The Student Room Group

Bath, Cambridge or Imperial for Chemical Engineering?

Scroll to see replies

Original post by Bath_Student
The starting salaries are not proportionate to the work load. Cambridge and Imperial graduates ought to earn significantly more for it to be the better choice.

I rest my case.


Going to university shouldn't just be about securing the highest graduate salary. University should be about learning as much as possible, a higher workload will make you learn more.
I have this dilemma of Imperial or Cambridge thank god I found this thread.

I really need to know how 'dreadful' imperials social life is because that is the only think now stopping me from making a descision. Will Cambridge, I know it sounds absurd, have a better social life than imperial?
Original post by A*da*m
Hi, thank you so much for your reply!! I applied for MEng at all three, have you applied for university this year? If so which course? :smile:

Yeah at Cambridge I would do Natural Sciences in the first year then move over to the Chem Eng department from year two and onwards. This is probably another slight drawback for me in choosing Cambridge, whether I would enjoy taking natural sciences rather than going straight into Chem eng I'm not too sure :/ That's interesting to know, may I ask what country you are from? And had you heard of Imperial before you applied? Because I've spoken to lots of people recently and the majority hadn't even heard of Imperial before even though it has been rated as a top ten uni fairly consistently and even second in the world in one league table, so I'm hoping it has a much higher reputation with employers compared to the general public ahaha!! :smile:

Thank you that was very helpful! Yeah a lot of people have said the same thing, because I've had the opportunity of going to both Cambridge and Imperial, would I regret it if I pass up both opportunities :/


Hey again.

Yea Ive already sent all my applications for 2016 entry. Ive applied to study EEE in Imperial and Bath and Mechatronics in Manchester, Southampton and Bath again. I have recieved offers from both courses from Bath and the one from Manchester and I had my interview with Imperial last week.

I live in Hong Kong so I've only managed to visit one university (Imperial) in the UK and that was only because of a summer school. At Imperial, I got to live in the campus dorms for two weeks and (to some extent) experience life as an Imperial student. I definitely want to study in Imperial but I honestly wouldn't mind Bath if I dont get an offer.

So have you made up your mind yet or are u still thinking it through? It is a huge decision to make but im sure you'll make the right one at the end. Good luck!!
Reply 23
Original post by anonwinner
According to http://university.which.co.uk/ Chemical Engineering at Cambridge and ICL both have average graduate salaries of £31K, whereas Chemical Engineering at Bath has a starting salary of £28K.

Chemical Engineering at Cambridge has a student satisfaction score of 88%, ICL 82%, and Bath 92%. This could be due to Cambridge and ICL students having higher standards than the average Bath student.

Cambridge is by far the most competitive and gives the least offers, followed by ICL and then Bath.

Overall, Cambridge is obviously the best choice.


Hi, thank you for replying and thank you very much for looking up those numbers!! :smile: I haven't looked at the which university site for a while so I'll go and have a look again. I always think student satisfaction scores are slightly misleading because everyone has different expectations over what being satisfied is :smile:
Reply 24
Original post by Bath_Student
Heavily biased because I firmed Bath for chemical engineering starting in September. The overall satisfaction of the students (100% in the chem eng department) coupled with the disproportionately good starting salary relative to the low work load all speaks for itself


May I ask what accommodation you are in this year? And also I don't know if you have started to look at next years accommodation yet but do you know roughly how much private accommodation/housing is in Bath? The high satisfaction is very attractive indeed :smile: Would you say the work load has been fairly low for you so far then?
Original post by A*da*m
May I ask what accommodation you are in this year? And also I don't know if you have started to look at next years accommodation yet but do you know roughly how much private accommodation/housing is in Bath? The high satisfaction is very attractive indeed :smile: Would you say the work load has been fairly low for you so far then?


I firmed Bath for next September, that is, I will start the course in September! All of the accommodation options on campus are outstanding though, from what I have seen. Irrespective of where you live, Bath looks excellent!

The rest can be answered by this helpful Bath fellow: @SeanFM
Original post by anonwinner
Going to university shouldn't just be about securing the highest graduate salary. University should be about learning as much as possible, a higher workload will make you learn more.

You are contradicting yourself left and right. My premise was that Bath offered the best all-round package. Its starting salary is excellent relative to the social life / fun one can have there.

I ultimately rest my case.
Reply 27
Original post by samb1234
Some things to think about:

1. Are you 100% sure that you want to do chem eng. Cambridge would give you a year to try either engineering or nat sci, and then specialise in year 2. This could be seen as either a benefit (as worst case you don't like them that much and do chem eng anyway, or you really enjoy them and maybe change your mind) or a negative if you just want to do chem eng.

2. Regarding social life, imo a large part of it is what you make of it. Yes you would have more work to do at either cambridge or imperial compared to bath, but that doesn't necessarily mean that you can't make time to see friends, go out etc etc.

3. Specifically regarding imperial, are you ok with having to find accommodation that may well be very expensive/far away in later years?

4. Regarding Cambridge, what about the college system and formals do you think wouldn't suit you? Bear in mind that you are not by any means forced to go to formals, it is left up to you whether you want to do that kind of thing or not.

Anyway hope this helped a bit.


Thank you very much for your reply!! I am really appreciating all the help thank you so much guys!! :smile: I am fairly certain I want to do chemical engineering, I have really looked into the courses to make sure and it really does look interesting to me :smile: But i agree the chance to do natural sciences in the first year is mainly a good thing for me, perhaps one disadvantage is that I'm guessing lectures are going to be all over cambridge? Because several departments run the course so I'm guessing that will mean quite a lot of travelling throughout the day.

In terms of social life, I wasn't so worried about the work load affecting it as I am with the sort of people I would be with. Obviously being very stereotypical but in general I would have thought the social life at Bath is going to be better than at ICL/Cambridge purely because you don't need the excessively high grades to get in. So I am just a little unsure and don't know so much about the social life at ICL/Cambridge.

The cost and distance is a drawback of Imperial I must admit, however I also think that having a reasonably long commute would be good practice for later in life, and if it's done with friends I don't see it being too big a problem. At the moment it takes me a good 45 minutes to get to my sixth form so I think i would be used to it :smile:

I think I just prefer modern arrangements but I appreciate that going to formals is certainly not compulsory and I'm sure i would get used to them and would enjoy them, but they seem to be about £12-15 and two to three times a week which I can see getting very expensive over the course of the year :/

Thank you that was very helpful :smile:
Reply 28
Original post by A*da*m
Thank you very much for your reply!! I am really appreciating all the help thank you so much guys!! :smile: I am fairly certain I want to do chemical engineering, I have really looked into the courses to make sure and it really does look interesting to me :smile: But i agree the chance to do natural sciences in the first year is mainly a good thing for me, perhaps one disadvantage is that I'm guessing lectures are going to be all over cambridge? Because several departments run the course so I'm guessing that will mean quite a lot of travelling throughout the day.

In terms of social life, I wasn't so worried about the work load affecting it as I am with the sort of people I would be with. Obviously being very stereotypical but in general I would have thought the social life at Bath is going to be better than at ICL/Cambridge purely because you don't need the excessively high grades to get in. So I am just a little unsure and don't know so much about the social life at ICL/Cambridge.

The cost and distance is a drawback of Imperial I must admit, however I also think that having a reasonably long commute would be good practice for later in life, and if it's done with friends I don't see it being too big a problem. At the moment it takes me a good 45 minutes to get to my sixth form so I think i would be used to it :smile:

I think I just prefer modern arrangements but I appreciate that going to formals is certainly not compulsory and I'm sure i would get used to them and would enjoy them, but they seem to be about £12-15 and two to three times a week which I can see getting very expensive over the course of the year :/

Thank you that was very helpful :smile:


You can go to formals as often or as little as you want. Absolutely not necesary to go twice a week...

Accommodation at Cambridge is guaranteed for your degree (pretty much, depending on college), Imperial is very much not and will be siginificantly more expensive. Bath is also more expensive than Cambridge.

Oh and the average UCAS points at Bath is on a par with Cambridge & Imperial. The student academic profile is not hugely different.
(edited 8 years ago)
Original post by A*da*m
May I ask what accommodation you are in this year? And also I don't know if you have started to look at next years accommodation yet but do you know roughly how much private accommodation/housing is in Bath? The high satisfaction is very attractive indeed :smile: Would you say the work load has been fairly low for you so far then?


Hi :h:

I am a second year Mathematical Sciences student at the University of Bath.

You may find this thread useful - I've answered a few questions about Bath there.

The place I'm staying at this year is £360 pounds a month in a fairly good location (about a 10 minute walk to a bus that goes to uni, and doesn't get anywhere near as busy as the main buses, and not too far from a Lidl), and then on top of that there are utilities between the 3 of us, so all in all not too bad.

For my course at least, the workload is okay for people who just want to get by and pass/do averagely, for people that want to do well they can work quite hard and see good results.
Reply 30
Original post by jamesgall_
I have this dilemma of Imperial or Cambridge thank god I found this thread.

I really need to know how 'dreadful' imperials social life is because that is the only think now stopping me from making a descision. Will Cambridge, I know it sounds absurd, have a better social life than imperial?


Hi, is this for chemical engineering too?! I hope so because I'm so glad I'm not alone in having to decide!!!

This is also something that I need to know!! Is the social life at Imperial really as dreadful as everyone makes it out to be? If any current Imperial students could answer this question that would be so so helpful!! :smile:

From what I've found out, it does sound like Cambridge has a better social life than Imperial, but it probably varies and must be to do with luck in terms of who you end up with in your accommodation block and on your course etc.

Good luck with your decision!!
Reply 31
Original post by jaichandak
Hey again.

Yea Ive already sent all my applications for 2016 entry. Ive applied to study EEE in Imperial and Bath and Mechatronics in Manchester, Southampton and Bath again. I have recieved offers from both courses from Bath and the one from Manchester and I had my interview with Imperial last week.

