The Student Room Group

Is wearing make-up a 'betrayal'? One woman's transformation sparks online backlash

Scroll to see replies

Reply 40
Queue that Asian guy who sued his wife for deceiving him and giving him an ugly baby.
Reply 41
Original post by danny111
Queue that Asian guy who sued his wife for deceiving him and giving him an ugly baby.


Ha! When I saw the thread title that's what I thought of too.
A betrayal? I don't understand this, guys drool over celebs and girls in porn etc who have plastic surgery, airbrushing etc but say that normal women wearing make up is a betrayal?


Posted from TSR Mobile
Make up is a way of expressing your self


Posted from TSR Mobile
Meh women can do whatever the fuarrrrk they wanna do! Ain't no problem with me. I'm not a fan of women caked in litres of make-up, but it's their face at the end of the day. :dontknow:
Reply 45
Original post by inthedark1
I don't wear makeup either, I will use that olay 'mousturisor with a hint of foundation' stuff and sometimes a bit of eyeliner/blusher but I dont see the point in attempting to change what I look like. I know what you mean about beuaty being presentstion. Years ago I used to feel down because people thought I was ugly. Back at college they did this facial attractiveness topic in class for a biology sexual selection topic. We had a teacher who wasn't all there lol and the whole class decided to anonymously rate each others looks out of 10 (we wrote the number on a piece of paper for each person then folded it up). We all agreed as obviously we were curious, I wish Id have opted out lol! The teacher then wrote the numbers on the board at the side of everyones name. I got mainly 4's and a few 5's..the lowest in the class. I didnt give anyone below a 6 as I felt it was too harsh lol! So I felt really down about it for ages college wasn't my favourite time!

Thinking back on it though I don't let it bother me because I didnt present myself well at all. I had a curly hairstyle comming just below my eyes which looked like a lads crop cut. I wore a baseball cap, no makeup, tracksuit top, jeans and trainers and had acne lol. Plus I didnt really speak to the others I only had one friend. Im not saying Id be good looking or anything if I had dressed well but I cant see how Id have been much worse than the others if Id have had some sense of style/identity rather than looking like a tramp. Obviously facial features/genetics play a big part in looking good but so does presentation. At the end of the day though makeup/style and all that are so temporary/superficial they can be removed in an instant thats why Ive never took much pride in clothes/makeup and I cant be bothered with jewellry at all. Yet oddly enough I like to be healthy/physically fit and keep in shape and can't understand people who don't. It seems most people are the opposite and place more value on clothes/style.

Appearance is generally a massive thing when you are young though (to most people) for a lot its as though its the end of the world if they are not attractive. I don't know why though because like you said a lot is down to presentation. As you get older and get to know more people you can put it into perspective more. You realise that everyone is insecure about something but they just look how they look and thats it lol. When we get a lot older and start getting health/family problems we will probably realise that our health is the main concern.


Well said, all of it. LOL. Aww. I'm sure I'd get a similar result too. But if you wore makeup, I bet you'd automatically go up a few points (just because people are conditioned to think 'makeup=beautiful/sophisticated' unless it's really that poorly applied. I bet if they did further analysis, made up ppl on average would be considered more attractive than non made up classmates. (dont quote me on that lol) I feel like people are generally more feminine often 'look'more attractive even if they aren't; a boyish attitude can make you seem less feminine despite your face. When I'm around really girly friends etc. I think I talk higher pitched, smile more femininely, and even walk different vs. when I'm around my brother. All those little mannerisms really make or break your femininity despite a full face of makeup etc. Also, I agree. Every time I try to care about my appearance, I always end up caring about health instead. I'm like "how can clothes ever make me more happy?? I just feel upset that it costs me so much money and if I look bad in it I feel worse. Not to mention everybody has a better fahsion sense than me, so why try? there's no inherent joy in clothes..but there is an inherent joy in running etc. and I suppose looking good (but good clothes/makeup and looking good are not the same thing) After realizing that I don't have the best health, being beautiful definitely took a back seat. Health, not beauty,d efinitely determines if you will be satisfied with your life.
Reply 46
Original post by hollywoodbudgie
'We all know that armpit hair, hairy legs, arm hair, monobrows, facial hair etc can do to transform a woman from ugly to average. Do you believe that that hair removal is a 'betrayal' because it hides a woman's true self?'

:rolleyes:

If you're going to be campaigning for women to be 'all natural' then you better get used to hairy legs mate because the preceptions of what 'natural beauty' is so distorted that I doubt most would even be attracted to it anymore.


No. Removing hair is taking care of yourself. Make-up is adding something ontop to hide. Totally different things.
Original post by CodeJack
No. Removing hair is taking care of yourself. Make-up is adding something ontop to hide. Totally different things.


Why is removing hair taking care of yourself?

Does having hair on your arms make you unhygenic suddenly? :confused:
Reply 48
Original post by hollywoodbudgie
Why is removing hair taking care of yourself?

Does having hair on your arms make you unhygenic suddenly? :confused:


Nah I didn't mean it in the unhygenic way, I just meant it's taking something away rather than adding something else ontop.
Original post by CodeJack
Nah I didn't mean it in the unhygenic way, I just meant it's taking something away rather than adding something else ontop.


Fondation takes away the appareance spots

Your argument is really rubbish mate, give up.
Reply 50
Original post by hollywoodbudgie
Fondation takes away the appareance spots

Your argument is really rubbish mate, give up.


Oh dear, you're really going to twist my words like that?...

PHYSICALLY taking away, not taking away the appearance.
Original post by Bassetts
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-2454391/Is-wearing-make-betrayal-One-womans-dramatic-transformation-sparks-online-backlash.html

We all know the power makeup can do to transform a woman's face from ugly or average to good looking. Do you believe these images demonstrate that makeup is a 'betrayal' because it hides a woman's true self?



Original post by IlexBlue
So many guys (to save twenty or so posts - not all guys) patronisingly say "I prefer women without make-up" or "I want a naturally beautiful women who doesn't need make-up" or even worse, "women don't need make-up. :smile:"

Then they go onto cite some celebrities/ people they believe are beautiful and don't need to wear any, who we should all aspire to be like, and give some examples.

Only 99.9% of the time they're pictures of women who have perfected the application of "flawless-looking natural make-up" that doesn't make it glaringly obvious they're actually wearing any. If you try typing in "[name + no make-up]" you'll see posts of guys waxing lyrical about how great ___ looks with no make-up on... only girls will spot straight away they have quite a lot of concealer and some eyeliner going on. :giggle:

What guys mean to say is "I prefer women with make-up to make them flawless but not enough to notice they're wearing any."


Come on Bassets honey. Not all of us cake it on like pornstars (whoch you dudes seem to like so much) to the point we look like someone else.

Drawing your eyebrows on and contouring are 100 miles away from simply evening the skin tone or covering scars with a bit of foundation. No one cares if men have a few lines, spots/scars/pubic hair/are a bit stocky. Men do care about things like penis size but women don't actually make a big deal about it. However, EVERYONE cares if women has one blemish. We pander to the crazy unrealistic standards you guys set. We struggle to behave correctly in a society that scrutinises women in the media and throws out the contradictory madonna/whore ideal. I've learned to accept there's no way in hell women will ever get anything right or stop being subjects of deep criticism whatever we do; the recent role reversal with men feeling victimised and under pressure to look right/act right is only a teeny tiny taster of what women have been subjected to since the dawn of time.

Not saying that it's nice. For that reason, feminism shouldn't be about making guys feel like crap. But how else can they empathise? It's sweet when a guy says 'stop caring about wearing makeup or your weight or what you wear' but it's naive. If we did that we'd be shot down like hell.

Seriously, I dislike blatant fakery (fake hair like extensions, acrylic nails, fake tan etc) but nothing wrong with working on what is already there. Subtly.

Please please please, there is a reason most women are crazy. It's because we're totally obsessed with trying to do everything to make men like us (or not hurl abuse at us) as well as being regulated and attackedby other women. Stop worrying about what we're doing wrong or right. Worry about finding a woman first, then you can talk to her about how she does her makeup x
(edited 10 years ago)
Reply 52
People should just be how ever they are comfortable for themselves, not for anyone else, and stfu.
Original post by CodeJack
Oh dear, you're really going to twist my words like that?...

PHYSICALLY taking away, not taking away the appearance.


Adding or removing makes little difference.

I don't see how spending hours yanking out hair from your skin is more natural than rubbing some pink vaseline onto your lips :confused:
Reply 54
Original post by hollywoodbudgie
Adding or removing makes little difference.

I don't see how spending hours yanking out hair from your skin is more natural than rubbing some pink vaseline onto your lips :confused:


Not talking about Vaseline either. The thread is talking about how makeup like foundation and that changes your appearance a lot. Vaseline doesn't exactly chance your looks.
Yay, let's insult and put down women who wear make up thanks to pressures from the media in the first place...

We can't ****ing win.

Original post by CodeJack
Nah I didn't mean it in the unhygenic way, I just meant it's taking something away rather than adding something else ontop.


Are tattoos a betrayal? Are piercings a betrayal? Is nail varnish a betrayal?

...

Sit down.
(edited 10 years ago)
Reply 56
Original post by ironandwine
Yay, let's insult and put down women who wear make up thanks to pressures from the media in the first place...

We can't ****ing win.



Are tattoos a betrayal? Are piercings a betrayal? Is nail varnish a betrayal?

...

Sit down.


1) I never said it was a betrayal, just because that's the thread title.

2) Those things are totally different from makeup and have totally different uses/effects. I never once mentioned them.

3) You shouldn't use 'Sit down' like you just burnt me in an argument or something.

4) So many people in this thread, twisting my words and not even seeing the other peoples points properly.

5) nobodies insulting or putting down women, it's a debate. Not everyone is attacking you for having a different view.
(edited 10 years ago)
I can't wear too much makeup. It makes me look horrible. I look good with just lipstick and MAYBE either blusher or eyeliner, but not both. It's either I'm bad at applying it or my face just doesn't suit it.

If it made me look better I'd wear it more often, I don't think it's deceitful at all.
Original post by CodeJack
Not talking about Vaseline either. The thread is talking about how makeup like foundation and that changes your appearance a lot. Vaseline doesn't exactly chance your looks.




Megan Fox as a girl with her monobrow. Do you think she would be regarded as super hot with a monobrow now?
Hair removal massively impacts your apparance as well and you're sounding foolish in saying otherwise.

A girl with a moustache, hairy armpits and hairy legs coming up to you would freak you out far more than how that girl looked in the before picture at the start of this thread, so stop trying to pretend otherwise!
Reply 59
I don't think it's a betrayal or whatever else, but I consciously don't wear makeup much as an effort to be more comfortable in my own skin. I don't want to get to a stage where I feel I have to wear it.

Quick Reply

Latest