The Student Room Group

TSR best (post-war) PM tournament: SF2: Brown v Wilson

This poll is closed

Who was the best British (post-war) prime minister?

Gordon Brown20%
Harold Wilson80%
Total votes: 10
Welcome to the TSR best (post-war) PM tournament!
This is semi-final 2
TSR is asking the question: Who is the best (post-war) UK Prime Minster?



We're holding a tournament of UK Prime Ministers and asking you to vote to determine which was the most significant in history. We are currently in the semi-final stages of this tournament, and this is semi-final 2. This is now a head-to-head shootout for a coveted place in the grand final!

There's a hub thread here if you're interested in reading more about how the competition has progressed.

The PMs in semi-final 2 are:

brown_1610219c.jpg
Gordon Brown (Labour, 2007–10)

James Gordon Brown was MP for Dunfermline East and later Kirkcaldy and Cowdenbeath from 1983 to 2015. He held various shadow cabinet posts, including shadow chancellor under John Smith and then Tony Blair, having allegedly stood aside to allow Blair to become Labour leader following Smith's sudden death in 1994, on the understanding that Blair would eventually stand down and hand over to him. Brown was one of the architects of New Labour in the mid-90s, and became chancellor in 1997. The often frosty dynamic between Brown and Blair and their supporters dominated Blair's premiership until he resigned in 2007 and made way for Brown. Brown entered office without much of a unique plan for government, but soon found a purpose as the global financial crisis bit. Although Brown played a leading international role in calming matters, the public did not necessarily see it that way, and the opposition managed to accuse Brown and Labour of crashing the economy themselves. Brown only fought one election as PM, in 2010: this produced a hung parliament, but with Labour clearly in second place, so when the Conservatives and Lib Dems agreed a coalition, Brown resigned as PM and Labour leader.


article-2277847-000097B200000CB2-753_308x185.jpg
Harold Wilson (Labour, 1964–70 and 1974–76)

James Harold Wilson was MP for Ormskirk and then Huyton in Lancashire from 1945 to 1983. He first joined Clement Attlee's cabinet in 1947 as president of the Board of Trade until Labour lost the 1951 election. In 1955 Wilson became shadow chancellor, then shadow foreign secretary in 1961, under leader of the opposition Hugh Gaitskell. Gaitskell died in office in 1963, and Wilson assumed the leadership of the party, winning the 1964 election narrowly against a tired Conservative government on its fourth PM, then winning a much bigger majority in 1966 in a snap election. This first period of Wilson government saw a variety of social reforms, including the legalisation of homosexuality, liberalisation of divorce, abortion and contraception laws and abolishing the death penalty. Wilson lost the 1970 election to Edward Heath, but stayed on as Labour leader and regained power in two elections in 1974, first in a hung parliament in February and then a very small majority in October. This makes Wilson the most recent PM to serve two separate periods in office. WIlson held a referendum on European Community membership in 1975, and eventually resigned amid ill health in 197t6, being replaced by James Callaghan.
(edited 9 months ago)
Reply 2
It just goes to show how people on here must have been voting if Gordon Brown - one of the worst post-War PMs has made it this far. A man of unbelieveable stupidity and arrogance - although granted he is I think the only Labour PM ever not to be an Oxford man. A man who claimed to be from such a grounded, humble, working class background that his girlfriend at Edinburgh University was an actual princess. A man who thought that he had changed the economic cycle, sold low and bought high, and didn't call an election because he thought he might win. A man so entitled that he ousted the most electorally successful Labour Prime Minister ever because he thought it was his turn to be PM - and promptly lost an election that should have been unloseable.

Harold Wilson - what can you say? Another actual champagne socialist who was always more at home supping port at High Table than running the country.
(edited 9 months ago)
Original post by Trinculo
It just goes to show how people on here must have been voting if Gordon Brown - one of the worst post-War PMs has made it this far. A man of unbelieveable stupidity and arrogance - although granted he is I think the only Labour PM ever not to be an Oxford man. A man who claimed to be from such a grounded, humble, working class background that his girlfriend at Edinburgh University was an actual princess. A man who thought that he had changed the economic cycle, sold low and bought high, and didn't call an election because he thought he might win. A man so entitled that he ousted the most electorally successful Labour Prime Minister ever because he thought it was his turn to be PM - and promptly lost an election that should have been unloseable.

Harold Wilson - what can you say? Another actual champagne socialist who was always more at home supping port at High Table than running the country.


To be fair the alterative vote to Brown was May.
(edited 9 months ago)
Original post by Guru Jason
To be fair the alterative vote to Brown was May.


This right here ^^^ (wasn't a good choice some may say).
The results are in:

:king1: Harold Wilson
:king2: Gordon Brown

This means that Harold Wilson will go to the final and Gordon Brown has been eliminated.

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending