1) how was your experience overall?
My experience has been a good one. I find that some departments have dealt better with covid than others, but I don't study a physics degree so I'm not sure what that's been like. Because of it being a 4 year degree, only the third and fourth year count towards your classification. This is good if you want to relax and have a bit more fun in your first year (probably shouldn't in your second lol) but also shouldn't really impact you if you want to study hard. I only started approaching my lecturers for help this year, and I was surprised at how willingly they gave it. I had felt a bit of a disconnect between myself and them, but knew that other people were far more integrated within this learning community than I was. Ultimately it's on you to start that relationship.
2) how are the personal tutors? are they helpful? and can you genuinely discuss all aspects of your academic progress with them, getting thorough advice when needed?
This varies. I had an absolutely terrible tutor to begin with and went a while not really understanding how everyone else around me loved their tutors and talked to them loads and got all this advice from them. However, I asked my departments student support if I could change tutors and I had within that day and I now have a much better experience with a tutor that is really willing to help me out and get the stuff done for me that needs doing.
3) how are student support services? Student support would include career advisors, study abroad support, and then personal tutors/tutorials, etc.
See above for personal tutors. Careers advice is pretty good - they have so many internship programmes at the uni each summer that you can apply to in your second and third year and I know some people that have done that and have really enjoyed them. Study abroad support I'm not totally convinced by personally, but I didn't go on a year abroad so maybe other people who actually did go had a different experience. I've used the counselling service twice and though loads of people complain about it and the waiting times, the waiting times are significantly better than the NHS. I've had a fairly good experience with it. Ultimately, if you seek out the support, it is there and the people working with them are clearly trying their hardest. But you won't automatically be noticed to be struggling or in need of something, you do have to go and ask.
4) Particularly for physics students, how is the course structure/organization?
Don't study physics sorry 😢
Lastly, even if you do not go/went to the uni, are there any aspects of Edinburgh that one should know before coming?
I really love Edinburgh and am planning to stay here for the rest of my life. I have literally nothing bad to say about Edinburgh, it's a great place to live.