Should the grade band of an A be shown?
Discussion for all types of Scottish exams, help on Scottish Results Day and advice on Clearing.
-
- Reputation:
- Thread Starter
- Adored and Respected Member
- Posts: 443
Should the grade band of an A be shown?Who is of the opinion that the exam certificate should show if a student has achieved an A1 at Higher or AH? By and large, scoring in the 70-100% bracket qualifies for an A, but that's a very large bracket and there's a real difference in aptitude between a student who scores 71% and a student who scores 89%. Given that a B is awarded at 60%, an A at 70% and an A1 at 85% (approx, of course), there's usually a larger difference between a B and an A than between an A2 and an A1, a situation I find very odd.
This seems especially counterproductive as university courses become more and more competitive. In England they've introduced the A* grade when typically, I believe, one needs 80% to score an A in any case. I can't think of any reason not to show the grade band a student achieves; an A2 will still be a very high grade, but an A1 will help to show which students are especially gifted in that subject. -
- Reputation:
- Exalted and Worshipped Member
Re: Should the grade band of an A be shown?We had a big discussion about this a couple of weeks ago.
http://www.thestudentroom.co.uk/show....php?t=1991315 -
- Reputation:
- Exalted and Worshipped Member
Re: Should the grade band of an A be shown?I think the bands of a subject should be shown in the near future, but at the moment they are unnecessary.(Original post by Julii92)
Who is of the opinion that the exam certificate should show if a student has achieved an A1 at Higher or AH? By and large, scoring in the 70-100% bracket qualifies for an A, but that's a very large bracket and there's a real difference in aptitude between a student who scores 71% and a student who scores 89%. Given that a B is awarded at 60%, an A at 70% and an A1 at 85% (approx, of course), there's usually a larger difference between a B and an A than between an A2 and an A1, a situation I find very odd.
This seems especially counterproductive as university courses become more and more competitive. In England they've introduced the A* grade when typically, I believe, one needs 80% to score an A in any case. I can't think of any reason not to show the grade band a student achieves; an A2 will still be a very high grade, but an A1 will help to show which students are especially gifted in that subject.
I say they begin to tell students when the new Higher Course is brought it. -
- Reputation:
- Adored and Respected Member
- Location: Scotland,United Kingdom
- Posts: 478
Re: Should the grade band of an A be shown?To be honest if I or anybody opened our results and got an A I would not mind what band it is on the other hand I know universities sometimes look at them. If I really did want to know my bands, I would ask the teacher of that subject(Original post by Julii92)
Who is of the opinion that the exam certificate should show if a student has achieved an A1 at Higher or AH? By and large, scoring in the 70-100% bracket qualifies for an A, but that's a very large bracket and there's a real difference in aptitude between a student who scores 71% and a student who scores 89%. Given that a B is awarded at 60%, an A at 70% and an A1 at 85% (approx, of course), there's usually a larger difference between a B and an A than between an A2 and an A1, a situation I find very odd.
This seems especially counterproductive as university courses become more and more competitive. In England they've introduced the A* grade when typically, I believe, one needs 80% to score an A in any case. I can't think of any reason not to show the grade band a student achieves; an A2 will still be a very high grade, but an A1 will help to show which students are especially gifted in that subject.
great idea though
-
- Reputation:
- TSR Demigod
- Location: Scotland
- Posts: 5,838
Re: Should the grade band of an A be shown?What?(Original post by tiger5000)
This better be worth it...
-
- Reputation:
- Respected Member
- Location: Fife
- Posts: 181
Re: Should the grade band of an A be shown?From a personal point of view, opening the exam results letter are seeing a couple of A2s in there would take away from the achievement of getting 5As.(Original post by Julii92)
Who is of the opinion that the exam certificate should show if a student has achieved an A1 at Higher or AH? By and large, scoring in the 70-100% bracket qualifies for an A, but that's a very large bracket and there's a real difference in aptitude between a student who scores 71% and a student who scores 89%. Given that a B is awarded at 60%, an A at 70% and an A1 at 85% (approx, of course), there's usually a larger difference between a B and an A than between an A2 and an A1, a situation I find very odd.
This seems especially counterproductive as university courses become more and more competitive. In England they've introduced the A* grade when typically, I believe, one needs 80% to score an A in any case. I can't think of any reason not to show the grade band a student achieves; an A2 will still be a very high grade, but an A1 will help to show which students are especially gifted in that subject.
In a more perspective point of view, I don't believe there is any need for showing the bands. Unless you're applying to Cambridge or Oxford or somewhere like that which may require specific bands. (In that case, the student would probably have had the initiative to ask their teachers of their bands), I don't think there's much need to show them. A pupil with paticularly strong grades is unlikely going to be rejected on the basis of their grades if they exceed the requirements, but it might be down to the personal statement. When the competition increases for the course, the universities simply increase the grade requirements. -
- Reputation:
- Banned
- Location: Edinburgh
- Posts: 899
Re: Should the grade band of an A be shown?I completely agree with that. Although 5A's is a significant achievement, unless I achieved 5 A1's I would feel as if my grades were second best..(Original post by Chrisruptor)
From a personal point of view, opening the exam results letter are seeing a couple of A2s in there would take away from the achievement of getting 5As. -
- Reputation:
- TSR Demigod
- Location: Scotland
- Posts: 5,838
Re: Should the grade band of an A be shown?I think that's fairly inappropriate...(Original post by SneakyDoug)
My english teacher told us who got A1's and whoever did got a round of applause from the class haha. -
- Reputation:
- Adored and Respected Member
- Posts: 472
Re: Should the grade band of an A be shown?It wasn't serious at all - it was a bit of a piss take. I think i put over the wrong idea...(Original post by TheUnbeliever)
I think that's fairly inappropriate... -
- Reputation:
- Respected Member
- Location: Fife
- Posts: 181
Re: Should the grade band of an A be shown?How did that happen? Don't you start a new timetable with new subjects after study leave?(Original post by SneakyDoug)
My english teacher told us who got A1's and whoever did got a round of applause from the class haha. -
- Reputation:
- Adored and Respected Member
- Posts: 472
Re: Should the grade band of an A be shown?This was at the beginning of this year when everyone had their results and we also did it for the prelim.(Original post by Chrisruptor)
How did that happen? Don't you start a new timetable with new subjects after study leave?
great idea though
