The Student Room Group

I don't know where I sit with Syria

Scroll to see replies

Original post by Aj12
Syria is fast becoming a hotbed of Islamic extremism and another country al Qaeda is starting to infiltrate. Fighters from Iraq Afghanistan Somalia and Yemen are entering the country to fight. If the West does nothing Syria will merely become like Yemen or Somalia or Afghanistan another country that al Qaeda can train and gather terrorists. People who say this does not affect us may feel differently when in a few years time terrorist attacks are being planned and launched from another failed state. The Middle East is one of the most strategically important areas of the world, everything that happens there affects us.


We've seen how good we are at taking care of places like Iraq and Afghanistan, do we really have to go through this whole thing again? There will always be places for terrorists to plan out terrible attacks. We might reduce the chances of a terrorist attack occurring on our soil slightly at a costly price by intervening in Syria although the opposite affect is also a possibility and it can never be a flat out guarantee that it will definitely protect us from further terrorism. I also see the amount of civilian deaths increasing as a result of western intervention as it happened in Libya.
Original post by Aj12
Syria is fast becoming a hotbed of Islamic extremism and another country al Qaeda is starting to infiltrate. Fighters from Iraq Afghanistan Somalia and Yemen are entering the country to fight. If the West does nothing Syria will merely become like Yemen or Somalia or Afghanistan another country that al Qaeda can train and gather terrorists. People who say this does not affect us may feel differently when in a few years time terrorist attacks are being planned and launched from another failed state. The Middle East is one of the most strategically important areas of the world, everything that happens there affects us.


DW Bin Laden said don't bother targeting the UK.
Reply 22
Its not that .....

The country is run by alawi's and like 90% of Syria is alawi so most of them support bashar coz he's alawi too. That's even why Hezbollah supports them coz he's shia too. However the Sunnis living there get treated like crap so they started protesting. That's when the army weren't having any. If only you see the stuff they do to the people they catch (torture , castration, electrocution even little kids). There are other stories I heard from 2 uni students I know that went there with a charity ..

All in all bashar won't stop till he secures his country again and the protesters won't stop either coz most of them have lost their homes and families . N there won't be a huge revolution coz there's only a small amount of them. And the west is only jumping in so that they can place a new ruler in charge , one they can control , coz if they really gave a **** about the dying ppl they'd would've stepped in long ago
Reply 23
Original post by fuze-mo25
Its not that .....

The country is run by alawi's and like 90% of Syria is alawi so most of them support bashar coz he's alawi too. That's even why Hezbollah supports them coz he's shia too. However the Sunnis living there get treated like crap so they started protesting. That's when the army weren't having any. If only you see the stuff they do to the people they catch (torture , castration, electrocution even little kids). There are other stories I heard from 2 uni students I know that went there with a charity ..

All in all bashar won't stop till he secures his country again and the protesters won't stop either coz most of them have lost their homes and families . N there won't be a huge revolution coz there's only a small amount of them. And the west is only jumping in so that they can place a new ruler in charge , one they can control , coz if they really gave a **** about the dying ppl they'd would've stepped in long ago


I'm confused as to what an Alawi is, I thought It was just a big family tree in Syria, or is it a sect of Islam? Since you say Hezbollah, who are Shia, support Assad, but I thought they only supported him because he supports them?
Original post by prog2djent
There are just so many sources and conflicting reports with syria, I hear all over various forums that most syrians actually support assad, but a minority of Syrian extremists have aligned themselves with mercenaries, syrian exiles, Lebanese terrorists, Egyptian terrorists, Iraqi mercenaries. But then we hear stories from opposition groups ... and our media, that Assad's army killed X amount of people, and that he has led the brutal crack down on the protests last year, but a Syrian Friend of mine on palchat tells me that destabalisation of syria is exactly what the US, Israel and the Arab League want.

As a disclaimer, the western media is clearly against Assad, and on a massive scale, this just SCREAMS to me that intervention is a-foot, it reminds me of the Iraq intervetion and "Weapons Of Mass Destruction".

I don't want to write a great tome on two sides of the story, so (because I'm often accused of not providing enough sources) I just seperate into this

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QSjGLhTyF9o - Pro Assad University Students in Aleppo
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NJK34FDnUVU - Syrian Pro Assad "reformation" doctors in the UK
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T-Ueb8g34rA - German-Syrians Pro Assad rally
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qn6Snf__nxY - Christians attacked by rebels (I know its RT, so there is a Bias)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1StSFCdZ7_4 - Pro assad syrian citizens
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7EWre9mRgcQ - Syrian-Turks, pro assad rally
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d7zFUaDOPCE - Huge pro-assad rally in capital
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_wLfxgMPKYA - Triploi, Lebannon, pro assad rally
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JRgvI7VFNzM - Pro Assad, anti-arab league demo
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mOBfZT-Z69I - Pro Assad demo in Holland
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JwjgatyzN5w - Pro Assad Supporter on a plane!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W9dQkUFnEMw&feature=results_video&playnext=1&list=PL75F56A4D10AB788E
- Syrian-Australians, Pro assad march - sydney

Have a channel, http://www.youtube.com/user/ProBasharRallysWorld/videos, pro assad rally's and marhes from Denmark, Sweden, France, South America, Cyprus and various other Countries/cities.

