of gov or affected democracy.. hard to tell.
Original post by marthakirby
For constitution if its 40 marker probably one of:

Advantages/disadvantages of UK constitution
Should UK have codified constitution?
How has location of sovereignty changed in UK?
How far is UK constitution out of date?

Unless they ask another about 1997 reforms / bring up 2010 proposed reforms etc.

It could be more specific about reforms e.g how have reforms since 1997 affected power of gov or affected democracy.. hard to tell.

Is thr far out of date one same as should the uk have an uncodified constitution?
Who's staying up tonight to revise for this exam?
Reply 199
Original post by simmy123
Who's staying up tonight to revise for this exam?


Who isn't?


Posted from TSR Mobile

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending