The Student Room Group

Is there any point in going to university anymore?

Scroll to see replies

Original post by digitalfever

My cousin is currently in a diploma level business program (2 years) and will then be starting a trade program (1 year) so he can start his own business in the trades, He'll probably make as a plumber around 100k a year. That's good money for only 3 years of schooling.


not to piss on your cousins trade, but no plumber will make 100K a year - Doctors barely make that by the high points of their career
Original post by Haraway
Aberdeen is one of these freaky places because of oil you can either get a HNC in administration/hr then start at the bottom as an office clerk or as a tea girl in an oil company at teh age of 16-17 and be earning 30-40k by the time people have graduated.

I could be a cleaner in a oil company and earn 30k a year.

FML


Ooh really? I have some admin qualifications - maybe I should move to Aberdeen to get a job there? :teeth:
Reply 82
Original post by Loveisonthedole
To the OP -

I study English. University is basically like a book club. They recommend some good texts (which you probably would have found on your own anyway) and they recommend a tonne of terrible texts. Twice a week you have lectures that are the equivalent to reading Wikipedia articles on the author/work (so much so, that you never go). Once a week you meet up in a group and 'discuss' the text which usually involves the tutor asking very basic questions and no one answering. If you have a good tutor, they will actually be interesting and go entirely off topic for an hour or two and every has a big chat with a cup of coffee. If there is a foreign student in your class, everyone will just ask them what they think about the UK and ask them questions about where they're from (usually germany).

Assessment wise.. you pick between 4 and 6 books out of 12-18 and do a couple of essays before christmas and a couple of exams at the end of january. Repeat for the next semester.

The only thing I've actually been taught is Theory (Post-Struturalism, Postcolonialism, Psychoanalysis, Marxism, Feminism, Eco-Criticism, Cultural Materialism).

Is that worth 9 grand a year? I wouldn't go to study English in 2012.

Anyone who wants to learn English to degree standard. Just buy Peter Barry - Beginning Theory and Stephen Fry - The Ode Less Travelled.


Is that any good? I like Fry. I just read the Fry Chronicles - he's certainly stretching out is autobiography.......canny bastard!
Reply 83
Yes, it's called an education. A university education delivers you out of ignorance. A university education isn't meant to be a vocational school. You shouldn't look to a Bachelor's degree as your ticket to lifelong employment. A Bachelor's degree is meant to enlighten and educate. Professional and Graduate Schools are where you go afterward in order to specialise and pursue a career. Studying on one of the arts and humaities courses like History or English Literature does not train you directly for a specific career; rather, they teach you how to think. They enlighten you and open your mind to the world. They help you see things you never saw before. Attending law school, business school or medical school after graduating with a Bachelor's degree will train you for a career, but don't expect a university to be a trade school.
Original post by Howard
Is that any good? I like Fry. I just read the Fry Chronicles - he's certainly stretching out is autobiography.......canny bastard!


Yeah it's really good, I've only been able to dip into it since last christmas but am taking it home with me this christmas to read it properly.

It's a history of poetry but also a guidebook to writing it. Explains how poetry is made etc and gives advice on how to write.

I didn't understand the structure and form of poetry really until I read it.

It's not an autobiography or fiction.
Reply 85
Original post by Loveisonthedole
Yeah it's really good, I've only been able to dip into it since last christmas but am taking it home with me this christmas to read it properly.

It's a history of poetry but also a guidebook to writing it. Explains how poetry is made etc and gives advice on how to write.

I didn't understand the structure and form of poetry really until I read it.

It's not an autobiography or fiction.


I'll pick myself up a copy then. I like books like that. Not that I am an English student or anything.
Reply 86
Original post by Timon
Yes, it's called an education. A university education delivers you out of ignorance. A university education isn't meant to be a vocational school. You shouldn't look to a Bachelor's degree as your ticket to lifelong employment. A Bachelor's degree is meant to enlighten and educate. Professional and Graduate Schools are where you go afterward in order to specialise and pursue a career. Studying on one of the arts and humaities courses like History or English Literature does not train you directly for a specific career; rather, they teach you how to think. They enlighten you and open your mind to the world. They help you see things you never saw before. Attending law school, business school or medical school after graduating with a Bachelor's degree will train you for a career, but don't expect a university to be a trade school.


Fair points, up to a point.

A lack of a university education doesn't condemn someone to a life of ignorance.
Original post by Timon
Yes, it's called an education. A university education delivers you out of ignorance.


Not so sure about that. Depends on the student.

Speaking of university more generally, everybody seems to think that University is the only way to get educated. It's the only way to get a peice of paper that says you are - and it's a very particular way, nearly all unis offer the same route with no deviation (exams and essays) and usually the same texts etc.

People should bare in mind that universities are also extremely liberal. Not a necessarily bad thing, but on an English course studying almost exclusively black and female authors does get tiresome - especially when you finally get round to a good white male writer (a la hemingway, kerouac...) and all the discussion centres around is how their mysogynistic racists. Too often these courses focus on substandard ethnic or female authors just so you can sit through a diatribe of postcolonial analysis. Rubbish.
Reply 88
Original post by Howard
Fair points, up to a point.

A lack of a university education doesn't condemn someone to a life of ignorance.


No, but not attending university denies you a great opportunity to expand your horizons and learn much about the world we live in that life experiences alone cannot teach you.
Reply 89
Original post by Loveisonthedole
Not so sure about that. Depends on the student.

Speaking of university more generally, everybody seems to think that University is the only way to get educated. It's the only way to get a peice of paper that says you are - and it's a very particular way, nearly all unis offer the same route with no deviation (exams and essays) and usually the same texts etc.

People should bare in mind that universities are also extremely liberal. Not a necessarily bad thing, but on an English course studying almost exclusively black and female authors does get tiresome - especially when you finally get round to a good white male writer (a la hemingway, kerouac...) and all the discussion centres around is how their mysogynistic racists. Too often these courses focus on substandard ethnic or female authors just so you can sit through a diatribe of postcolonial analysis. Rubbish.


Believe it or not, even a Lefty like me actually agrees with you to a point. That's why you, as a consumer, should shop around different universities for an Englsih course to your likeing. Check out online the key lecturers in the English department of the various universities that interest you and find out what the main focus of their reseach is, and you#ll most likely find what modules will be offered at that institution.
Reply 90
Original post by Timon
No, but not attending university denies you a great opportunity to expand your horizons and learn much about the world we live in that life experiences alone cannot teach you.


Perhaps. But there's more than one way to skin a cat.

Up until the recent education boom triggered by Major's government university was attended by far fewer people. Go back to the 70's and maybe only 5% went. Are people truly more enlightened today than they were then?

Is university really able to expand horizons more than life experience? I'm not really sold on that idea. Personally, I think my life experiences have done far more to expand my horizons and shape the way I think than the three years I spent at uni.
Original post by Howard
From a "life experience" point of view? Well, if you think that living on Pot Noodles, not getting up before noon, and getting pissed in the SU bar is "life experience" then maybe.


Original post by takethyfacehence
How about people who go to uni, get up every morning and do something with their time, getting involved in extra-curriculars, networking, working hard (eating what they want - fairly sure what one eats has nothing to do with anyone else, unless it results in serious malnutrition/it's to do with the career e.g. the person is an athlete)..?


...
Reply 92
Original post by Liissiie
Personally, the main reason I want to go to uni is to learn more about a subject I like.


I completely agree, and I also think that the person who thumbed you down is worse than Hitler. HUZZAH!
Original post by Pwn4g3_P13
not to piss on your cousins trade, but no plumber will make 100K a year - Doctors barely make that by the high points of their career


He most likely will since he's going to own his own company. However, I'm talking about Canada and doctors in Canada are paid well over 100k. Soo...
Original post by r.hackett
I completely agree, and I also think that the person who thumbed you down is worse than Hitler. HUZZAH!


You'd be bitter too if you didn't get into art school.
Original post by Bill_Gates
Yep this is where everyone comes to talk bull****. Sure in 5 years when the cyclical nature of our economy changes and everyones back in the moneys and you'll be wondering damn.


This. Very easy to dismiss degrees in recessions, but the "best" jobs go to graduates, and will do so even more once things pick up again.

On the other hand 9k a year is a lot of money...
Original post by Timon
Believe it or not, even a Lefty like me actually agrees with you to a point. That's why you, as a consumer, should shop around different universities for an Englsih course to your likeing. Check out online the key lecturers in the English department of the various universities that interest you and find out what the main focus of their reseach is, and you#ll most likely find what modules will be offered at that institution.


I think I've learnt a few critical thinking skills, or rather been able to devote time to developing them, but I don't think the lecturers have contributed to my education much at all. I've taught myself. That's why when I picked a university, I picked the one with the environment that would be most conducive to learning: a chilled out seaside town. Obviously this only applies to the arts. Maths, Sciences.. there's a lot you really need to learn there.

But you're completely right about picking university as a consumer.
Original post by Howard


From a "life experience" point of view? Well, if you think that living on Pot Noodles, not getting up before noon, and getting pissed in the SU bar is "life experience" then maybe.


If that's all one was hoping to get out of university then one probably shouldn't be going no matter what the fee level.
Reply 98
People who are saying the fees are too high if you don't get a well-paid job do realise that you only pay it back if you earn over a certain amount, and even may not pay it all back, right?
From an education point of view, if you are doing a science/maths type subject then no because you can learn these subjects yourself from books and online resources far more efficiently and completely than you would at uni.

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending