The Student Room Group

STUDENTS FROM UK who go ABROAD to study medicine

Scroll to see replies

Original post by maria-z
I am studying abroad and I think it was one of the best decisions I ever made. 40% of the UK's doctors are hired from abroad.

I was born and bred in the UK and so are a few of my classmates. We all intend to return to the UK and practice. Would you not prefer a larger percentage of doctors that know and understand british culture.

When doing summer placements in the UK, our knowledge is on par with UK medical school students. Our study is more self directed however the level of detail to which we learn is equal. A lot of us are taking USMLE exams as well which are internationally renowned.

So when you ask why do we go abroad?

Yes we have the finances- we don't take student loans therefore we have no debt at the end. Often the studies are much cheaper. I pay 4000 euros a year tuition fees, and 300 euros a month for an apartment which looks like something out the movies.

Yes we love travelling- living on mainland Europe means the opportunity to catch a train to a nearby country is very realistic and for less than half the cost.

And most importantly we go because of the sheer lack of medical student places available in UK.

More than 80% of UK medical applicants are rejected. We just choose another method :biggrin:

Posted from TSR Mobile

So I'm assuming you were rejected from the UK Universities and resorted to studying medicine abroad?
People shouldn't be so rudely dismissive. Are you going to openly display the same attitude when your SHO or reg tells you they trained in Bulgaria?
Original post by maria-z
I am studying abroad and I think it was one of the best decisions I ever made. 40% of the UK's doctors are hired from abroad.

I was born and bred in the UK and so are a few of my classmates. We all intend to return to the UK and practice. Would you not prefer a larger percentage of doctors that know and understand british culture.

When doing summer placements in the UK, our knowledge is on par with UK medical school students. Our study is more self directed however the level of detail to which we learn is equal. A lot of us are taking USMLE exams as well which are internationally renowned.

So when you ask why do we go abroad?

Yes we have the finances- we don't take student loans therefore we have no debt at the end. Often the studies are much cheaper. I pay 4000 euros a year tuition fees, and 300 euros a month for an apartment which looks like something out the movies.

Yes we love travelling- living on mainland Europe means the opportunity to catch a train to a nearby country is very realistic and for less than half the cost.

And most importantly we go because of the sheer lack of medical student places available in UK.

More than 80% of UK medical applicants are rejected. We just choose another method :biggrin:

Posted from TSR Mobile


Thats complete rubbish, which would lead me to believe most of what you've said is also made up.
60% of medical/dental applications are rejected, yes.

Of course you're going to try and come back to the UK to work, although, it may not happen anymore - as already dentistry graduates from the UK are given priority over EU graduates for VT places, this will probably be the same in medicine.
No, your education is not as good as UK medical students(or, to be frank, you're not as academically able as UK students) as EU trained medical students over and over again perform MUCH worse on the MRCP exams.

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2596701/
Reply 23
Yeh, I was rejected, and now I am studying medicine and taking the USMLE exams that will let me practice in the US, Canada and Arab Emirates as well as the UK and any other country in Europe. On top of that I am learning an extra language and getting life experience many UK students miss out on. So worked out quite well? :biggrin:
Original post by WackyJun
People shouldn't be so rudely dismissive. Are you going to openly display the same attitude when your SHO or reg tells you they trained in Bulgaria?


No.
But quite frankly, it annoys me that this is possible. Its ridiculous that people who get often VERY low A level grades(in comparison to uk med/dental students) are able to just go abroad and come back and it makes no difference.
Its completely unfair on students who work incredibly hard to get their grades, do well on the UKCAT, work experience, volunteering EVEN take gap years to reapply, just to have these rich kids come back with exactly the same benefits as UK grads - fortunately, this is no longer the case with dentistry.
Original post by maria-z
Yeh, I was rejected, and now I am studying medicine and taking the USMLE exams that will let me practice in the US, Canada and Arab Emirates as well as the UK and any other country in Europe. On top of that I am learning an extra language and getting life experience many UK students miss out on. So worked out quite well? :biggrin:


Good luck getting a good residency in the US with a degree from a second world country - it wont happen.
May aswel have a DO degree.
Reply 26
Haha you obviously don't know the system, it depends on the USMLE score and btw people who graduated from this 'second world university' are currently practicing in UK, US, Germany and Dubai. So stop being so immature. Your attitude shows me that you would be a terrible doctor.

Posted from TSR Mobile
Original post by maria-z
Haha you obviously don't know the system, it depends on the USMLE score and btw people who graduated from this 'second world university' are currently practicing in UK, US, Germany and Dubai. So stop being so immature. Your attitude shows me that you would be a terrible doctor.

Posted from TSR Mobile


Yes, they are currently practicing. However, this is slowly dwindling away - as i've said, dentistry graduates from the EU are now second priority after UK graduates for training places, it is not long until the same is for medicine graduates.
And again, time and time again EU grads do worse on the MRCP exams as shown by my link.
Im not being immature, in any way shape or form.
Original post by alevelzzz
No.
But quite frankly, it annoys me that this is possible. Its ridiculous that people who get often VERY low A level grades(in comparison to uk med/dental students) are able to just go abroad and come back and it makes no difference.
Its completely unfair on students who work incredibly hard to get their grades, do well on the UKCAT, work experience, volunteering EVEN take gap years to reapply, just to have these rich kids come back with exactly the same benefits as UK grads - fortunately, this is no longer the case with dentistry.


True. But don't be rude to individuals. Hate the system, not the pawns.
Original post by WackyJun
True. But don't be rude to individuals. Hate the system, not the pawns.


Im not being rude.
I don't blame them tbh, I mean, why not?
The system is broken.
Original post by alevelzzz
Im not being rude.
I don't blame them tbh, I mean, why not?
The system is broken.

Even if it's broken, it doesn't mean other people should abuse it.
Reply 31
Well as I said currently 40 percent of uk's medical workforce is hired from overseas. So the actual problem is in the UK's educational system. We just think 'out of the box'. Don't be a sour puss and be happy there will be more UK doctors in our workforce :biggrin:

Posted from TSR Mobile
Reply 32
Original post by alevelzzz
Thats complete rubbish, which would lead me to believe most of what you've said is also made up.
60% of medical/dental applications are rejected, yes.

Of course you're going to try and come back to the UK to work, although, it may not happen anymore - as already dentistry graduates from the UK are given priority over EU graduates for VT places, this will probably be the same in medicine.
No, your education is not as good as UK medical students(or, to be frank, you're not as academically able as UK students) as EU trained medical students over and over again perform MUCH worse on the MRCP exams.

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2596701/

Have you even read that link properly?
Original post by alevelzzz
People who don't get AAA for medicine and dentistry often go for pharmacy, optometry, biomed etc.
Some of them have the money to study at bulgaria, romania etc etc.

Although, the majority will say 'I wanted to go abroad' etc etc, if you ask them what their a level grades are - you'll be shocked.

1)medicine/dentistry
2)pharmacy,optom,biomed - abroad medicine/dentistry

This is the case for 90% of the students.


Sorry, just telling it like it is


A lot go abroad because they just didn't make the grades however many top students are also forced to go abroad because there just aren't enough places.

Affordability is another reason. The EU is far cheaper particularly when it comes to GEM. Despite some people making the cut academically there's no way they could fund GEM in the UK.


Posted from TSR Mobile
Reply 34
Original post by alevelzzz
No.
But quite frankly, it annoys me that this is possible. Its ridiculous that people who get often VERY low A level grades(in comparison to uk med/dental students) are able to just go abroad and come back and it makes no difference.
Its completely unfair on students who work incredibly hard to get their grades, do well on the UKCAT, work experience, volunteering EVEN take gap years to reapply, just to have these rich kids come back with exactly the same benefits as UK grads - fortunately, this is no longer the case with dentistry.


Very interesting points :thumbsup:

because this is no longer the case with dentisry don't you think in a few years the same thing will happen with medicine i.e. the people who qualify abroad won't just be able to return and have the same benefits as UK grads?
Reply 35
Original post by maria-z
Yeh, I was rejected, and now I am studying medicine and taking the USMLE exams that will let me practice in the US, Canada and Arab Emirates as well as the UK and any other country in Europe. On top of that I am learning an extra language and getting life experience many UK students miss out on. So worked out quite well? :biggrin:


If a student qualifies in the UK and decided to go abroad to Europe for whatever reasons would they be in the same position as you i.e. they would have to take the USMLE exams in order to work as a medic in Europe?
Original post by ChocInABox
Very interesting points :thumbsup:

because this is no longer the case with dentisry don't you think in a few years the same thing will happen with medicine i.e. the people who qualify abroad won't just be able to return and have the same benefits as UK grads?


