The accommodation offerred by the acommodation service is typically overpriced and basic and and, for about everyone, adequate and sometimes a little better, some of the flats being basically coolish and suited to cat like living. Or not, you may find they are just basic and adequate.
By comparison the accommodation offered in the rental market place in the city of Edinburgh which is taken by students is typically quite nice or either cosy, spacious, or pleasant at least and quite some beter than adequate.
It is most common for market let flats to be without a living room or with this room used as a bedroom, though to have a kitchen which is spacious enough, maybe just, for living in, with T.V. stereo and chairs at the table for lounging, or extra more comfortable chairs. I think all of the university's flats, with very, very few exceptions, have no living room.
There is nothing else to say about the university flats except that they are usually made up of typical, basic bits of living space, never bad, but most often not really inspiring, with fluffy, strange coloured lino squares on the floor. The only other thing to say is that there are a few places, like the student flats in Warrender Park Road or Terrace or something in Marchment, I can't remember which, which are in a converted school building have large foyer coridors which sometimes get noisy and students have parties in them. Elsewhere like at the flats at Sciennes and New Arthur Place, there may be some noise of students coming in and out at night especially in the coridor, but the coridors are not large or pleasant enough for most people to stay around in.
The halls rooms are fine. I liked them. They are smaller than many and bigger than some, but typical and otherwise sympathetically plain and conducive of relaxing. But the rooms are close to the same size of the smallest B&B single room you have ever stayed in and it would be for nearly nine months as a full adult, though it is easy to move out to a room in a nice flat with people you have never met before. (Rather than friends you meet which is always a decent idea.) The student rooms in shared student city market flats are advertised constantly in the halls and all over the place.
As the university was no good at all though, halls were a headache regarding working. I could hardly do any, sometimes even the basic requirements. After a while it felt like communism and I wanted, need like you need air, very much to be independent of the company regarding my living arrangements.