D&D Religion's "Ask About Judaism" Thread

When will you accept that you don't know more about Judaism than I do?

But he said a valid point.
This is a view that was shared by all religious leaders..According to another speaker.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h58N8q0OQBw&feature=related

I'll try again. In Judaism once a Jew always a Jew and sinner or not Jews go to Heaven. Some go straight, others go via Hell for "purification" first. When will you accept that you don't know more about Judaism than I do?

With all due respect, your answer blurs the requirement point.
We "Muslims" don't just pluck things out of thin air, untill we have subsantial evidence.
I was asking you for evidences from torah about many issues, and you with all due respect gave me your cold shoulder, could you possibly asking my direct Questions with frank answers.
1- Didn't prophet moses get anger upon who worhsiped idols and they repented to god by killing each others?
2- Didn't his follower repent to god?
3- Where is your proof from torah that godless jews are going to heaven? as well as prophet moses will surely deem them his follower if he is alive among us.

Thanks.

It has no meanining, In other words, it is false anaolgy.

We "Muslims" don't just pluck things out of thin air, untill we have subsantial evidence.

Actually not only him.
There still are many peace-maker rabbi against zionisim.

Please stop quoting Neturei Karta on this topic. .

But, didn't he make a valid arguemnt.
I mean, it is impossible that all jews before Zionism movements throughout the history were be considered a "deluded people"?

It's not a false analogy - you just failed to understand it.

Chosen people = God has put on them more obligations than the rest->
the chosen people "owe" God the "Mitzvot", whether they choose to believe in it or not.

1) Moses got angry because they had sinned. They repented and were killed in order to atone for their sin and enter Heaven.
.

Two flows.
1- So, why god created other races, surely his inseparable attribute rejects that he created them for no reason!.
2-Jews believe in prophets from other races before their existence.


By assuming that Prophet moses is alive among us, he will treat those godless by the same treatment in order to believe in god and at least for atone their sin and enter heaven, true?

I have no time for the NK or their arguments, really. Zionism came about at a time when Jews were finally being given some sort of freedom from persecution. Before then I expect Jews were more concerned with not being massacred than with trying to reestablish a homeland for themselves. But returning to Israel has been an ever-present hope and dream since the exile began.

I can easily prove to you historically and religiously that you are wrong, but it seem to me will have no end.

But tell me - have you accepted that all Jews go to Heaven in the end even if they sin heavily? Even if they do not believe in God?

I highly doubt that you could. For one thing if it were so easy you would have just done it rather than tell me how easy it would be for you to do it.

I think i can agree that all of jews wheather they are believer or disbleiever only will go to heaven, if only an idea is dismissed out of hand. "Do you know what?".

Two flows.
1- So, why god created other races, surely his inseparable attribute rejects that he created them for no reason!.

2-Jews believe in prophets from other races before their existence.

??

Thanks so much for your neggating.
Fair enough, It seems you would like to argue about it, but hopefully you don't consider it a political issue shouldn't be discussed here later as you did with ABR with regard the rest of jews who are trying to burn the mosque.