If at ANY medical grads from the UK cannot get a foundation place, then yes, this will be implemented.

Theres already a slight saturation in medicine and dentistry. Fully qualified specialists cannot find consultant positions apart from in very rural areas, waiting 5-10 years AFTER full qualification aka ~40 years old.
Getting foundation places in London hospitals is pretty much impossible unless you're a VERY good candidate as London is the number 1 choice for a large number of applicants.
Reply 37
Original post by miscounted_time
A lot go abroad because they just didn't make the grades however many top students are also forced to go abroad because there just aren't enough places.

Affordability is another reason. The EU is far cheaper particularly when it comes to GEM. Despite some people making the cut academically there's no way they could fund GEM in the UK.


Posted from TSR Mobile


When yoy say the EU is far cheaper particularly when it coems to GEM you mean it is cheaper for these students to do a first degree in the UK then go abroad to do graduate entry medicine rather than go abroad straight away as soon as they finish A level to do medicine...why is that though :confused: or have I misunderstood.
Reply 38
Original post by alevelzzz
If at ANY medical grads from the UK cannot get a foundation place, then yes, this will be implemented.

Theres already a slight saturation in medicine and dentistry. Fully qualified specialists cannot find consultant positions apart from in very rural areas, waiting 5-10 years AFTER full qualification aka ~40 years old.
Getting foundation places in London hospitals is pretty much impossible unless you're a VERY good candidate as London is the number 1 choice for a large number of applicants.


that's insane! so they just continue for another 10 years as a specialist despite being able to become a consultant. Is it such a struggle then because there are so many
people in this area therefore not many consultant jobs and so thats why the specialisit struggle to find consultant positions
Reply 39
Original post by ChocInABox
If a student qualifies in the UK and decided to go abroad to Europe for whatever reasons would they be in the same position as you i.e. they would have to take the USMLE exams in order to work as a medic in Europe?

You don't need the USMLE within Europe at all. The poster is just saying their course equips them to take the exam (known to be very difficult due to the greater depth US med schools still go into with the sciencey stuff, for example) so it can't be that sub-par. A UK grad wanting to work in another EU country would, I assume, need to demonstrate a certain level of language ability.

Original post by alevelzzz
If at ANY medical grads from the UK cannot get a foundation place, then yes, this will be implemented.

What is 'this' specifically? What measures were put in place for dentistry? I'm not sure how restricting EU access to FY1 is going to help, given that the majority of EU med courses are the same six year kind with the final year counting as equivalent to FY1. Maybe lots of them apply for FY1 anyway, who knows. Any data on that?

Theres already a slight saturation in medicine and dentistry. Fully qualified specialists cannot find consultant positions apart from in very rural areas, waiting 5-10 years AFTER full qualification aka ~40 years old.

This is because of the pyramid structure and nothing to do with EU competition.

Getting foundation places in London hospitals is pretty much impossible unless you're a VERY good candidate as London is the number 1 choice for a large number of applicants.

London is popular and competitive. Again, how big an impact are UK citizen, EU med school 'returners' having on this? How big an impact are applicants from EU med schools having on this full stop? Any data?

Original post by ChocInABox
When yoy say the EU is far cheaper particularly when it coems to GEM you mean it is cheaper for these students to do a first degree in the UK then go abroad to do graduate entry medicine rather than go abroad straight away as soon as they finish A level to do medicine...why is that though :confused: or have I misunderstood.

I think the poster must have meant that people who have done a degree already and who consider applying and paying for the regular 5/6-year courses instead of the more competitive GEM find that doing this will be cheaper in other EU countries. GEM itself will still be more affordable due to Student Finance help (unless the person happens to speak another language to a high enough level and chooses a place with no or low tuition fees - then it might start to rival the GEM option).

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending