The Student Room Group

Oxford Maths and Philosophy Students and Applicants

Scroll to see replies

Reply 60
Original post by Billy Pilgrim
Hey, I was wondering if any current students could tell me what they think of the course - specifically, does cutting out the 'applied' stuff limit you as a mathematician, or do you feel that a solid grounding in pure maths is enough? I love philosophy, but I'd rather keep my options open as much as possible in terms of graduate studies etc, and it seems like philosophy is something you can go into at a later stage whereas maths is not.

Muchas Gracias

Short reply since it's May Morning and I'm about to get very drunk and not sleep all night, but it's my understanding that the areas you could go into in maths for graduate study are very much informed by what you'd do at the end of a degree course (particularly since I'd expect most such people would have done an MMath or equivalent). The MathPhil course does let you get into applied content, though it requires savvy option-choosing early on, so it doesn't limit what fields you can get into per se. The lack of a general background in applied stuff might make it harder to move fields if you weren't set on it from second year or so, though.
Reply 61
I did Maths and Philosophy, and I'm now doing a PhD in pure maths, and I know several other people who've done the same. As long as you've done maths in the areas relevant to what you'll be doing your PhD in (so probably harder for applied PhDs) that's enough. You're not penalised at all for doing maths as a joint degree.
Reply 62
Hey guys
Noticed there wasn't much about this course on here and just wanted to know what everyone was doing for A levels etc and reading wise? Where's everyone thinking of applying to and all that and if there's any similar courses i might not have heard of! Good luck with applications everyone!
Reply 63
soo to get this started im thinking of Kings College London, Oxford (looong shot!) and Glasgow. Taking maths, further, physics and hist of art. Got 5 As at AS but tbh dont know much philosophy yet. :s
Reply 64
Original post by jones17
Hey guys
Noticed there wasn't much about this course on here and just wanted to know what everyone was doing for A levels etc and reading wise? Where's everyone thinking of applying to and all that and if there's any similar courses i might not have heard of! Good luck with applications everyone!


Original post by Carrotcake18
You can relate your A-Level subjects to philosophy. e.g. since you are studying History of Art you may want to expand on that by reading about Aesthetics.

PM me if you have any specific questions :smile:

Generally decent advice, but, um, what do you do? I'm not sure I'd presume to offer to answer people's questions about a course by PM if I wasn't actually studying the course. :confused:

I'm also not sure I'd advise someone considering maths and philosophy to look much at aesthetics: most British departments will be heavily analytical, and aesthetics (though I'm sure very interesting; I know nothing about it) will be very different to the philosophy most students will have to cover, as well as potentially being quite inaccessible to beginning readers.
Is this degree accredited by the Institute of Mathematics? Would it be possible to study a PhD in Mathematics if one were to study this degree? Would I be restricted in any way, mathematically, as to what I could specialise in?

Thanks.
Reply 66
Original post by Acroamathematics
Is this degree accredited by the Institute of Mathematics? Would it be possible to study a PhD in Mathematics if one were to study this degree? Would I be restricted in any way, mathematically, as to what I could specialise in?

Thanks.

I couldn't find Oxford on the list on their website, but, like, I couldn't find Cambridge, Warwick or UCL on their either, so I think it's just not something a lot of places bother with. The list does include various joint honours courses though, so if anyone gives a crap about accreditation the MathPhil course should be fine.

If you're keen on doing applied stuff, it might involve doing a bunch of non-examinable work in first year and applying to do applied rather than pure options later, but it's pretty possible. See replies to similar questions above.
Original post by dbmag9
I couldn't find Oxford on the list on their website, but, like, I couldn't find Cambridge, Warwick or UCL on their either, so I think it's just not something a lot of places bother with. The list does include various joint honours courses though, so if anyone gives a crap about accreditation the MathPhil course should be fine.

If you're keen on doing applied stuff, it might involve doing a bunch of non-examinable work in first year and applying to do applied rather than pure options later, but it's pretty possible. See replies to similar questions above.



