Reincarnation is inevitable and infinite

laws of conversation of mass =\= reincarnation

Reincarnation is so much more metaphysically deep

The universe is matter / mass, the soul is not.

The universe is matter / mass, the soul is not.

Reincarnation demands that the 'new' consciousness is the 'same' consciousness continued, and so this doesn't work.

The universe is energy. Don't you think the soul is also a form of energy? If not, what are you suggesting the soul is made of?

I'm not entirely sure reincarnation does demand that TBH but I'm open to persuasion. You could create a completely new "me" in every respect, looking exactly the same, but totally wipe my memory of previous incarnations. Is that not reincarnation?
I guess it's terminology and definitions.

I certainly believe that we are "recycled" if that's a better term. Every atom that makes us what we are has been in the universe since it began. They've simply taken a myriad of different forms over the countless trillions of years. We likely started as stars of hydrogen and helium. If my soul is something different then how am I not aware of anything beyond my current existence?

Well this is just a subjective question of whether you think consciousness needs a body to exist. I think it does. I think if you give it another 5.4 billion years in perfect conditions and started from scratch, we would gradually develop a nervous system and consciousness once again.