Edexcel GCSE History Paper 1 (1HI0 10-13) - 18th May 2023 [Exam Chat]

(Original post by Rushdis)I talked about avoidance in both of them. In medieval in Black Death people moved away from areas with a lots of cases and didn’t allow strangers into village similarly to how in modern we quarantine infected e.g Ebola, covid so they’re away from the healthy but idk if I’m right

I talked about how quarantine was performed during the bubonic plague and lockdown and isolation in the modern period in England due to covid 19

Reply 61

username5792062

5

I completely messed up that 12 marker how did I not think of these ideas 😭

Reply 62

da0sy

10

Original post by Rushdis

What did people write for the 12 marker I hated it so much I completely waffled. I talked about the NHS as a 3rd point but for the rest I just talked about things ppl would get for free at GP/hospitals e.g ultrasounds

I put about the NHS, liberal reforms and access to cancer diagnosis/treatment via the NHS. Also, in source b , was the new treatment they were describing the Carrol dankin method ?

Reply 63

xxxNeroxxx

5

Original post by jfatt

i put praying ffs - most people in my year put quarantine or warding away miasma

Don’t worry! I put warding away miasma, but I nearly put quarantine. Honestly I’m pretty sure quarantine only occurred in the Renaissance, 1665 Great Plague, but they might still get marks.

EDIT: Woops.

(edited 11 months ago)

Reply 64

speedrunningGCSE

6

Original post by xxxNeroxxx

Don’t worry! I put warding away miasma, but I nearly put quarantine. Honestly I’m pretty sure quarantine only occurred in the Renaissance, 1665 Great Plague, but they might still get marks.

You are wrong. There was a quarantine during the bubonic plague not on an national level but in towns and small villages.

Reply 65

imco55505

5

Original post by thismyusername

Anyone else do warfare through time?

yeah i do... how did you find it?

Reply 66

username5792062

5

Yeahh it was, that’s what I put

Original post by da0sy

I put about the NHS, liberal reforms and access to cancer diagnosis/treatment via the NHS. Also, in source b , was the new treatment they were describing the Carrol dankin method ?

Reply 67

2muchlikehardwrk

7

Original post by thismyusername

Anyone else do warfare through time?

That 12 marker got me bad - feudal army lost popularity? what a weird question. waffled a bit about battle of Falkirk and poor discipline because they were mostly serfs etc etc. Not sure about that one. Naseby was good though for the 16 marker

Reply 68

xxxNeroxxx

5

Original post by Rushdis

I talked about avoidance in both of them. In medieval in Black Death people moved away from areas with a lots of cases and didn’t allow strangers into village similarly to how in modern we quarantine infected e.g Ebola, covid so they’re away from the healthy but idk if I’m right

Such a good answer!!! I nearly put quarantine but I chickened out because I couldn’t remember if it was done in The Black Death or only during the Great Plague. I’ve had a look and I’m pretty sure you’re right.

Reply 69

MishMohan

5

What do you think the Grade Boundaries will be?

Reply 70

xxxNeroxxx

5

Original post by speedrunningGCSE

You are wrong. There was a quarantine during the bubonic plague not on an national level but in towns and small villages.

Yeah, apologies & thanks, I just realised, but oh well. It’s what I get for being a chicken I guess 😂😂

We've just put up an article of student reactions to the exam - take a look!

Featuring @jfatt and @Lil Sumi 👀

Reply 72

TapTim007

1

Original post by Lil Sumi

The first question in crime and punishment paper was so weird and unexpected it was about describing 2 features of growth of socialism in whitechapel and the 12 marker was a bit hard so waffled a bit apart from that the rest of the paper was good

I agree - the first question was so odd. Didn't know what to write so put anarchism .... rest of paper did not go well. does anyone eremember the question about how prisoners were treated - what were the 2 time periods?. I might have messed up there too!! the 12 marker was okish - I chose about Robert Peel and his achievements

Reply 73

Maoamking1

3

GCSE history crime and punishment (paper 1)

anyone add their own points/thoughts on mine

Q1a) Two features of the growth of socialism
Spread by Immigrants e.g Russian Jews brought socialist ideas into Whitechapel after migrating from Russia to avoid persecution
Was feared? e.g the government was afraid that the growth of socialism could challenge capitalist ideologies

Q1b) Question was on how conditions in Whitechapel affected police.
source A was really nice, first hand H division officer account of struggles
sourceB was not so nice, illustration of some poor people

Q2) Follow up Q, i personally chose the poor lighting and asked if the lighting in whitechapel hindered the police. Used H-division first hand witness as a source

Q3) main difference between treatment of young criminals 1700-1900 vs 1900-present
crime and punishment first question wasn't too bad. I said 1700-1900 was more deterrence (Transportation) 1900-present more rehabilative (borstals)

Q4) Why were there changes in use of community law enforcement 1000-1700 (I think)
1. Population growth (e.g doubled 1485-1603, meant law enforcement needed to change)
2. Centralisation (e.g coroners, king wanted more power in more serious crime)
3. Change in nature of crime (more serious crimes due to reformation/religious turmoil, more serious crimes more likely to not be dealt with by the community)

Q5) option 1: To what extent did the nature of crime change 1000-1700
For: more crimes against authority due to religious turmoil/population instability (e.g heresy, witchcraft, treason)
For: New crimes introduced to secure William's power (e.g forest laws. William had to secure power as Normans were outnumbered)
Against: Continuity in crimes against a person (e.g Theft or murder, murder punished by wergild in 1000, murder punished by execution in 1700 shows it stayed the same over the period)

Q6) To what extent was Peel the most important reason for change in law enforcement 1700-1900? (not sure)
Didnt do this question so don't have any points.

let me know what you guys think!

Reply 74

emilyworrell

6

medicine student here,

i think i’ve done perfectly on everything other than the 12 marker
my points were penicillin, NHS and i mentioned florence nightengale but she’s not apart of modern so i’m so mad

how many marks do you think i will lose because of this?

Reply 75

raantaaro

7

Original post by Lil Sumi

The first question in crime and punishment paper was so weird and unexpected it was about describing 2 features of growth of socialism in whitechapel and the 12 marker was a bit hard so waffled a bit apart from that the rest of the paper was good

stop i lovedd the 12 marker and i correctly predicted that the first question would be on radical political beliefs im shocked

Reply 76

slklylmlalk

3

Original post by emilyworrell

medicine student here,

i think i’ve done perfectly on everything other than the 12 marker
my points were penicillin, NHS and i mentioned florence nightengale but she’s not apart of modern so i’m so mad

how many marks do you think i will lose because of this?

Not too many as only 1/3 of your answer is out of the range. However, it may be okay if you reference how it influences the modern period but idk. I'm super annoyed because I put NHS, Florence Nightingale and GERM THEORY!!!!

Reply 77

evpoo102

3

the renaissance 16 marker on medicine was sooooooooo leng

Reply 78

slklylmlalk

3

Btw did anyone notice the typo in the medicine 16 marker? It said that observationes medicae was 1576 but it's actually 1676.

Reply 79

emilyworrell

6

Original post by slklylmlalk

Not too many as only 1/3 of your answer is out of the range. However, it may be okay if you reference how it influences the modern period but idk. I'm super annoyed because I put NHS, Florence Nightingale and GERM THEORY!!!!

i did mention that the hospitals were cleaner and looked more modern so maybe i’ll pick up a mark.

At least we both put Nightengale we’re in this together ✊

Edexcel GCSE History Paper 1 (1HI0 10-13) - 18th May 2023 [Exam Chat]

Quick Reply

Related discussions

Latest

Trending

Trending

Articles for you