I think you need to take advice from here with a pinch of salt. You shouldn't decide one way or the other simply because someone here had some good points. At the end of the day it is your decision and you need to work it out for yourself. If it was me I would visit all the sites, ask the current medical students (not one or two) about their site and ultimately try to imagine if you would fit in rather than if the school would fit you.
I had my HYMS interview at Hull and I though the site was pile of *****. It was my first interview and took it as a practice for my Manchester and St. George's. I didn't care whether I get in or not because after the tour I knew that I wouldn't be happy studying at Hull or York (especially Hull).
P.S. Please don't double post.