The Student Room Group

Resolution 2012/04 - Concerning the Situation in North Korea

A new resolution submitted by the representative for Japan and seconded by the representatives for the USA and the Republic of Korea.

Resolution

Committee: Security Council
Submitted By: Japan; the United States of America; the Republic of Korea

Concerned that North Korea's proposed satellite launch is, in fact, a cover for a long-range missile test;
Noting that other states are of the same opinion, including South Korea, Russia and the USA, as well as North Korea's ally China;
Alarmed by North Korea's repeated refusal to begin talks about the circumstances of the launch in a diplomatic manner, despite international opinion being weighed against them;
Remembering that the food parcels from the US have ceased due to the situation;
Worried that these tests and North Korea's refusals to co-operate are a threat to stability.

1. Condemns North Korea's ignorance of the international community's opinion on the matter;
2. Calls that the proposed operation to be ceased immediately;
3. Summons North Korea to discuss the matter with the international community openly, with particular dialogue being given to Japan, South Korea, Russia, China and the US;
4. Reminding North Korea that food parcels from the US have stopped due to the situation, and that it is in its people's interests to comply with these terms;
5. Agrees to re-assess the situation after said talks have finished.


DebatingGreg
QFA

Scroll to see replies

The United States has stopped sending food aid to the majority of people on the basis of the minority action? Utterly ridiculous and we'll buffer this shortage instead. Once again, ridiculous. Russia won't support this motion.
(edited 12 years ago)
Japan, naturally, supports the resolution. North Korea have proven themselves to be, among other things, impossible to trust, inconsistent and have been known to possess a general ignorance against the will of the rest of the rest of the world, as well as diplomacy and stability. These traits were highlighted in this particular case, where North Korea still continues with these tests, despite doubts over the launch's legitimacy amidst fears of it being a long-range missile test, and many, including its closest neighbours, expressing said doubts and that it could be a threat to stability and peace. Even China, which has supported North Korea in the past, shares these views.

Therefore, we have drawn up this resolution in a last attempt to offer North Korea a chance to explain itself by pursuing diplomatic dialogue and that the proposed operation be ceased immediately. Others may have been a lot harsher with them, but Japan retains the sentiment that it should offer one last chance to North Korea. If the resolution passes, and North Korea ignores it, Japan cannot promise that other states will not act more aggressively against them and their actions.

Japan, once again, reminds North Korea that it is in the interests of its people to cease the operation, for the food packages from the US have stopped due to it. Japan hopes that North Korea acts with the will of its people instead of its arrogance.

Japan has enjoyed working with its neighbour South Korea and ally the USA on this resolution.
(edited 12 years ago)
Though Finland was not in favour of the the US's stopping of food packages to the North Korean people, it notes that North Korea is showing ignorance to peace and stability by continuing with the operation without diplomatic and proper dialogue. Therefore, Finland supports the resolution, and hopes that North Korea acts accordingly for the good of both stability and its people.
Reply 4
Latvia loses hope with North Korea. Latvia supports this resolution and hopes that North Korea opens its inward nation to international investment and I can assure the North Korean representative that any measures from its Government to open its country would be met with universal support from the Baltic Partnership and the wider international community.
Reply 5
The Democratic People's Republic of Korea obviously rejects this motion, and warns other countries about involvement. We shall continue our projects with or without the support of the UN.
Once again, North Korea is showing ignorance to the will of the world. Indeed, they state that they shall continue their "projects with or without the support of the UN". They ignore what the world says, they ignore what their people need instead focusing on weapons and corruption, and now wish to ignore the UN for its own pursuits. It even goes so far as to warn members in their involvement. Japan, quite frankly, finds their position laughable, and certainly not one to be trusted.
(edited 12 years ago)
Reply 7
Tuvalu supports this resolution.

The Holy See, while an observer, would like to remind the international community of the plight of the thousands of Christians imprisoned in North Korean labour camps on the basis of their beliefs.
The Republic of Korea supports this resolution. Action needs to be taken against the aggressive military regime of the DPRK, this goes some way to addressing the situation.
UNIDO supports this resolution.
Zimbabwe fully rejects this resolution. Zimbabwe shares the views of Russia that the stoppage of food aid in Zimbabwe will only prove to cause unecessary destress to many of the great nations population. Zimbabwe would like to remind the panel that it fully supports the Democratic People's Republic of Korea and has full confidence in the supreme leader Kim Jong-un.
Original post by Foghorn Leghorn
Zimbabwe fully rejects this resolution. Zimbabwe shares the views of Russia that the stoppage of food aid in Zimbabwe will only prove to cause unecessary destress to many of the great nations population. Zimbabwe would like to remind the panel that it fully supports the Democratic People's Republic of Korea and has full confidence in the supreme leader Kim Jong-un.


Japan would like to remind the representative for Zimbabwe that the Resolution is not endorsing said stopping of food aid, but instead noting that it exists.
Original post by Stricof
The United States has stopped sending food aid to the majority of people on the basis of the minority action? Utterly ridiculous and we'll buffer this shortage instead. Once again, ridiculous. Russia won't support this motion.


As said to Zimbabwe, this resolution does not support the stopping of food aid. Instead, it simply notes that it has stopped. Japan hopes that Russia's view on the Resolution was not dictated by this one factor which bears no relevance to the legitimacy of the resolution itself, and hopes that it shall not direct such complaints against the resolution.
(edited 12 years ago)
Lithuania fully supports this resolution and urges DPRK's new leader Kim Jong-un to take heed of the views expressed by UN memebers. Lithuania believes that DPRK forces are causing uncessesary suffering and this must come to a halt immediately. Lithuania also condemns Russia's repeated unwillingness to recognise the dire situation in DPRK, and condemns Russia's rhetoric it constantly expresses in support of nations with woful human rights records. Lithuania believes Russia must stop acting in an archaic Soviet manner and recognise that Russia too has a role to play in reforming belligerent and oppressive regimes.
Original post by DebatingGreg
Japan would like to remind the representative for Zimbabwe that the Resolution is not endorsing said stopping of food aid, but instead noting that it exists.


Zimbabwe would like to express it's appologies for the confusion, however still rejects any resolution and expresses it's full support of the Workers' Party of Korea and the supreme leader Kim Jong-un.
Original post by Foghorn Leghorn
Lithuania fully supports this resolution and urges DPRK's new leader Kim Jong-un to take heed of the views expressed by UN memebers. Lithuania believes that DPRK forces are causing uncessesary suffering and this must come to a halt immediately. Lithuania also condemns Russia's repeated unwillingness to recognise the dire situation in DPRK, and condemns Russia's rhetoric it constantly expresses in support of nations with woful human rights records. Lithuania believes Russia must stop acting in an archaic Soviet manner and recognise that Russia too has a role to play in reforming belligerent and oppressive regimes.


Switzerland fully echoes Lithuania's statement and supports this motion, however, we our concerned of course that food aid has stopped because of this situation. We hope that the DPRK will cease their activities for the good of the international community and for their own people.
Poland fully supports this resolution and condemns North Korea for putting its military prestige above the well-being of its people. People are starving to death in North Korea and yet the country still refuses to stop its nuclear weapons programme and engage with the international community in order to receive international aid. Poland views this as simply disgraceful. Poland is also disappointed at Russia's continual support of countries such as North Korea and Syria which are denying their people basic human rights and hopes Russia reviews its support of these nations.
Reply 17
Turkey would also like to suggest greater incentive rather than just punishment however all in all good resolution if complied with however is another matter.
Cyprus will offer its support out of preservation of links with Japan and South Korea. However, it notes the importance of diplomacy and advises caution in interfering with other countries affairs, despite being of the opinion that said satellite launch is not in international interest.
Reply 19
The Democratic People's Republic of Korea asks USA to resume food aid, but we shall not stop these tests. It is perfectly reasonable for us to want to join the 'space race', and we are not testing missiles or nuclear weapons.

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending