The Student Room Group

How come Asian students achieve A/A* at GCSE Language?

Just for the record, I have absolutely nothing against chinese people. I even admire them for their outstanding attitude towards learning and everything and find it really inspiring that many chinese students, who arrive to England can barely speak english at first, and still manage to achieve an A/A* at GCSE English? What's their secret?

Why are there so many ****ing negs?
(edited 11 years ago)

Scroll to see replies

You do really Asains do not just include Chinese people...
Reply 2
Yes, I am aware, but I'm referring to all Asian students in general, and that includes Chinese people as well :smile:
Erm I believe its called "Hard Work".
Chinese emigrants to the UK and other developed countries are usually the top few % of IQ from their home country.
Its because to come and learn here they need to learn english abd as they do theat it gives them an adavantage as they already know what it takes to learn a new language!
Reply 6
They are seem to be brilliant because india is located in asia.
Reply 7
Maybe they "barely speak english" to people because they get made fun of their accents, when in fact their written english is perfect.
Original post by PinkFire
Maybe they "barely speak english" to people because they get made fun of their accents, when in fact their written english is perfect.


Is this not due to foreign language teaching in China? I've heard they teach English from quite a young age.

Not that it has made any difference at all with the Chinese students in my lectures, who can't speak English with the requisite degree of fluency necessary to get by, IMO.

Universities just cram as many foreign students in for the £££. It's a shame really.
Original post by Memphis_93
Just for the record, I have absolutely nothing against chinese people. I even admire them for their outstanding attitude towards learning and everything and find it really inspiring that many chinese students, who arrive to England can barely speak english at first, and still manage to achieve an A/A* at GCSE English? What's their secret?


Either they've been learning English for a while but don't feel comfortable speaking it but can write it, or the GCSE English paper is a whole bag of easy.
Original post by Memphis_93
Just for the record, I have absolutely nothing against chinese people. I even admire them for their outstanding attitude towards learning and everything and find it really inspiring that many chinese students, who arrive to England can barely speak english at first, and still manage to achieve an A/A* at GCSE English? What's their secret?


Not *all* Asians get A*/A in GCSE languages..
I know a few who have tutors but barely even passed the exam :/
I know in China and SE Asian countries they start learning English in their equivalent of year one in primary school. And most who immigrate to the UK are from middle and upper class families and were probably taught in better schools and had plenty of private tuition, the Chinese will spend a fortune on tuition! I think it's pretty sad that most of us born in the UK can't speak other languages like people in other countries can speak English. I suppose it's our own fault.


This was posted from The Student Room's iPhone/iPad App
Reply 12
Original post by ilickbatteries
Is this not due to foreign language teaching in China? I've heard they teach English from quite a young age.

Not that it has made any difference at all with the Chinese students in my lectures, who can't speak English with the requisite degree of fluency necessary to get by, IMO.

Universities just cram as many foreign students in for the £££. It's a shame really.


No it's actually quite good. Whatever they pay helps to keep fees for home students down. Secondly, from what I've seen (I'm Chinese, however I'm a third gen) most of them tend to take Maths/Science/A&F courses as these subjects require little use of the English language. So it's a win win for everyone. If they're struggling, they usually work out between them what they need to do. The downside to this is that they usually don't socialise as much, and this is mainly because they're shy. I feel for them, I'd feel exactly the same if someone stuck me in a Spanish university where most of the students spoke Spanish and I was there with a couple of Brits who could speak English - I'd just chat to them :yup:
Original post by JamesYoung
No it's actually quite good. Whatever they pay helps to keep fees for home students down. Secondly, from what I've seen (I'm Chinese, however I'm a third gen) most of them tend to take Maths/Science/A&F courses as these subjects require little use of the English language. So it's a win win for everyone. If they're struggling, they usually work out between them what they need to do. The downside to this is that they usually don't socialise as much, and this is mainly because they're shy. I feel for them, I'd feel exactly the same if someone stuck me in a Spanish university where most of the students spoke Spanish and I was there with a couple of Brits who could speak English - I'd just chat to them :yup:


I think its a shame. Firstly, its a waste of their own potential if they come over and can't do well because of the language barrier. I mean, if your English is poor, why study in English? Why not study in Mandarin?

Why come over here if the grasp on the language is poor. I mean, I wouldn't go to university in Paris or Madrid - I can't speak French or Spanish, and I certainly wouldn't want to study in a language I only half know.

I know we need their big money to fund our own courses but I'd much rather we weren't reliant on foreign students and could provide more places for our own students. I know someone will see this as racism, its TSR, everything is racist, but I'm not going against someone on the basis of their race, more their citizenship. The girls in my lectures just sit around and play on their iPads or PDAs. They don't integrate, they just sit and talk amongst themselves and don't contribute to the classes.

I know that is probably because they feel isolated but really they should be studying in their home country if they feel isolated and out of place here.
Reply 14
Original post by ilickbatteries
I think its a shame. Firstly, its a waste of their own potential if they come over and can't do well because of the language barrier. I mean, if your English is poor, why study in English? Why not study in Mandarin?

Why come over here if the grasp on the language is poor. I mean, I wouldn't go to university in Paris or Madrid - I can't speak French or Spanish, and I certainly wouldn't want to study in a language I only half know.

I know we need their big money to fund our own courses but I'd much rather we weren't reliant on foreign students and could provide more places for our own students. I know someone will see this as racism, its TSR, everything is racist, but I'm not going against someone on the basis of their race, more their citizenship. The girls in my lectures just sit around and play on their iPads or PDAs. They don't integrate, they just sit and talk amongst themselves and don't contribute to the classes.

I know that is probably because they feel isolated but really they should be studying in their home country if they feel isolated and out of place here.


I can see this really; a mate of mine got sent to Paris to study Engineering, and he wonders now, once he got back home, would he even use the language he has to study there (they don't use English). I wonder whether it's worth the loneliness and isolation, as well as the struggle to adapt to the country.

Regarding the Chinese girls, what's the point coming all the way from China but can't speak a word of English?
Reply 15
Original post by ilickbatteries
Is this not due to foreign language teaching in China? I've heard they teach English from quite a young age.

Not that it has made any difference at all with the Chinese students in my lectures, who can't speak English with the requisite degree of fluency necessary to get by, IMO.

Universities just cram as many foreign students in for the £££. It's a shame really.


That is true. Plus the English they're taught at a young age makes them learn the proper sentence structure, standard grammar, nouns, verbs, etc. with little exposure to the colloquialism that students in "native" English countries grow up with.

I'm with you there. A lot of universities accept students for the money and the chance to increase the 'international-ness" of student demographics. It looks good on the books. Visa restrictions are getting tighter and tighter to ensure that students have at least the basic knowledge, but I agree that learning a course in a language you barely know is not much of a use.

Original post by kka25
I can see this really; a mate of mine got sent to Paris to study Engineering, and he wonders now, once he got back home, would he even use the language he has to study there (they don't use English). I wonder whether it's worth the loneliness and isolation, as well as the struggle to adapt to the country.

Regarding the Chinese girls, what's the point coming all the way from China but can't speak a word of English?


Parental influence maybe? Degrees from UK and the US are seen as prestigious over there and parents often want the best for their children. It could also be an attempt to encourage their kids to "improve their English", but this backfires as they end up banding with others from their country and speaking their own language as they can't properly communicate with other peers to be accepted by other social groups. :frown:
Original post by Memphis_93
Just for the record, I have absolutely nothing against chinese people. I even admire them for their outstanding attitude towards learning and everything and find it really inspiring that many chinese students, who arrive to England can barely speak english at first, and still manage to achieve an A/A* at GCSE English? What's their secret?


They work their butt off! And also coming from an asian family myself I can understand the emphasis that is placed on education and hard work in Asian housholds, so this motivates people to work even harder :smile:
Reply 17
Original post by ilickbatteries
I think its a shame. Firstly, its a waste of their own potential if they come over and can't do well because of the language barrier. I mean, if your English is poor, why study in English? Why not study in Mandarin?

Why come over here if the grasp on the language is poor. I mean, I wouldn't go to university in Paris or Madrid - I can't speak French or Spanish, and I certainly wouldn't want to study in a language I only half know.

I know we need their big money to fund our own courses but I'd much rather we weren't reliant on foreign students and could provide more places for our own students. I know someone will see this as racism, its TSR, everything is racist, but I'm not going against someone on the basis of their race, more their citizenship. The girls in my lectures just sit around and play on their iPads or PDAs. They don't integrate, they just sit and talk amongst themselves and don't contribute to the classes.

I know that is probably because they feel isolated but really they should be studying in their home country if they feel isolated and out of place here.


Well the Chinese I know from friends and family tend to do very well. They may not understand every word, but when they group together, they manage to work things out between them.

Lastly you need to remember how prestigious a UK degree is seen in the East. This is the most important factor for coming to study in the UK. They're very highly valued - a good Top 25 degree will earn you a nice salary when you go back home. UK universities are world leaders for undergraduate education. You say you wouldn't go to France or Spain to study, but if you could understand French or Spanish to a reasonable level and Britain had much weaker educational institutions, I'm sure you'd jump at the chance to have a better education (or a more prestigious brand on your CV and thus a greater salary).

You have a lot of Chinese students on your Sociology course? I find this rare, as I said, they tend to take things in Maths/Science where they can get a book, study it hard and get good grades without having great English. A Sociology degree would hold little value back home. Whereas if they did Accounting&Finance/Maths/Economics/Management/Sciences/IT, they'll earn big salaries in China/HK and in the Tiger economies if they so wished.

As for the part about becoming less reliant. That would be perfectly possible. Just expect more of the rich kids filling university places. The bulk of the population won't vote to pay higher taxes to fund university educations for students. As for funding more places for our students...I don't see how this comes into the equation. There are hundreds of thousands of places for UK applicants. If you get AAB, places are unlimited, I believe this goes to ABB for the next cohort. So if you achieve well, there aren't any barriers.
(edited 11 years ago)
Reply 18
Original post by PinkFire



Parental influence maybe? Degrees from UK and the US are seen as prestigious over there and parents often want the best for their children. It could also be an attempt to encourage their kids to "improve their English", but this backfires as they end up banding with others from their country and speaking their own language as they can't properly communicate with other peers to be accepted by other social groups. :frown:


:frown:
Original post by JamesYoung
Well the Chinese I know from friends and family tend to do very well. They may not understand every word, but when they group together, they manage to work things out between them.

Lastly you need to remember how prestigious a UK degree is seen in the East. This is the most important factor for coming to study in the UK. They're very highly valued - a good Top 25 degree will earn you a nice salary when you go back home. UK universities are world leaders for undergraduate education. You say you wouldn't go to France or Spain to study, but if you could understand French or Spanish to a reasonable level and Britain had much weaker educational institutions, I'm sure you'd jump at the chance to have a better education (or a more prestigious brand on your CV and thus a greater salary).

You have a lot of Chinese students on your Sociology course? I find this rare, as I said, they tend to take things in Maths/Science where they can get a book, study it hard and get good grades without having great English. A Sociology degree would hold little value back home. Whereas if they did Accounting&Finance/Maths/Economics/Management/Sciences/IT, they'll earn big salaries in China/HK and in the Tiger economies if they so wished.

As for the part about becoming less reliant. That would perfectly possible. Just expect more of the rich kids filling university places. The bulk of the population won't vote to pay higher taxes to fund university educations for students. As for funding more places for our students...I don't see how this comes into the equation. There are hundreds of thousands of places for UK applicants. If you get AAB, places are unlimited, I believe this goes to ABB for the next cohort. So if you achieve well, there aren't any barriers.


Yeah, there are quite a few. I think they've been enticed more by the name of the university rather than by what subject they're doing. Half of my degree is education and of about fourty students I'd say there are about seven or eight Chinese girls who are beyond useless. I think I've heard them say only one or two sentences in class discussions and only when they've been asked by the lecturer.

Becoming less reliant on foreign money is a pipe dream yes, but I'd rather places were given to students holding British citizenship. If Asia wants well educated students, why farm them out to us? Why don't they improve their own infrastructure?

As for the relevance of the subject - according to what I've been told by university academics - the subject is merely a university level education and something to prove they can work in English, which is good enough to get them a job back home.

Quick Reply

Latest