There are hundreds and hundreds of videos of pro-assad rallies in Aleppo and
Damascus where tens of thousands attend.

http://www.youtube.com/user/SyriaTruthNetworkEN/videos, channel exposing Rebels faking deaths, killing civilians, killing alleged pro-assad civilians,

http://www.youtube.com/user/TimeToFightBack1 the "Free Syrian army", terrorists, Lebanese Militants and Mercenaries killing various civilians and those that are even part of the FSA, who dare to criticise them.

Christians tagetted by Islamist Rebels

http://barnabasfund.org/Christians-in-Syria-targeted-in-series-of-kidnappings-and-killings-100-dead.html
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/2848301/posts
http://www.catholicfreepress.org/international/2012/03/10/christians-in-syria-live-in-fear-of-persecution-say-catholic-officials/

http://www.bbc.co.uk/newsbeat/17425759 - Interview with Assad supporters in London

Hell, even Hezbollah is pro Assad http://worldblog.msnbc.msn.com/_news/2012/03/17/10722017-why-is-the-resistance-group-hezbollah-standing-beside-syrias-dictator?lite
http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/news/michaelweiss/100134187/hezbollah-launched-rockets-into-syria-says-free-syrian-army/

There are also tens of other sources linking Al-Qaeda and affiliated groups who have joined with the FSA.

Anyway, I get the impression that there are two sides to the story. One is that Syria is/was the most liberal Arabic nation, but Islamist Militants and various extremists groups have used the arab spring as an opportunity to throw a relatively liberal dictatorship over and install an islamist - muslim brotherhood presence in syrian politics/society, ala Egypt and Libya. The US, Israel, Nato and western media portray Assad as an evil boogey man since destabalisting muslims nations approaching liberalism has been a common trait through out the 20th century.

I fear this will be Afghanistan all over again too, Assad is backed by Russia, the rebels are/will be backed by the west, a **** load of **** happens and the nation falls into less than savoury hands.


The whole thing started with members of Assad's regime torturing and killing children who wrote anti-regime graffiti. That's when people started protesting.
I don't know if your right, but the fact the west is doing next to nothing shows that they could be waiting till total collapse till the come in and look like the 'saviours'...I found it particularly ignorant for America to say 'this might be a civil war' on a few months ago...
I think people need to see that many innocents are being killed, (if you really want to see a video that's anti assad there's one floating around of a teen who got his lower jaw shot off...really makes you wonder how these soldiers are pulling the trigger in youngsters...and what they think wil be solved by it.
Original post by fuze-mo25
Its not that .....

The country is run by alawi's and like 90% of Syria is alawi so most of them support bashar coz he's alawi too. That's even why Hezbollah supports them coz he's shia too. However the Sunnis living there get treated like crap so they started protesting. That's when the army weren't having any. If only you see the stuff they do to the people they catch (torture , castration, electrocution even little kids). There are other stories I heard from 2 uni students I know that went there with a charity ..

All in all bashar won't stop till he secures his country again and the protesters won't stop either coz most of them have lost their homes and families . N there won't be a huge revolution coz there's only a small amount of them. And the west is only jumping in so that they can place a new ruler in charge , one they can control , coz if they really gave a **** about the dying ppl they'd would've stepped in long ago


Syria is 90% Alawi???????????????
Original post by Carecup
My view of it is that it started off as most peaceful demonstrations that Assad put down with force, which in turn gave birth to the rebel and terrorist groups. There is no doubt in my mind that at this point both sides are as bad as each other.


No doubt? Really?
Original post by Aj12
Syria is fast becoming a hotbed of Islamic extremism and another country al Qaeda is starting to infiltrate. Fighters from Iraq Afghanistan Somalia and Yemen are entering the country to fight. If the West does nothing Syria will merely become like Yemen or Somalia or Afghanistan another country that al Qaeda can train and gather terrorists. People who say this does not affect us may feel differently when in a few years time terrorist attacks are being planned and launched from another failed state. The Middle East is one of the most strategically important areas of the world, everything that happens there affects us.


