The Student Room Group

really basic m1 kinematics question

A ball A is thrown vertically downwards with speed 5ms^-1 from the top of a tower block 46m above the ground. At the same time as A is thrown downwards, another ball B is thrown vertically upwards from the ground with speed 18ms^-1. The balls collide.

Find the distance of the point where A and B collide from the point where A was thrown.

My working
Ball A: u = 5, a = 9.8, s = ? (taking down +ve)
Ball B: u = 18, a = -9.8, s = ? (taking down +ve)

Ball A: s = 5t + 4.9t^2
Ball B: s = 18t - 4.9t^2
5t + 4.9t^2 = 18t - 4.9t^2
9.8t^2 - 13t = 0
t(9.8t - 13) = 0
t = 13/9.8 = 1.32653...

Substituting t into equation A...

S = 5(13/9.8) + 4.9(13/9.8)^2
S = 15.25m

So it collides at 46m - 15.25m from the ground, since A was thrown off a tower 46m above ground. So the answer is 30.75m?

My book however says the answer is 30m to 2.s.f., so have I done it wrong and fluked? or does the book just have the wrong answer?

THANK YOU<3
Reply 1
Pretty sure the book is right. Your method is almost correct (equating two quadratics with t which are equal to s), but you missed something. You can't call both the distances 's', as they start 46 metres away from each other. Do you see what you should have done?

Spoiler



Edit: Re-reading your method, I should add you should probably keep the accelerations the same direction, makes cancelling the t^2 easier, but don't believe it's essential.
gcseeeman
Pretty sure the book is right. Your method is almost correct (equating two quadratics with t which are equal to s), but you missed something. You can't call both the distances 's', as they start 46 metres away from each other. Do you see what you should have done?

Spoiler



Edit: Re-reading your method, I should add you should probably keep the accelerations the same direction, makes cancelling the t^2 easier, but don't believe it's essential.
Using your way:
-46 = 5t + 4.9t^2 (BALL A)
0 = -18t + 4.9t^2 (BALL B)

therefore 5t + 4.9t^2 + 46 = 4.9t^2 - 18t
46 = -13t
t = 3.53846...

putting T into A:

s = 5(46/13) + 4.9(46/13)^2
s = 79.04378... umm :s
Reply 3
dumb maths student
Using your way:
-46 = 5t + 4.9t^2 (BALL A)
0 = -18t + 4.9t^2 (BALL B)

therefore 5t + 4.9t^2 + 46 = 4.9t^2 - 18t
46 = -13t
t = 3.53846...

putting T into A:

s = 5(46/13) + 4.9(46/13)^2
s = 79.04378... umm :s


Not exactly, you are mixing up the distances or something. I didn't check that thoroughly, but I think the minus 46 is on the wrong side. You also can't say one of them equals zero, it equals s. You just substitute it into the other one in place of s.
As you have posted quite a bit of working, I'll show you what you should have done for t:

Spoiler


Can you see what to do now for the distance?
gcseeeman
Not exactly, you are mixing up the distances or something. I didn't check that thoroughly, but I think the minus 46 is on the wrong side. You also can't say one of them equals zero, it equals s. You just substitute it into the other one in place of s.
As you have posted quite a bit of working, I'll show you what you should have done for t:

Spoiler


Can you see what to do now for the distance?
ah i see!

thanks for the help :smile: i was sweating for like 30 minutes straight trying to do this haha
Reply 5
You're welcome :smile:
dumb maths student
A ball A is thrown vertically downwards with speed 5ms^-1 from the top of a tower block 46m above the ground. At the same time as A is thrown downwards, another ball B is thrown vertically upwards from the ground with speed 18ms^-1. The balls collide.

Find the distance of the point where A and B collide from the point where A was thrown.

My working
Ball A: u = 5, a = 9.8, s = ? (taking down +ve)
Ball B: u = 18, a = -9.8, s = ? (taking down +ve)

Ball A: s = 5t + 4.9t^2
Ball B: s = 18t - 4.9t^2
5t + 4.9t^2 = 18t - 4.9t^2
9.8t^2 - 13t = 0
t(9.8t - 13) = 0
t = 13/9.8 = 1.32653...

Substituting t into equation A...

S = 5(13/9.8) + 4.9(13/9.8)^2
S = 15.25m

So it collides at 46m - 15.25m from the ground, since A was thrown off a tower 46m above ground. So the answer is 30.75m?

My book however says the answer is 30m to 2.s.f., so have I done it wrong and fluked? or does the book just have the wrong answer?

THANK YOU<3


EDIT: Just realised that both values aren't s.

Ball A is 46 - S
Ball B is S

EDIT2:

Other way around ^^
Reply 7
U are an idiot💋. Ur supposed to get displacemnt fot ball A first. sA= 4.9t^2 5tAnd then ball BsB= - 4.9t^2 18tAnd since sA sB = 46 so solve it and get the value of t. Substitute the vakue of t in the sA equation. Idiot
Reply 8
46m
(edited 6 months ago)
Reply 9
Original post by Nadzu
U are an idiot💋. Ur supposed to get displacemnt fot ball A first. sA= 4.9t^2 5tAnd then ball BsB= - 4.9t^2 18tAnd since sA sB = 46 so solve it and get the value of t. Substitute the vakue of t in the sA equation. Idiot

i agree 💋

Quick Reply

Latest