Sorry for the tardy response, I've been hibernating. :tongue:


Thanks, I've a fervent interest in Mathematics, and have realized that I've actually been asking philosophical questions rather than scientific catechisms with premises about logic, proofs and metaphysics, so Math and Phil seems the most appropriate course for me. Got to love a bit of Frege :cool:.
I've no idea which course to choose.

I find Mathematics/Theoretical Physics/Philosophy exhilarating but I honestly can't decide. I've looked over Number Theory/Topology/Calculus and I find that enjoyable, and I've read a few books from Plato/Nietzsche/Berkeley/Spinoza and Russell/Frege, and I find all of it sublime, but I've no idea which course to choose. Does anyone have any experience with these courses/any emboldening anecdotes. Cheers. :smile:
Reply 69
Original post by Acroamathematics
I've no idea which course to choose.

I find Mathematics/Theoretical Physics/Philosophy exhilarating but I honestly can't decide. I've looked over Number Theory/Topology/Calculus and I find that enjoyable, and I've read a few books from Plato/Nietzsche/Berkeley/Spinoza and Russell/Frege, and I find all of it sublime, but I've no idea which course to choose. Does anyone have any experience with these courses/any emboldening anecdotes. Cheers. :smile:


You have 8 months to decide, give yourself some more of that time. A few things to think about:

1) If you didn't do a course, would you be able to learn about it in your free time?
2) In terms of maths, are you interested (broadly) in pure or applied? If the former Maths & Philosophy people do plenty of it, but if you like applied (which theoretical physics suggests) then maybe it'd be good to do more by taking maths.
3) How specialised is your interest? If you like one particular aspect of physics then relating to 1), that's more simple to learn out of interest.
4) Looking up full details of the course would be a good idea.

The main thing I'd say, though, is relax. Keep trying to help yourself decide by reading around all of the subjects to try and help make a decision but don't rush it :smile:
How difficult is it to get a place for Mathematics (Post-graduate) research once you've completed this degree? I'm not entirely sure how many people actually go onto PhD's when they've completed their MathPhil, so it'd alleviate my disinclination if someone could inform me. Cheers. :smile:
Reply 71
Original post by Acroamathematics
How difficult is it to get a place for Mathematics (Post-graduate) research once you've completed this degree? I'm not entirely sure how many people actually go onto PhD's when they've completed their MathPhil, so it'd alleviate my disinclination if someone could inform me. Cheers. :smile:


The course is explicitly designed to allow its graduates to proceed to further study, so providing you've done appropriate backing in whatever field you're going to go into I shouldn't imagine it's any more difficult than for those who've done a straight maths degree. I don't know much in the way of specifics but there certainly are MathPhils currently moving on to higher study.
Original post by dbmag9
The course is explicitly designed to allow its graduates to proceed to further study, so providing you've done appropriate backing in whatever field you're going to go into I shouldn't imagine it's any more difficult than for those who've done a straight maths degree. I don't know much in the way of specifics but there certainly are MathPhils currently moving on to higher study.


I was hoping to specialize in a topic dedicated to number theory / complex analysis which is covered fully in the syllabus.


Thank you, that is reassuring. :smile:
Reply 73
Does anyone know the modules one can choose from for this course for philosophy (and/or maths)? Is there a fair amount of history of philosophy, including post-Kantian (Hegel, Nietzsche, Heidegger) modules to choose from in this specific course?

I very much enjoy this combination, and am studying at first year now, considering changing unis. My worry is, however, that due to the combination and it being Oxford, the modules taken are almost only analytic recent philosophy, but my preferences lie much more within the history of philosophy, including post-Kantian continental philosophy.

If anyone has any info about this, I'd be very grateful!
Original post by Byrks
Does anyone know the modules one can choose from for this course for philosophy (and/or maths)? Is there a fair amount of history of philosophy, including post-Kantian (Hegel, Nietzsche, Heidegger) modules to choose from in this specific course?

I very much enjoy this combination, and am studying at first year now, considering changing unis. My worry is, however, that due to the combination and it being Oxford, the modules taken are almost only analytic recent philosophy, but my preferences lie much more within the history of philosophy, including post-Kantian continental philosophy.

If anyone has any info about this, I'd be very grateful!
Here's a list of courses:

101 History of Philosophy from Descartes to Kant

102 Knowledge and Reality

103 Ethics

104 Philosophy of Mind

105 Philosophy of Science and Philosophy of Psychology and Neuroscience

106 Philosophy of Science and Social Science

107 Philosophy of Religion

108 The Philosophy of Logic and Language

109 Aesthetics

110 Medieval Philosophy: Aquinas

111 Medieval Philosophy: Duns Scotus and Ockham

112 The Philosophy of Kant

113 Post-Kantian Philosophy

114 Theory of Politics

115 Plato, Republic

116 Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics

117 Frege, Russell, and Wittgenstein

118 The Later Philosophy of Wittgenstein

120 Intermediate Philosophy of Physics

122 Philosophy of Mathematics

124 Philosophy of Science

125 Philosophy of Cognitive Science

199 Thesis

Reply 75
Original post by Byrks
Does anyone know the modules one can choose from for this course for philosophy (and/or maths)? Is there a fair amount of history of philosophy, including post-Kantian (Hegel, Nietzsche, Heidegger) modules to choose from in this specific course?

I very much enjoy this combination, and am studying at first year now, considering changing unis. My worry is, however, that due to the combination and it being Oxford, the modules taken are almost only analytic recent philosophy, but my preferences lie much more within the history of philosophy, including post-Kantian continental philosophy.

If anyone has any info about this, I'd be very grateful!

fluteflute has posted the list of options; basically everything continental fits into Post-Kantian (113), for which you normally study two philosophers from a small range. Everything else is pretty analytic.
Reply 76
Original post by Byrks

I very much enjoy this combination, and am studying at first year now, considering changing unis.!


Oxford don't accept transfers though. How would you change to Oxford?
Reply 77
Original post by fluteflute
Here's a list of courses:


Original post by dbmag9
fluteflute has posted the list of options; basically everything continental fits into Post-Kantian (113), for which you normally study two philosophers from a small range. Everything else is pretty analytic.


Thanks to both of you, that was pretty helpful. It looks like Oxford is not for me, then, with only one History of Philosophy module and the Post-Kantian module! Oh well, it was worth checking out.

Original post by RichE
Oxford don't accept transfers though. How would you change to Oxford?


Oh, I was talking about possibly applying to start from the first year, although I was just toying with the idea. I'd be incredibly surprised if they accepted transfers! Haha.
Reply 78
Hello. I'm about to enter Year 12 and having started looking around at degree choices really like the look of this course. It very much seems like a 'best of both worlds' sort of fit. However, my sixth form do not offer Further Maths at A-Level (although they do say I may be able to do the AS in Year 13). I was wondering if anyone could give me some insight as to how much of a disadvantage this could prove to be when applying - did you or anyone you know get onto the course without FM/just AS-Level FM? Or should I accept I'll probably have to look elsewhere? Thanks.
Reply 79
Original post by Cynical.
Hello. I'm about to enter Year 12 and having started looking around at degree choices really like the look of this course. It very much seems like a 'best of both worlds' sort of fit. However, my sixth form do not offer Further Maths at A-Level (although they do say I may be able to do the AS in Year 13). I was wondering if anyone could give me some insight as to how much of a disadvantage this could prove to be when applying - did you or anyone you know get onto the course without FM/just AS-Level FM? Or should I accept I'll probably have to look elsewhere? Thanks.

Pretty certain you can apply without Further Maths; check the website for the formal requirements. I got in with IB Higher Maths, which doesn't cover various things the A-level course does; any difficulties you would find would be lack of familiarity with things that get taught pretty quickly, nothing serious.

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending