D&D Theology's "Ask About Islam" Thread Mk. IV

The thing is, your opinion doesn't matter.

It's not an opinion if it contradicts the very definition of all-loving.

Sounds a bit of a **** if you ask me knowingly do that and knowingly knowing that religious violence because of traditional religious allegiance would ensue.

Not exactly all-loving.

Anyway, it is peoples free will which makes them do wrong, not religion itself.

It's not an opinion if it contradicts the very definition of all-loving.

Then why did god create us as sinful beings? What about people incapable of digesting moral code? It's like the game is rigged from the start for those people.

How do you know people's judgement? Stop pretending you know things that you are ignorant of.

Actually it is just an insignificant opinion that you have.

How do you know people's judgement? Stop pretending you know things that you are ignorant of.

Then why did god create us as sinful beings? What about people incapable of digesting moral code? It's like the game is rigged from the start for those people.

I dunno, perhaps years and years of dedicated neurological medical journals that explain psychopathic and sociopathic individuals with no ability to distinguish right or wrong and merely act on instincts and impulses?

I'm merely asking questions. I would think that would be able to adequately address my ignorance to elementary questions sufficiently being a follower of the universal truth.

Actually it is just an insignificant opinion that you have.

Well, that's just not true now is it? If I murdered a certain group of people and favoured another group of people, how could I say I love them all equally? It goes against the definition of 'all-loving' - that is a fact, not an opinion. And personally, in my opinion, it was quite a significant fact.

Tell me, why don't you question your own beliefs? Surely you must think "Actually, that doesn't seem quite right" or are you that tunnel-visioned and will just resort to calling my facts 'insignificant' without properly addressing them?

Could you try being patient and respectful or just avoid replying?

We may sin but that is the test - will we worship God, will we come back to Him after sinning. Just because we sin, doesn't make us inherently bad.

Those who are mentally disabled will be tested on the day of judgement rather than now

No, I said people's judgement, as in what judgement they will be handed by God. You have no idea what awaits people so going around pretending to be asking intelligent questions isn't an antidote to ignorance.

There is no concept of God loving everyone equally in Islam, especially in the manner that you put it. It's called a strawman, you create your own argument and then proceed to refute it, thereby giving yourself the delusion that you have refuted Islam. Bravo.

Surely that's god's judgement of the people? I still don't understand the flux in the moral code of the god though, can you explain to me why christians see god as more-loving in your eyes than how muslims see god?

Hmm, interesting. I was under the impression that Islam followed the Christian philosophy of god being an all-loving entity. So do you feel coerced into believing god? Because if you don't love him, then he doesn't love you and the power is in his court, isn't it? I'm not refuting Islam either, I'm just asking questions and formulating an impression on the answers you give me.

So if life is a test and people who are mentally disabled will be tested after their life then why do they need to live a life of suffering if it contributes nothing to their life after death?

The power is always in his court, unconditionally.

-No one's suffering is in vain - people are forgiven for sins through pain (but that is only one way and it is not something you should wish for or try to stay in a bad situation)
-Sometimes people etc can be a trial for others, e.g. the parent of an ill child.
However I'm not entirely sure about the ins and outs of this and they may be someone with more information on this.



God is not less loving than how He is described by Christians, he's just not ONLY the most-loving.

Just a note to everyone The way Noisy is talking does not represent the way the Prophet (peace be upon him) taught Muslims to talk to others.

Who do you think invented god though? And also, why the need to test us in the first place? I mean, we may have not even evolved into humans anyway. What happened to people in like 10000BC before monotheistic traditions?


So they have to suffer even though they did nothing wrong? That's a bit off. So what happened to humans before civilization occurred? That question has always intrigued me and do you completely eradicate the possibility that religion was constructed purely for imperial control of large territories under the premise of immorality would result in pain, anguish and torture in the 'after life'?

So if he is all-loving, why would god bestow us into a world where survival and power are incredibly more important in order to survive than moral codes? And why did he condition our instincts this way?

What a troll. If you're not here to ask sensible questions, make your way out.

Why aren't they sensible?