I live in Hong Kong so I've only managed to visit one university (Imperial) in the UK and that was only because of a summer school. At Imperial, I got to live in the campus dorms for two weeks and (to some extent) experience life as an Imperial student. I definitely want to study in Imperial but I honestly wouldn't mind Bath if I dont get an offer.

So have you made up your mind yet or are u still thinking it through? It is a huge decision to make but im sure you'll make the right one at the end. Good luck!!


Oh okay well best of luck with hearing back from Imperial!! And congrats for your other offers so far!! :smile: Oh okay, thats such a great opportunity to have been able to live in accommodation for two weeks!! :smile:

No I'm definitely still thinking it through!! But this thread has helped me so much so thank you to everyone who is replying!! I really appreciate it :smile:

Good luck with your decisions and offers too!!
Reply 32
Original post by Bath_Student
I firmed Bath for next September, that is, I will start the course in September! All of the accommodation options on campus are outstanding though, from what I have seen. Irrespective of where you live, Bath looks excellent!

The rest can be answered by this helpful Bath fellow: @SeanFM


Oh okay sorry I'm with you now!! Yeah I am going back to look at the actual city of Bath again because I didn't see too much of it when I last went :smile: Thank you for tagging the Bath guy, that's very helpful :smile:

Thank you for all your helpful advice, much appreciated :smile:
Reply 33
@A*da*m you should also join the Cambridge offer holders thread - lots of unbiased advice in there :smile:
http://www.thestudentroom.co.uk/showthread.php?t=3815849

Are you via NatSci or Engineering?
(edited 8 years ago)
Reply 34
Original post by jneill
You can go to formals as often or as little as you want. Absolutely not necesary to go twice a week...

Accommodation at Cambridge is guaranteed for your degree (pretty much, depending on college), Imperial is very much not and will be siginificantly more expensive. Bath is also more expensive than Cambridge.

Oh and the average UCAS points at Bath is on a par with Cambridge & Imperial. The student academic profile is not hugely different.


On the nights when there are formals is there the usual catering option available too? Or would you have to self cater on formal nights if you choose not to go to them?

Yeah I've noticed the same things about the accommodation, that is one of the good things about Cambridge, that it's guaranteed for your whole course while Bath and Imperial are just first year :frown: I have heard Cambridge is much less independent however because of this? A few have told me that you are treated more like boarding school students rather than university students if someone could clear this up for me that would be hugely appreciated :smile:

Thanks for your response :smile:
Original post by Bath_Student
I rest my case.


Original post by Bath_Student
I ultimately rest my case.


Have you really rested your case this time or are you just saying that to sound dramatic?

You're coming off as pretty bitter, to be honest.
Original post by anonwinner
According to http://university.which.co.uk/ Chemical Engineering at Cambridge and ICL both have average graduate salaries of £31K, whereas Chemical Engineering at Bath has a starting salary of £28K.

Chemical Engineering at Cambridge has a student satisfaction score of 88%, ICL 82%, and Bath 92%. This could be due to Cambridge and ICL students having higher standards than the average Bath student.

Cambridge is by far the most competitive and gives the least offers, followed by ICL and then Bath.

Overall, Cambridge is obviously the best choice.


This doesn't tell us anything..

Fact is, a Bath student is smart enough to vie for the same jobs as the Camb guys. If we're talking strictly 'engineering', then the difference is meaningless as the salary you receive is based on the company/role you chose to apply to.

Pretty poor example rebuttal tbh.


Posted from TSR Mobile
Reply 37
Original post by A*da*m
On the nights when there are formals is there the usual catering option available too? Or would you have to self cater on formal nights if you choose not to go to them?

Yeah I've noticed the same things about the accommodation, that is one of the good things about Cambridge, that it's guaranteed for your whole course while Bath and Imperial are just first year :frown: I have heard Cambridge is much less independent however because of this? A few have told me that you are treated more like boarding school students rather than university students if someone could clear this up for me that would be hugely appreciated :smile:

Thanks for your response :smile:


There is a formal hall (usually an old hall), a normal hall (often in a modern dining hall), and a buttery (cafe) - all depending on your college. Which college is your offer?
Original post by jneill
There is a formal hall (usually an old hall), a normal hall (often in a modern dining hall), and a buttery (cafe) - all depending on your college. Which college is your offer?


Can you stop trying to advertise that cesspit, please?
Reply 39
Original post by A*da*m
Thank you for your reply! Yeah so many people have suggested this combination but I'm just still unsure on what the social life will be like at Cambridge!! And also the intensity of the course there, the sort of people I would meet etc. Yeah unless i choose Bath as my first choice i will definitely put it as my insurance, about Imperial when you say you have heard about it, do you know people who have gone there? Or is this from what has been said online about it?


I know someone that goes imperial for aerospace engineering and he said that and loads of people say it here as well

Quick Reply

Latest