The Student Room Group

Indices question

Why is it that when we normally square root a number the answer must have a +-, e.g. sqrt(9) = +-3, but that when there is a fractional index, the positive root is taken when square rooting, e.g. sqrt(9^3/2) = 3^3 = 27 and not +-3^3 = +-27. Sorry I'm just confused about it- thanks for any help
Reply 1
Original post by 11owolea
Why is it that when we normally square root a number the answer must have a +-, e.g. sqrt(9) = +-3, but that when there is a fractional index, the positive root is taken when square rooting, e.g. sqrt(9^3/2) = 3^3 = 27 and not +-3^3 = +-27. Sorry I'm just confused about it- thanks for any help


You don't take the negative square root. It would b wrong to say that 4=2 \surd 4 = 2 . So 4=41/2=22 \surd 4 = 4^{1/2}=2 \neq -2 .
If x2=4 x^2= 4 then sure, x=±2 x=\pm 2 but it is important to realise that you are not just simply taking the square root of both sides.
This is a misconception many people have so please feel free to ask any more questions regarding the square root of you are confused about anything.
(edited 7 years ago)
Reply 2
Original post by B_9710
You don't take the negative square root. It would b wrong to say that 4=2 \surd 4 = 2 . So 4=41/2=22 \surd 4 = 4^{1/2}=2 \neq -2 .
If x2=4 x^2= 4 then sure, x=±2 x=\pm 2 but it is important to realise that you are not just simply taking the square root of both sides.
This is a misconception many people have so please feel free to ask any more questions regarding the square root of you are confused about anything.


Sorry but I still don't understand, if the square root of 4 is +-2 then why would you sometimes take the negative value and sometimes not, and how do you know if you should?
Reply 3
Original post by 11owolea
Sorry but I still don't understand, if the square root of 4 is +-2 then why would you sometimes take the negative value and sometimes not, and how do you know if you should?


That's what I'm saying, the square root of 4 is not +-2. 4=2 \sqrt 4 =2 and 4=2 -\sqrt 4 = -2 . The square root does not return a negative value.

Quick Reply

Latest