The I-SOC (Islamic Society) (X)

Assalaamu 'alaykum.

I can't see the images, the link is broken.

This is not a matter for me to say much, as it is something the manner of which cannot be elucidated. Allahu a'lam. However, I will quote from those better able to reply to questions about the deen:


The context is explained here:

Regarding this, Ibn Majah and Abu Nu’aim have narrated from Aws bin Aws Ath Thaqafi that the Prophet (SAS) said, ‘From among the most virtuous of your days is the day of Juma. So ask Allah to send blessings upon me abundantly on that day. (i.e. send ‘Salaah’ (darood) upon me abundantly on that day). For your ‘Salaah’(darood) is presented to me. (Upon this) the Sahabahs (companions) said ‘O Messenger of Allah, how will our ‘Salaah’(darood) be presented ‘to you when your body would have been decayed?’ He (the Prophet SAS) said, ‘Certainly Allah Has made it haram (unlawful) upon ‘the earth to consume the bodies of the prophets’. (Al Khasa’is Al Kubra by Allama Jalaludeen Suyuti vol.2 pg.489)

[Source: http://www.darululoomtt.net/i-would-like-to-know-the-tafseer-on-surah-3169-insha-allah/ ]

Anyhow, this is a matter the elucidation of which does not concern the vast majority of Muslims, if not all of us. Whether we study this narration or not, whether we hold one particular interpretation of it or another, it does not affect our understanding of the deen, our practice of the deen, nor is their any practical benefit to us through delving into it.

Some of us don't want to see images of decomposed bodies. Put them in spoiler tag if you must post them. Thanks

the body was decomposed though when they opened the grave it doesn't make sense

which grave was that and who opened it and why?

the body was decomposed though when they opened the grave it doesn't make sense

I can't see the images so I cannot comment.
I believe what I said in the last post was sufficient. As lakshaone has questioned, one must consider such things and any claims made by those circulating the images, whatever they may be.

Sorry idk how to spoiler what button is it

You just put tags around whatever you want to hide by using the yellow face icon with a "x" in place of its mouth. It's the one besides the youtube icon.

Also you said something about the bb font. Well, just highlight the text and click double A icon (with red cross under it). That one will remove the format for you and so you should be able to post.

Hope what I said made sense.

So if a grave of a prophet were to be dug up (god forbid), and the body was found to be decomposing, what would that mean?

Posted from TSR Mobile

So if a grave of a prophet were to be dug up (god forbid), and the body was found to be decomposing, what would that mean?

Posted from TSR Mobile

So if a grave of a prophet were to be dug up (god forbid), and the body was found to be decomposing, what would that mean?

Posted from TSR Mobile

It wouldn't though because the body would be intact

I know the rate of decomposition depends upon many factors, but bodies buried under the ground which are thousands of years old will have no sign of decomposition? (Would their bones even remain by then? )

Why would they be exempt from such a natural process?

Posted from TSR Mobile

Why would they be exempt from such a natural process?

See my previous posts.