These rebels are the currently the most pro-western militants that have come out of the middle east. Trying to include Al Qaeda into the mix is a bit of Orientalist thinking. The rebels are outright against Al Qaeda, often because their own relatives have been killed by such terrorists. What we will see however, is the influx of jihadis (not Al Qaeda but Islamist fighters) to counter the support coming from Iran. The Arab League hate Assad and are already secretly funnelling weapons to the rebels which is good but more needs to be done. The Western nations are dilly-dallying because they don't think the SNC are truly representative of the rebels/Syrians and want a more authoritative body to negotiate with. That ain't gonna happen when people are getting massacred. These things get sorted after massacres/uprisings not during them.
Reply 29
Original post by fuze-mo25
Its not that .....

The country is run by alawi's and like 90% of Syria is alawi so most of them support bashar coz he's alawi too. That's even why Hezbollah supports them coz he's shia too. However the Sunnis living there get treated like crap so they started protesting. That's when the army weren't having any. If only you see the stuff they do to the people they catch (torture , castration, electrocution even little kids). There are other stories I heard from 2 uni students I know that went there with a charity ..

All in all bashar won't stop till he secures his country again and the protesters won't stop either coz most of them have lost their homes and families . N there won't be a huge revolution coz there's only a small amount of them. And the west is only jumping in so that they can place a new ruler in charge , one they can control , coz if they really gave a **** about the dying ppl they'd would've stepped in long ago


Where on earth did you get the idea of 90% of Syria is Alawi?? The Alawites are about 10% of the population, concentrated in Syria's northwest. This is much more even sided than you think. I often see the figure of 30% militantly pro-regime (Alawites and Christians largely I believe), 30% militantly-anti regime and 40% in the middle. Assad really only has the support of the Alawites + Christians who fear Islamism. The majority of Syrians are apathetic or totally opposed.
Original post by prog2djent
I don't know where I sit with Syria

About 2300 miles away.
Reply 31
Original post by prog2djent
I'm confused as to what an Alawi is, I thought It was just a big family tree in Syria, or is it a sect of Islam? Since you say Hezbollah, who are Shia, support Assad, but I thought they only supported him because he supports them?


alawis are a tribe but then they have their own religious beleifs similar to that of shias and then they also ate close to Hezbollah and iran
Reply 32
Original post by 12lightf
Where on earth did you get the idea of 90% of Syria is Alawi?? The Alawites are about 10% of the population, concentrated in Syria's northwest. This is much more even sided than you think. I often see the figure of 30% militantly pro-regime (Alawites and Christians largely I believe), 30% militantly-anti regime and 40% in the middle. Assad really only has the support of the Alawites + Christians who fear Islamism. The majority of Syrians are apathetic or totally opposed.


trust me its much more than 10% ... And plus they also rule the country ... And occupy the highest positions in government
Reply 33
who are u to say that because u live in britain u deserve a good life but if ur in a country where u are killed for having a opinion u don't deserve to have an opinion. were human they are human we have feeling and family so do they what is wrong with them that they don't deserve to have freedom or the right to live??? .

sorry not aimed at everyone just those who are saying its not my problem.
Original post by Aj12
Syria is fast becoming a hotbed of Islamic extremism and another country al Qaeda is starting to infiltrate. Fighters from Iraq Afghanistan Somalia and Yemen are entering the country to fight. If the West does nothing Syria will merely become like Yemen or Somalia or Afghanistan another country that al Qaeda can train and gather terrorists. People who say this does not affect us may feel differently when in a few years time terrorist attacks are being planned and launched from another failed state. The Middle East is one of the most strategically important areas of the world, everything that happens there affects us.


And if the we do something all that will happen is the propaganda officers within the extremist groups will use all the collateral damage and dead civilians to rally more support in the middle east and within Europe. If we go in all that will happen is accusations that we are being evil imperialist monsters trying to exploit the poor Syrian people (will probably say for oil) and thanks to tricks they probably learned in places like Afghanistan and Palestine extremist groups know all to well how effective putting a military target in the middle of a civilian population can be. Wait for us to blow it up and then post youtube videos cradling all the dead kids screaming "why god why", works like an absolute charm and before you know it you have a huge increase in support not just from the middle east but from people within our own country. At the end of the day groups like Al-Queda will have just as much support, if not more and all we will have is a bunch of coffins with flags draped across and a bill we don't need.
Reply 35
Original post by Brutal Honesty
These rebels are the currently the most pro-western militants that have come out of the middle east. Trying to include Al Qaeda into the mix is a bit of Orientalist thinking. The rebels are outright against Al Qaeda, often because their own relatives have been killed by such terrorists. What we will see however, is the influx of jihadis (not Al Qaeda but Islamist fighters) to counter the support coming from Iran. The Arab League hate Assad and are already secretly funnelling weapons to the rebels which is good but more needs to be done. The Western nations are dilly-dallying because they don't think the SNC are truly representative of the rebels/Syrians and want a more authoritative body to negotiate with. That ain't gonna happen when people are getting massacred. These things get sorted after massacres/uprisings not during them.


