As the title says..... People will laugh at this, but for me it's Gerrad. If Liverpool win the title, it'll be because of his. I feel he's massively underrated for what he's done over the years. As a Utd fan, I say that with a bitter pill as many of you will probably say Scholes...
I think Scholes was a better player technically, but Gerrard's motivational and leadership skills make him a more complete and influential player overall.
Lampard is a perfect example of statistics not being reliable. More goals than Gerrard or Scholes, but nowhere near as good.