Mark Duggan was assassinated, claims his mother

Got a breaking news topic or want to post the most recent issues for sensible, on-topic discussion? This is the forum for you.

Announcements Posted on
Sign in to Reply
  1. Dux_Helvetica's Avatar
    • Adored and Respected Member
    • Posts: 439
    Re: Mark Duggan was assassinated, claims his mother
    Assassinated? Give me a break. Politicians are assassinated, not low-to-middle ranking drug dealers and small-time thugs. He got what was coming to him. Good bloody riddance.
  2. unclej's Avatar
    • Respected Member
    • Posts: 196
    Re: Mark Duggan was assassinated, claims his mother
    (Original post by marcusfox)
    Re the bit in bold, how have you come to this conclusion?



    I suppose the gun magically appeared at the scene somehow then.



    How have you come to the conclusion he was innocent and unarmed?
    There was a gun at the scene witch the sock it was inside did not even have his fingerprints on. My sceptesism comes from police lies. They first told us that duggan shot first. And then they took the taxi to a police station rather then leaving it for DNA testing.

    I do not trust the ipcc report and we should all be cautious when reading propaganda on the case.
  3. unclej's Avatar
    • Respected Member
    • Posts: 196
    Re: Mark Duggan was assassinated, claims his mother
    (Original post by Dux_Helvetica)
    Assassinated? Give me a break. Politicians are assassinated, not low-to-middle ranking drug dealers and small-time thugs. He got what was coming to him. Good bloody riddance.
    The world would be better off with more dealers and less politicians.
  4. marcusfox's Avatar
    • TSR Demigod
    • Location: Manchester
    • Posts: 7,160
    Re: Mark Duggan was assassinated, claims his mother
    (Original post by unclej)
    There was a gun at the scene witch the sock it was inside did not even have his fingerprints on. My sceptesism comes from police lies. They first told us that duggan shot first. And then they took the taxi to a police station rather then leaving it for DNA testing.

    I do not trust the ipcc report and we should all be cautious when reading propaganda on the case.
    I see, so the gun was not brought to the scene by Duggan?

    The alternative is that the police planted it, or that the taxi just happened to coincidentally stop where some other hoodlum had disposed of a gun, both which seem vanishingly unlikely.

    Thus to say he was innocent and unarmed is entiely disingenous.
  5. unclej's Avatar
    • Respected Member
    • Posts: 196
    Re: Mark Duggan was assassinated, claims his mother
    (Original post by marcusfox)
    I see, so the gun was not brought to the scene by Duggan?

    The alternative is that the police planted it, or that the taxi just happened to coincidentally stop where some other hoodlum had disposed of a gun, both which seem vanishingly unlikely.

    Thus to say he was innocent and unarmed is entiely disingenous.
    the police are racist liars trying to cover up their mess, by convincing people it was all for the best.

    It angers me that you've all fallen for bull-s that suggests mark duggan somehow deserved to die
  6. Dux_Helvetica's Avatar
    • Adored and Respected Member
    • Posts: 439
    Re: Mark Duggan was assassinated, claims his mother
    (Original post by unclej)
    The world would be better off with more dealers and less politicians.
    While some politicians may be rotten, are you actually serious?

    Do you know what happens to the money given to most dealers for the purchase of drugs? It goes towards funding gangs and leads to violence and turf wars in inner cities. Not to mention the addictions of people who have been ruthlessly dealt crack/heroin/other highly addictive drugs. I'm sure John Lennon would not have approved.

    You need help.
  7. marcusfox's Avatar
    • TSR Demigod
    • Location: Manchester
    • Posts: 7,160
    Re: Mark Duggan was assassinated, claims his mother
    (Original post by unclej)
    the police are racist liars trying to cover up their mess, by convincing people it was all for the best.

    It angers me that you've all fallen for bull-s that suggests mark duggan somehow deserved to die
    As to whether he was rightly shot, that will come out in the inquest of course. But I doubt very much that he would be dead today if he had chosen a different path.

    If he hadn't bought a gun, and been on his way somewhere with it, then the police would not have been tailing him, would not have needed to use armed police to stop him and he would almost certainly not have been shot.