http://www.aljazeera.com/news/middleeast/2012/02/201221794018300979.html
http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-202_162-57376121/al-qaeda-urges-muslims-to-help-syria-rebels/

I think its a bit much to claim they are outright against al Qaeda. The rebels are too fragmented to really be for or against anything apart from the Assad regime. There are huge divisions on tactics as well as what each group wants to do with Syria if they are successful
[video="youtube;ChZ0-W3A2RA"]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ChZ0-W3A2RA[/video]
Original post by Aj12
http://www.aljazeera.com/news/middleeast/2012/02/201221794018300979.html
http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-202_162-57376121/al-qaeda-urges-muslims-to-help-syria-rebels/

I think its a bit much to claim they are outright against al Qaeda. The rebels are too fragmented to really be for or against anything apart from the Assad regime. There are huge divisions on tactics as well as what each group wants to do with Syria if they are successful


Al Qaeda always do this, whenever Muslims are getting slaughtered they urge jihadis to go and defend them, same was true in Libya as well. However, your links speculate that foreign jihadis may be allied to Al Qaeda but this is based on their own propaganda. Currently most of the foreigners/terrorists involved in Syria are backing Assad, Hezbollah and members of the IRGC. Syria's rebels so far have gone out of their way to protect western journalists, reporters entering conflict areas have relied exclusively on the rebels for support/access and the FSA have been in close talks with NATO countries (more recently as the FoS conference).

Currently there doesn't seem to be much in the form of resistance against Assad except for the FSA and ad hoc armed locals who are defending their town. The explosions/suicide bombings which have occurred seem to have been orchestrated by Assad to try and discredit the FSA and link them with Al Qaeda.
Reply 38
Original post by fuze-mo25
trust me its much more than 10% ... And plus they also rule the country ... And occupy the highest positions in government


What reason do you have for thinking it's 'much more than 10%'? Wikipedia (yeah I know) seems to agree with me. 11% Alawite, concentrated around Latakia in the north (interestingly, an early locus of the uprising, according to 'Religion in Syria'. I know Alawites rule the country. The Assad clan is Alawite. That doesn't dictate that they are a majority and, ergo, the country is against the uprising.
Reply 39
I'm Lebanese, Sunni, hear me out.
I don't have Internet at the mo so I cannot fully contribute to this but I will try my best over my mobile.

This whole saga dates back far longer than just Bashar Al Assad, his father Hafez Al Assad was just as bad.

There has always been a large percentage of Syrians who hated Assads tyrant regime. A lot of them emigrated to Sunni-friendly places like Tripoli, Lebanon. Sayda, Lebanon and others also emigrated to Jordan. Reason being is because Sunnis - who are the majority of Syrians - always have been treated like utter dog poop. It is permitted in the Alawi/Shia religion that "the killing of Sunnnis is halal" since they are the supposed special ones.

The Assad regime(s) always have been mass murdering tyrant ones since day 1. 40,000 massacred in Hama for example. Thousands of Lebanese people were killed for no reason during the Syrian occupation of Lebanon. Tens of thousands of Lebanese people are trapped in Syrian jails as we speak.

Syria, Iran & Hezbollah all come from the same toilet America & Israel do.
Assad always goes on and on about how Syria are anti-Israeli. Well, when was the last time a Syrian bullet was fired at Israel & when was the last time a Syrian bullet was aimed at Syrians & Lebanese people?
Let's not forget Hafez sold the Golan Heights to Israel.

If America really wanted Assad to step down then they would've done something about him ages ago. Saddam, Mubarak & Gaddafi went under the "American" treatment, enjoyed it and after they were no longer needed, they were taken care of.
Syria is a massive obstacle in the middle east, why do something about Assad when he's demolishing it for them?

I really want to go into more detail but I can't over the mobile. Point is, I know tons of Syrians who hate Assads guts out. The only ones who like him are the Alawites & a minority of Christians. Then you get the majority who strongly dislike him but can't speak out because THIS would happen to them.
Whenever I talk to my Syrian mates whether it's Internet/fb or over the phone we can't mention anything about Assad because it's all recorded and they will get in trouble.
The fact that if u are found with a copy of COD4 in Syria you go to jail sums it all up really..

The Lebanese lived through years of being tortured by Assads rad3 army... all animals who used to fire their guns at us for fun.
The regime needs to be taken down otherwise Syria will crumble.
Syria crumbling will strongly affect countries like Lebanon.
A week ago there was over 2 weeks of street fighting between Sunni fighters and Syrian Alawi fighters in northern Lebanon. The man hates Sunnis, Wcyd?

There are also many videos on YouTube interviewing Syrian Alawites who repeatedly say they worship "Assad before Allah". That should sum them up...




This was posted from The Student Room's iPhone/iPad App

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending