What clothing size on girls do you consider 'fat' ?

To be honest I wouldn't call size 14 fat in most cases, at size 14 it is totally dependant on height
My mum used to be a size 14 at 5ft 8 (on the bottom anyhow) and she has never been fat, just wide hips.

However I think when you get to size 16, the majority of people will be carrying extra weight.

Surely even if you were 6ft10 you would not wear a 16 because it would be far too short, and far too wide too if you were thin?
I still think someone who is 6ft10 and a size 16 would look relatively large in all honesty, the fact of the matter is they would have to be pretty wide for it to fit them.

Google Amazon Eve, she stands 6ft8 or 6ft9 tall and her measurements are 38-40" bust, 29-31" waist, 40-42" hips which translates to a UK size 14/16 and she weighs 14-15 stone! And she is not fat in the slightest.

Ive been reading a lot of posts on the student room about size ect, and it seems to me that if your a size 12-14 your classed as 'fat' or 'chubby' ! :/
I was just wondering at what size do you then class someone as fat?

according to her facebook page she is dress size 12-14 long
So that would surely be a 14-16 in the UK?
Ie on the small end of a 16
And she does look big - she is very muscular!

She's big in terms of height and build, i.e. tall and broad build but the dress size and weight is perfectly proportionate to her height. You can't expect a woman of 6ft8 or 6ft9 to be wearing a size 10, she'd look like a rake!

My second post was merely requesting you to state this - what you believe to be *average*. You're now holding on to this figure as sole argument. Contradicting yourself since well, I had to get that figure out of you.
I'm a Bolivian woman of average height - 4'8, wearing clothes with a uk dress size.
OR
I'm a dutch woman of average height - 5'6.5, wearing clothes with a uk dress size.

NO. I DO NOT WEAR THE SAME DRESS, IT WILL NOT FIT.
so simple, really. If you're going to make judgement, in a public place, make sure it's concrete, or else you get the size 16/18/44/whatever-you'd-like-to-believe-I-am woman telling you how specific you'd need to stop your argument from sounding stupid . Never said you were wrong. Just.PLEASE.accept.that.there.are.specific.things.to.take.into.account.to.have.an.accurate.judgement.
All I asked for, idk why it's got to be such a problem, it's simple logic.
about to *jog on*, so farewell.

Yes, you are definitely allowed your own opinion.

However, I don't think you need to be rude and aggressive when posting it, doesn't really add to your argument at all. Do you like trying to offend/ upsetting people or something?

I would take your opinion more seriously, if you construed it in a calm and constructive way, rather than saying 'Deal with it' 'Don't like that?' ect. You just sound like an immature boy that, rather than calmly stating his opinion like any adult would do, would rather resort to petty remarks for no discernible reason, than perhaps to make himself feel good.

Just my opinion.

Oh yeah I never said I expected her to be a ten!
Just said you'd have to be large (not necessarily fat) to be a 16.

This girl is a size 14/16. How on earth is she fat? Depends on height.
when I was a 10 a couple of years ago, because of my height people claimed I was underweight. My best friend is an 10 too but barely 5 feet and she's been called chubby a few times.
It's ridiculous, really.
This society is messed up, i say GOD BLESS FOOD.
eating is amazing, let's face it

Well yeah large in build, but that goes hand in hand with her tall stature. But for her height she is perfectly proportionate.

Still pretty hench though, look at those guns:

I think she looks hot