    There is another thing to consider also. If the police had not done what they did, it is quite possible that he would have continued on his way with the weapon to shoot someone dead. Of course, we can only suggest what might have happened after the event, but those defending him have to answer some very tough questions as to the hypothesis that he was quite likely on his way to shoot someone dead with it.

    Did they deserve to die?
  8. Skip_Snip's Avatar
    • Peer Of The TSR Realm
    • Location: Ankh Morpork
    • Posts: 1,764
    • Warning points: 5
    Re: Mark Duggan was assassinated, claims his mother
    (Original post by unclej)
    x
    Can I ask why you're defending so much? Did you know him? If it's a matter of people falling for media lies, you must be angry a lot ..

    ETA: I'm not saying I think any media lies are connected with the case, I was just curious
    Last edited by Skip_Snip; 05-08-2012 at 13:19.
  9. unclej's Avatar
    • Respected Member
    • Posts: 196
    Re: Mark Duggan was assassinated, claims his mother
    (Original post by Skip_Snip)
    Can I ask why you're defending so much? Did you know him? If it's a matter of people falling for media lies, you must be angry a lot ..

    ETA: I'm not saying I think any media lies are connected with the case, I was just curious
    I probably am over defending him.
    Some of the comments on here suggesting an innocent man deserved to die have irritated me.
    And you're right. Maybe angry is the wrong word. Just media lies that seem to turn people in such a way. It irritates me
  10. marcusfox's Avatar
    • TSR Demigod
    • Location: Manchester
    • Posts: 7,160
    Re: Mark Duggan was assassinated, claims his mother
    (Original post by unclej)
    I probably am over defending him.
    Some of the comments on here suggesting an innocent man deserved to die have irritated me.
    And you're right. Maybe angry is the wrong word. Just media lies that seem to turn people in such a way. It irritates me
    Not innocent by a long shot.

    If you know something that we don't, then all well and good. But like the guy above said, you can't base your decision purely on a contrarian basis due to the fact that the media sometimes lie or that the police were somehow racist.
    Last edited by marcusfox; 05-08-2012 at 13:40.
  11. unclej's Avatar
    • Respected Member
    • Posts: 196
    Re: Mark Duggan was assassinated, claims his mother
    (Original post by marcusfox)
    As to whether he was rightly shot, that will come out in the inquest of course. But I doubt very much that he would be dead today if he had chosen a different path.

    If he hadn't bought a gun, and been on his way somewhere with it, then the police would not have been tailing him, would not have needed to use armed police to stop him and he would almost certainly not have been shot.

    There is another thing to consider also. If the police had not done what they did, it is quite possible that he would have continued on his way with the weapon to shoot someone dead. Of course, we can only suggest what might have happened after the event, but those defending him have to answer some very tough questions as to the hypothesis that he was quite likely on his way to shoot someone dead with it.

    Did they deserve to die?
    Mark duggan had never shown any sign of intending to commit a violent crime or any previous offences. It's insulting to suggest he would have gone on to kill someone. He would have more likely gone on to be a valued member of his community and a loving farther. The racist police robbed him of that chance
  12. marcusfox's Avatar
    • TSR Demigod
    • Location: Manchester
    • Posts: 7,160
    Re: Mark Duggan was assassinated, claims his mother
    (Original post by unclej)
    Mark duggan had never shown any sign of intending to commit a violent crime or any previous offences. It's insulting to suggest he would have gone on to kill someone. He would have more likely gone on to be a valued member of his community and a loving farther. The racist police robbed him of that chance
    Obtaining an illegal weapon and going off somewhere with it loaded and ready to use is an indication of precisely that.
  13. unclej's Avatar
    • Respected Member
    • Posts: 196
    Re: Mark Duggan was assassinated, claims his mother
    (Original post by Dux_Helvetica)
    While some politicians may be rotten, are you actually serious?

    Do you know what happens to the money given to most dealers for the purchase of drugs? It goes towards funding gangs and leads to violence and turf wars in inner cities. Not to mention the addictions of people who have been ruthlessly dealt crack/heroin/other highly addictive drugs. I'm sure John Lennon would not have approved.

    You need help.
    I am serious to an extent.

    I'm referring to trustworthy reliable drug dealers, not who supply hard drugs.

    The minority of drug dearlers are involved in violent gangs and obviously the world would not be better off with that kind of dealer.

    The money spent on taxes funds murdered of innocent afghani civilians and bonuses for politicians.

    I'm sure John Lennon would prefer more moral cannabis and ecstasy dealers the politicians like Kennedy .

    You need perspective
  14. Scumbaggio's Avatar
    • Exalted and Worshipped Member
    • Posts: 1,253
    Re: Mark Duggan was assassinated, claims his mother
    I think it speaks volumes about large sections of our society when they are willing to riot over a piece of filth like this.

    He probably shouldn't have been killed but in all honesty the world is not worse off without him.
  15. unclej's Avatar
    • Respected Member
    • Posts: 196
    Re: Mark Duggan was assassinated, claims his mother
    (Original post by marcusfox)
    Obtaining an illegal weapon and going off somewhere with it loaded and ready to use is an indication of precisely that.
    No it is not there is no evidence that he would of used the weapon.
  16. marcusfox's Avatar
    • TSR Demigod
    • Location: Manchester
    • Posts: 7,160
    Re: Mark Duggan was assassinated, claims his mother
    (Original post by unclej)
    No it is not there is no evidence that he would of used the weapon.
    So what?

    Carrying an illegal weapon, loaded, is evidence that you intend to use it for its intended function if if the need arises, or intent to use it at a later time. Indeed, because the penalty for doing so is so high if caught, why would you carry one if you did not intend to use it to kill or at least threaten to kill someone with it?

    No one is going to have definitive proof that he was on his way to use the weapon unless he publicly stated this intention before the fact, and unsurprisingly, it's quite common for those who do use illegal weapons in the commission of a crime to not publicly state their intentions before the event.

    In fact, they go to great lengths to disguise their intentions.

    I wonder why this could be?

    However, it is quite common for people who are in possession of illegal weapons to use those illegal weapons in the commission of crimes, and carrying such is a reliable indicator of intent.

    Given the above, we are entitled to draw inferences about the motives of people who carry illegal weapons.
    Last edited by marcusfox; 05-08-2012 at 14:22.
  17. Dux_Helvetica's Avatar
    • Adored and Respected Member
    • Posts: 439
    Re: Mark Duggan was assassinated, claims his mother
    (Original post by unclej)
    I am serious to an extent.

    I'm referring to trustworthy reliable drug dealers, not who supply hard drugs.

    The minority of drug dearlers are involved in violent gangs and obviously the world would not be better off with that kind of dealer.

    The money spent on taxes funds murdered of innocent afghani civilians and bonuses for politicians.

    I'm sure John Lennon would prefer more moral cannabis and ecstasy dealers the politicians like Kennedy .

    You need perspective
    I still think legalising soft drugs to cut out the incentive for drug dealers to start out would be a good first step.

    However, you are still not excused for defending Duggan. He was a scumbag who deserved his untimely death. It's not like he was unarmed either.
  18. RowingGoose's Avatar
    • Adored and Respected Member
    • Posts: 479
    Re: Mark Duggan was assassinated, claims his mother
    The important part of this story is that it's his mother who's said this and she's obviously biased toward the "innocence" of her son. I think we should leave the accusations and enquiry to non-biased individuals to be honest.
  19. sorafdfs's Avatar
    • Exalted and Worshipped Member
    • Posts: 902
    Re: Mark Duggan was assassinated, claims his mother
    If he was assassinated then he must've done something significant to warrant it. I think the police have bigger fish to fry than some small time gang member - like twitter trolls.
  20. unclej's Avatar
    • Respected Member
    • Posts: 196
    Re: Mark Duggan was assassinated, claims his mother
    (Original post by Dux_Helvetica)
    I still think legalising soft drugs to cut out the incentive for drug dealers to start out would be a good first step.

    However, you are still not excused for defending Duggan. He was a scumbag who deserved his untimely death. It's not like he was unarmed either.
    He did not deserve to die however many politicians do
Sign in to Reply
Share this discussion:  
Useful resources
Article updates
Moderators

We have a brilliant team of more than 60 volunteers looking after discussions on The Student Room, helping to make it a fun, safe and useful place to hang out.

Reputation gems:
The Reputation gems seen here indicate how well reputed the user is, red gem indicate negative reputation and green indicates a good rep.
Post rating score:
These scores show if a post has been positively or negatively rated by our members.