Doctor Who - Discussion Thread II

+1 for this when I can rate posts again. Why did I use them all up? River and the Doctor are the most awesome couple ever to set foot on the TARDIS. I bet she is actually his wife.

They're just so darn cute! Isn't anyone still completely obsessed with Doctor Who in the good old days (season one and two, and perhaps the end of season four)? Though I loved Donna and Martha had her moments, I feel like Doctor Who has really changed (obviously). Steven Moffat's out of control in his quest to leave his mark on the show! He says he's not too keen on the character and is unlikely to re-introduce her to the Eleventh Doctor.



Please let me know your thoughts on them! Cute moments, cool videos...your opinion on the couple (so long as it's the right opinion ).

Yeah, just ain't the same thesedays. I miss the "team". Rose, Jack, Mickey etc. Feel nothing for Amy, Rory or River Song. Meh.

Amy, Rory, River > Rose, Jack, Mickey.

You are so wrong that I feel sorry for you.

And your wrongness makes me happy.

Happiness > Pity

Guess I win again

Just because you want to bang Rory. D: <

THIS!

She also had an amazing repertoire with the Doctor, and I loved how she seemed 'real' as a character.

Curse you guys! I tried to stay off this site but Doctor Who drove me back on :/ Long time lurker on this thread but I would like to add my two cents having read the majority of it (sad I know).

Firstly a couple of things I don't seem to get (even having watched it 3 times).

Why does it take the doctor 5 days to rescue Amy? We know she's been in that tardis-esque thing for five days but where has he been? Surely he can't be certain they'd wait until the moon landing to "bring silence"?

Also did people not find the silence defeat a little bit easy? It seems like the doctor is being set up for something by his own cleverness (just a general feeling here)

I think River looked mighty shifty when they were discussing the silents. Not sure what minute this was on, but when they are doing the hand injections thing she looks down when the doctor says he can't remember them either to Canton. Possibly implying she's in/was in cahoots with them?

River also says "Well I say she's human" when inspecting the space suit. Being an archeologist you'd think she'd know. So maybe the kid ain't a time lord?

With reference to that spoiler on the web please delete this or tell me if its not allowed


Also with reference to the "last kiss" bit. She may think its the last kiss. But surely there's that picnic where the doctor gives her the screw driver, just before SITL? I think this will be the bit where the doctor and River know everything about each other, at the same time. So can have a nice day out for once

I don't want to see Rose back. I liked Rose but it was starting to get annoying where she just had to keep reappearing throughout the Tennant era. I really liked Martha and I know not many people did, but I think she was my favourite companion!

I don't think the silents really are defeated there was one in 2011 remember? and he said humans would be fighting them for generations. I'm sure they will come back.